Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Posts

Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#1

Turning A Familiar - Challenging

charlie belden

>Hollow forms, lidded boxes, plates, platters and vases - they give you a lot of leeway - there is no commonly recognized image of any of them. But turn a very familiar shape and what initially seems easy - ain't.

Easter - Easter Egg. What could be easier? Two curves - that's it. A spindle gouge or a skew -either or both will do the job.

Then I turned one. Close - but no cigar.

Turned another one. A flat area between the two curves - that wasn't noticed 'til the attempt was held up between thumb and forefinger - the acccepted way of holding an egg for viewing.

Turned another one - this one with what later was recognizable as having a "bullet shaped" top.

Turned another one - and it looked sort of like a football - or more like a rugby ball.

They all looked eggish - on the lathe. But when parted off and held using the approved Thumb and Forefinger method - THAT ain't egg shaped!

Other than a sphere, the egg shape is probably the next most recognizable "organic" form (as opposed to cubes, pyramids and the like). And because everyone on the planet knows what an egg actually looks like - they can notice, and often be irritated, when a shape that's almost egg shaped is NOT egg shaped.

But you're probably thinking "A hemisphere on one end and a bullet shape on the other - what's the problem?"

That's not a hemisphere nor is that a bullet shape -more like parabolas or more likely catenary (sp?) curves (the ones formed when you hold a piece of string on both ends and move your hands towards or away from each other - the ones used by skateboard ramp builders).

So turning a "simple" egg shape isn't all that simple. And it sure is great for learning to see and cut fair curves that blend into each other. And if that gets boring try an egg shaped lidded box. And just to make it interesting, turn them using just a skew.

Anyone come up with a use for ALMOST egg shaped turnings?

Fun this wood turning thing.

charlie belden

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#2

Steven Antonucci

Been there, still haven't come up with a way

steve antonucci

>But I have managed one "good egg".

Keep trying.

Steven

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#3

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Molly Winton

>Ah Charlie, I feel your pain. I have yet to master this elusive form. It's a complete exercise in frustration for me.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#4

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Ron in Drums PA

>One of the problems in turning "eggs" is we think we know how they are suppose to look.

Go out and buy a couple of dozen eggs and take a look at them, you'll find that they vary in shape. You may even find one that looks like your egg.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#5

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Darylee

>True depends on breed of bird (not just chicken) and what they have been eating...sea turtle eggs are almost round.

I bet nobody says anyting and if they do, just be prepared to tell them it's spring layed polehen's egg....or how about a turner's hen egg.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Mike Stafford

>Charlie, I also learned that this simple shape is much more challenging than I thought when I first tried to turn a box in the shape of an egg. I think I turned more than 10 before I turned one that finally looked like an egg and functioned as a box.

It has been a while since I turned an egg box so I think I will put that on my list to do this Spring. Maybe I can beat the Easter Bunny with a nice turned egg box full of.......

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#7

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

charlie belden

>While it's certainly true that there are different proportions for eggs, and we're talking about birds eggs specifically - have never seen a dyed lizard or turtle egg Easter Egg and they don't show up in grocery stores often. But while birds eggs may have a range of sizes and proportions, EVERYONE can immediately recognize Egg Shaped. And while the proportions may vary the Two Curves are immediately discernable from their cousins the hemisphere, the tapered cone, the parabolic.

If you turn a plate, bowl, cup or vase, and it deforms a little it's recognized as what it is and more leeway is given when determining that it IS NOT a plate, bowl, cup or vase. But with an egg shape, it's egg shaped or not and folks will comment when it's not.

Years back I did a bunch of plywood lawn figures for the neighborhood kids. I made Halloween characters - 8 foot Frankenstien, five foot witch - with cauldron, drooling wolf, tombstones, etc. NO ONE, not even a kid (they're very up front with their opinions) ever said "That doesn't look like ________" But do a Santa Claus - and oh boy will you get feedback - "his cheeks are too red", "he's too skinny/fat", "his cap doesn't look like THAT", "his nose is too long/short/round/pointy", . . .

When it comes to turned objects eggs seemed to have the most restrictive criteria of what is and what isn't "right". And there's nowhere to hide a mistake. Eggs don't have coves or beads or V grooves to disquise flat areas or a curve that tightens too quickly - an error or almost minute proportions stands out like the proverbial sore thumb. Which is why I'm probably going to play with The Egg for a while.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#8

Well, If that's the way you feel about it!!!!

Ron in Drums PA

>All you need to do is Practice, Practice, Practice!!!!

After about 300 or so eggs, you should have it done pat.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kglcgy6TgxU

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#9

"Perfect" eggs and Real eggs

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The "perfect" egg shape is a human concept. Chickens don't understand it and wouldn't care if they did.

Chickens lay real eggs. Some might go further and say that real eggs are also perfect eggs.

As Ron suggested, buy a couple of cartons of eggs. Each egg has its own shape, and each shape is a real egg shape.

The "perfect" egg shape only occurs in plastic easter eggs.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#11

The Funniest thing I've ever seen........

Barry Irby

>at a turning club meeting......

In the local club, we have a member that is a master of the skew. Truly. A joy to watch the magic when he waves that wand around. (Hold that thought)

The club had a demonstrator come in and show us how to turn an egg. The guy had chucks and jamb chucks, and templates, and blanks and....

He spent over an hour showing us that he chucked a small blank about 1 1/2" square by four inches. He turned it round and then VERY carefully turned the "Hemisphere" on the outboard end, Carefully matching it to his template. Then he mounted and trued his jamb chuck and, After sanding the round end, he jambed it and brought up the tail stock. Then he meticulously turned the "pointy" end and sanding it before parting it off. He was enormously proud and said that when he was set up and really moving he could do more than an egg an hour. Nice round of applause and thank you's all around.

In the confusion that was the start of the clean up, the fellow who knows which end of the skew to point at the wood walked up and asked if he could show the demonstrator how he did it? Could he use a leftover blank? Yes, of course. He chucked the blank, with a skew, turned it round and said, Now I turn a dome on this end, and did it. Then he said now I turn the other end like this... and did it. He explained that if you did the right cut, you did not really need to sand, but you could. Then he reached out with one hand and parted the egg off with the skew and caught it in the other. He sanded the little tip by hand and said, "There, I can turn an egg a minute." The look on the demonstrator's face was worth the price of admission. The whole thing was so quick I doubt anyone else saw it.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#12

Re: The Funniest thing I've ever seen........

john lucas

>My friend Randy Trentham turns an egg in a minute, usually at the end of his fruit turning demo. He worked in Pidgeon Forge Tennessee with his dad and turned thousands of those.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#13

13 pages on turning an egg?!?

Craig Daymon

>Wow! When I get the itch to turn with not much time to do it, I grab a piece of scrap and turn an egg. For the most part, they look like eggs, though the more pointed end tends to be a bit too pointy. So I guess I need more practice.

But 13 pages? Wow. I never thought someone could put that much thought into it. I'll read it, but I won't print it. That way there will be one more tree left to use for turning.

Thanks for the article.

-Craig

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#14

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

Texian

>Fun post Charlie! My two-piece hollow egg looks a lot like an acorn without the cap.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#15

I've turned dozens... :)....

Allen Neighbors

>Charlie, I went to the kitchen, opened the fridge, took out an egg, carried it to my shop, and turned one to match.

It's now on top of the knob that removes the upper belt cover on my lathe. Handy to look at, and easy to copy. :)

BTW... there are no perfect eggs. Just ask a chicken. :)

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#16

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

charlie belden

>it's true that practice,while not necessarily making you perfect at something, will sure as hell make you a lot better at it. That certainly was my experience with using a skew. Probably around my 50th finial I got the hang of it. Putting a curve on the cutting edge didn't hurt either. Hopefully I'll get this egg shape down a little sooner than that. But it doesn't hurt to cheat a little by turning a pedestal for one.

So here's Egg Box #1. Walls are a little thick but that's because I wasn't sure of what chucking sequence would work so I left a little extra meat. Next one will have walls a little closer to "egg shell" thickness - if you think in terms of ostrich egg shell thickness.

This one will go to Sarah, the provacateur who "persuaded" me (Oh please, please. PLEASE make me an egg! ) to turn her ONE egg. Kids are great inspirers. especially this particular kid. When I think Optimist I think of Sarah. Put her in a room full of horse manure and she'll gleefully begin searching for the pony that just has to be in there somewhere.

This is one of the many reasons I take big pieces of wood and turn them into little pieces of wood. The smile on Sarah's face - priceless


img

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#17

LOL - Thanks for sharing that

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#18

Hollow Egg *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>Every time a thread starts regarding eggs I end up going back and viewing this video by Larry Marley.


Hollow Egg

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#19

Re: Not just hen's eggs *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

>A good approach to take is to turn an "egg", then go to a web site that shows a selection of eggs and choose which one yours looks like, then claim you made, for eggsample, a murre egg, deliberately.


Royal Albert Museum: Eggs

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#20

Re: Hollow Egg

charlie belden

>GREAT VIDEO! Thanks. The "cracking" the egg and frying pan was a nice finale.

As is the case with most turnings, the fun and games is how to hold the piece at each step of the process. And, as a relative newbie, I trap myself by thinking only in terms of "between centers" or "one end in the chuck". To a large extent that's because of my other newbie bias - don't waste wood. The idea of USING some of the wood for a jam chuck violates Don't Waste Wood and is foolishly ruled out.

So that means "between centers" to create tenons on both ends of the blank for holding the top and bottom parts for hollowing and roughing the shape while still between centers.

But, that procedure means that the top of the top and the bottom of the bottom are shaped to the point of parting off - which - leaves a point top and bottom - exactly what you don't want - points.

The jam chuck allows you to work on the ends, solving the "point" problem the newbie approach wolefully doesn't permit.

I enjoy thinking "outside the box" when it comes to ideas for turnings. I'll try all sorts of things, some wild ass dead ends, but still interesting. BUT - when it comes to holding the parts my vision narrows to "between centers" or "one end in the scroll chuck" - in no small part dues to the newbie Don't Waste Wood fallacy.

But even if 95% of what I start with ends up on the floor (and in my shirt, in my pockets and some even in my shorts) AND I end up with the piece I either envisioned before turning on the lathe, or which presented itself during the turning - NOTHING was wasted.

That change in mindset may be one of the significant milestones on this turning journey. I'll keep turning right along and eventually I'll pass that important milestone.

So much to learn. So little wood. So many shavings.

Fun this turning thing.

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#21

Re: I've turned hundreds of perfect eggs

Arch

>....and I'm getting fed up with Fabrege's hired hens plagiarizing my perfect eggs. They never get it right anyway. (don't know if there will be any chicks. Tried to candle some of my eggs, but fried them instead).

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

#22

Re: Turning A Familiar - Challenging

michael serpa

>First find an egg that you like, empty it and keep it in front of your lathe when turn. Start at the tailstock end and turn the 'fat' end ( it's a hemisphere ) and work your way to the 'pointy' end. Keep your eye on the real one. Practise makes perfect.


img