Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Vacuum Chuck.....

Posts

Vacuum Chuck.....

#1

Vacuum Chuck.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'm planning on a vacuum chuck for my new lathe. Does anyone have any experience with the Holdfast vacuum chuck system? It hooks up to a shop air compressor. Since I recently got a new compressor that makes about half as much noise as my old one did, I'm wondering if that might be a good way to go.

Wally

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#2

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

Pete in Holland, MI

>Vacuum generators draw a lot of compressed air to operate. We use them here at work in numerous places where a vacuum pump isn't practical.

Check the CFM requirments of the generator verses the capacity of your compressor & figure out how much it will need to be running to keep up with the generator.

Not sure on your compressor, but dry-sump compressors need rest time between cycles to cool off, else they'll melt out the seals.

My advice is to look for an electric pump.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

Richard Allen

>The Oneway system is excellent and of course expensive. The Oneway pump is expensive and the drum chucks are expensive. But they are also foolproof and you can be sure that the Oneway system will work effortlessly like all Oneway products.

You can make your own drums and you can get cheaper pumps. The Oneway adapter works great but if you have a hand wheel you will need to remove it to use the Oneway vacuum adapter. The easy-vac adapter can be used with the hand wheel attached as long as you have a hole in the center of your hand wheel.

Personaly I use a cheap pump and vacuum gauge from service center (other post), The E-Z Vacuum Adaptor from packard, plumbing parts from the Borg, and drum chucks from Oneway. The system is very quiet and holds as well as any vacuum chuck.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#5

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

john lucas

>Wally Hopefully you will hear from someone who owns one. I asked about them a while back and got some favorable feedback. They apparently aren't air hogs like some of the other venturi style vacuum systems. I ended up buying a used vacuum pump made by ghast. It's noisy compared to the Oneway but seems to work fine.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#6

One way vaccum chucks

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Wally, I use the One way vacuum chucks with a vacuum pump and I am very pleased with the set up.

Jorge

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#7

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Hi Wally

Buy the right tool for the right job. I have an SPX Robinair cooltech model 15600. It is 1/2 hp, pulls 6cfm and will draw down to almost 28". At one time, on this site, someone was selling them reconditioned for about $ 85.00. I rigged this up with a filter and tubing to make my connections. I do have the Oneway vacuum adaptor but not their drum chucks.

You are sure welcome to drive up and look at mine.

I also made a 2 1/2 gal. vacuum pot out of a Harbour Freight paint pot.

Good turning and be safe

Bill

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#8

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

Mark Paulley

>Wally,

I got my Gasst pump at the Surplus Center for $89.00 and it works great. Soemone else has provided the link. The rest of the supplies, copper tubing and hose and such came from Lowes. Some of the turning catalogs sell a Gasst for approx $300. The difference between theirs and mine was some filters that were built into the pump. Other then that same HP, same amount of vaccuum, 220v. Hope this helps!

Mark

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#9

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

Larry Bisbee

>Note that the Vacuum Pump for $89.95 from the Surplus Center requirse a 220 Voltage and not 110.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#10

Gast is the way to go

Michael Nelson

>Wally, I got the Gast, 89$ and put it on the other side of the wall from my lathe, my wife's ceramic room, only the cats can fit in that room now. I use MDF glued together and craft foam with spray glue to make most any size vac chuck. Seal the MDF to keep air seepage down. I drill a hole a little smaller than my spindle and just thread it to the stop, works great.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#11

Thanks Everyone....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Just about everybody favors using a Gast pump. I guess that's the way I'll choose to go.

Wally

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#12

Re: in a hurry, Wally???

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Are you in a hurry, Wally?

I will be in Arizona from April 18 to April 27. I used to teach vacuum technology for woodworking. I have two vacuum systems in my shop, and I will be making a third for the lathe at some point.

So if you'd like a little experienced help, I'd be happy to trade building your system for another turning lesson or two. I may even have some spare parts I don't need and would donate to the project.

I could PM you a list of what you will need....

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#13

what advantage

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>I have no experience whatsover with a vacuum chucking system and I am curious about how you find advantage over other chucking systems??

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#14

Heck of a Deal......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Nope, I'm not in a hurry.

Wally

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#15

Re: Heck of a Deal......

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Great!

Want to carry out the "what you will need" conversation here on the forum or via private email?

BTW, If you have not already done this, go read the joewoodworker site. He has very good information and is a reasonably priced resource for some items. I know of other vendors but that involves some chasing around.

It will also give us a common usage of terms. ;)

Also, I have bunch of HDPE. It is totally non-porous, and machines easily with woodworking tools. Its kinda pricey if you have to buy it, but I have lots and you are welcome to what you need. It will be good for the bearing enclosure and the spindle adapter, unless you planned to buy a ready made one. With your turning skills we can easily make those parts, saving some bucks.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#16

Re: what advantage

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Certainly others will chime in here.

It is used to reverse chuck a turning to finish off the bottom. It is quick and easy. If you get a spindle thread to MT adapter for your tail stock, you simply slip that adapter into your tailstock. Thread on your faceplate or chuck. Slide the assembly to the vacuum chuck, turn on the vacuum, Then remove the chuck/faceplate and adapter from the turning and your piece will be perfectly centered. Takes less time to do it than to write about it!

There are probably other uses, but that is the one that comes to mind to this rookie turner. I do have lots of experience with vacuum clamping, though. :)

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#17

Re: what advantage

Bill Howatt

>As Carol said. Holds real well for most regular bowls and platters and easy to do.

It isn't all roses, if the wood is very porous or has knot-holes in it you can have a problem getting sufficient vacuum. Real small pieces, say less than 4" dia, are harder to hold because the amount of holding force depends on the evacuated area. If you elect to buy everything from a supplier like Oneway it can get expensive but you can make all the parts yourself including the rotating adapter and buy a surplus vacuum pump. You can also use the compressor from an old air-conditioner or dehumidifier as a pump but it will not be able to handle much leakage due to the lower pumping speed.

End-grain turnings don't usually mount very well because of the porosity of the thin end-grain.

Putting a coating of finish on the bottom of a porous piece will usually provide a better seal.

Now that I have a vacuum chuck I never bother with the other methods unless absolutely necessary. This means that it certainly isn't a necessity but it sure is convenient - another tool in the arsenal.

Bill

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#18

Also...

Bill Howatt

>Your lathe needs to have a spindle that has a hole bored completely through it and a thread on the outboard end, typically where a handwheel is located. This is needed to screw on the rotating vacuum adapter.

There are gizmos you can buy for lathes that have a solid spindle or no way of mounting an adapter on the outboard end. These add considerable cost to the setup though.

Bill

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#19

Re: Heck of a Deal......

Mike Nelson

>Carol, what is hdpe? I think I get the high density part, it sounds better than having to seal mdf.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#20

Re: Heck of a Deal......

Wilford Bickel

>I am not Carol but HDPE stands for High Density Polyethylene.

Re: Vacuum Chuck.....

#21

Re: Heck of a Deal......

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Wilford is right.