Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Trimming Bowl Blanks

Posts

Trimming Bowl Blanks

#1

Trimming Bowl Blanks

Steve in NC

>A few weeks ago, a friend gave me several logs, Sugar Maple I beleive, 14-18 inches in diameter. I ripped them in half with the chain saw but they would not fit under my band saw to trim into round blanks. Rather than fire up the chain saw on a early Sunday morning, I remembered that I had purchsed (but never used) some "pruning" blades for my Milwaukee Sawzall several several months ago. I put in one of the blades and while a rather slow process it worked out just fine to trim the blank.

I had tried the Sawzall before with a standard wood cutting blade with poor results. (The blade was too flexible.) These pruning blades are much stiffer with a very aggresive tooth pattern. Would not want to make a habit of it but it sure helped in a pinch.

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#2

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

GaryG in MD

>Steve, An inexpensive electric chain saw is a much better solution. Many of us use them. ...Gary

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I trim my logs with a little electric chain saw and then mount them as rough pieces even if they are particularly out of round. It seems to be quicker than trying to hold an unruly piece of wood whilst chainsawing.

Regards, Peter.

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

Dick Hines

>I trim the corners off my bowl blanks with a bowl gouge. Just put the blank between centers and go to it.

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#5

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

John K Jordan

>>...I trim the corners off my bowl blanks with a bowl gouge.

Did you try trimming the corners off with a chain saw while the blank is spinning on the lathe?

JKJ

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

Dick Hines

>I'm not that brave John. I can't seem myself useing a chain saw on a spinning piece of wood.

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#7

John, I did that ... just once... :)

Allen Neighbors

>and just enough to know it wasn't a very good idea. :) Pretty spicy!

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#8

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

robo hippy

>When ripping the logs in half, try cutting the top and the bottom of the blank at the same time. I use plywood strips from 1 to 8 inches (on half inch increments) to mark the log, then cut most of the way through. This is usually 3 cuts on a log that small, one down the center, and one on each outside part of the log. Turn it over and cut the rest of the way through. If you are good with a chainsaw, this gives you parallel top and bottom, and a flat surface for rounding off on a bandsaw, or for laying on a cutting block and lopping off the corners with the chainsaw. I believe I got this from Bill Grumbine. An electric chainsaw works, or get a BIG bandsaw.

robo hippy

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#9

Steven Antonucci

Not with the lathe spinning!

steve antonucci

>I have run a gas powered chainsaw in my garage (generally, a bad idea) with the door open to trim up a blank that was too out of balance. Lock the headstock, cut. rotate. lock. cut...etc.

But even I'm not crazy enough to stick a running chainsaw on a spinning blank! When a man with a chainsaw meets a running lathe, that man is known as "old one ear".

Steven

Hoping this is an April Fools joke...

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#10

Stupid stuff I tried.......

Barry Irby

>I used my power plane to trim a few blanks. With it on the lathe, but not with the lathe running. I would put the blank on and use the plane to knock off the high points. Actually that worked fairly well, but seems tough on the planer blades.

Then I got the idea that I could hold the router up to the tool rest with a large straight bit in it and a collar to allow it to rest on the rest. Holding the large three horse power router with one hand, I turned the blank over and into the cutter with the other hand. Not sure exactly when it went bad or precicesly what happened, but a few seconds alter when the excitement died down, I had a big notch in the tool rest and a ruined router bit. I was thinking that this might make a slick way to quickly true up blanks and that this was a "proof of concept". If it worked, I was going to make some sort of holder for the router. I visualized slowly spinning the blank and moving the router closer while it was held in a bracket. Strangely, I have not pursued the idea.

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#11

Re: It never fails to amaze me ....

Steve in NC

>where some of these threads end up. Sounds like there are some candidates for the Darwin awards.

Steve

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#12

Re: Stupid stuff I tried.......

Ed in Leaside

>Works for me on spindles, but I've never tried it on a bowl. This pic is of a trim router, swinging a 1 7/8" modified slot cutter, with the cut depth limited by the pattern follower (blanked out).


img

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#13

Come on Ed...

Steven Kubien

>...that's not a spindle. That's a skull-bashing instrument of fine precision happening there (well, in some people's hands. In mine, it's just a basher).

Man, I have got to come by your shop some day....

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#14

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

jim Miles - Charlotte NC

>When I have a big blank that is really out of round I have held a magic marker on the tool rest to get a reasonably close circle marked on the face side of the bowl blank, then go to work on it while mounted on the lathe with electic chain saw ( NOT TURNING ) use the tool rest away from saw area to hold it still for cutting.

A easier than chasing a bouncing lathe around the shop!

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#15

unconventional rounding

John K Jordan

>>...then go to work on it while mounted on the lathe with electic chain saw ( NOT TURNING )

This is what I wondered. I have trimmed large irregular blanks with a bowl gouge and it was unpleasant. Besides the unbalanced issues and the stresses on the bearings of even large lathes, a very sharp gouge takes a pounding on hard, dry chunks of wood. It seems to me that some POWERED means of reducing the chunk to a round would be preferable, whether bandsaw, router, reciprocal or other powered cutter.

I once watched a woodcarver attack a log with an angle grinder with rotary chain saw disk as the cutting edge. Large amounts of wood were removed quickly. It seems to me it would make more sense to use something like that mounted on a rest or jig somehow where it could be controlled, and cutting against a blank turned very slow (i.e., by hand).

I think I'll pick up a Merlin with a chain disk the next time I go to Woodcraft and give it a try.

BTW, rather than a gouge, I usually use an unconventional tool to rough out large spindle squares or bowl blanks which works surprisingly well. It's a sharply pointed spear-point scraper. The sharp point removes wood more rapidly and with far less force and stress than a large gouge. Except on end grain, the surface is not left smooth but this is unimportant. This is also my tool of choice when hollowing end grain for boxes and goblets - I remove most of the wood with the spear-point before I switch to other tools for smoothing. I think there is a good reason automated machines like duplicators sometimes use a single sharp point to remove wood.

JKJ

Re: Trimming Bowl Blanks

#16

In my hands ...

Ed in Leaside

>..., seeing as how I don't practice the art, it's just a stick. Hopefully perfectly straight, or perfectly tapered, and perfectly balanced ... but still just a stick. ;-)

I'm sure we'll meet one of these days.

Ed