Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Question for the Pen Turners

Posts

Question for the Pen Turners

#1

Question for the Pen Turners

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

I've been mainly a bowl/hollow form turner with just a few experiments turning pens. The dozen or so pens I've done have turned out ok, but honestly, it was the kits I just wasn't happy with. The fit and finish was often hit or miss it seems and the click mechanisms were a bit spotty. They were all kits from Woodcraft purchased over the course of a year. Their twist pen (slimline) seems to work fine, it is the click ones I have trouble with.

However, I've gotten an offer for a order to make a few for someone and I thought I would ask here if anyone has a favorite pen kit supplier? I am specifically looking for the click pen types.

Thanks in advance!

Mike

Gotta find my pen stuff in Apex, NC!!

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#2

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

eaglesc

>The "Sierra" click has been receiving good reports though I am not fond of the mismatched fittings.(Beads and cut design)

Traditionally click pens don't get good reviews from pen turners though the few I have made (Button click Berea and the Power Point PSI Gel Writer Pro PSI) have worked well with no problems.

Some people have posted they had trouble with mechanisms failing, to date I have not.

One of the bigger issues is I don't believe anyone is offereing click pens with better platings.

Click pens are normally considered a disposable item by the general public.They can buy a click pen for a buck at Wally World.

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#3

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

Rick Davenport

>I've tried most of the suppliers and prefer Berea Hardwoods.

They cost just a bit more, but you get what you pay for.

And I believe their plating is superior.

R

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#4

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Mike!

Eagle hit it on the head! The Sierra click has been getting good reviews. Click pen kits have generally not been worth messing with for a while, but this Sierra and the PSI gel seem to be better.

As for recommending Berea, well, yes they make very good pen kits. But for the most part, the kits you buy at Woodcraft ARE Berea kits, as are the ones at Arizona Silhouette and Bear tooth Woods. The Sierra click mentioned by Eagle is a Berea kit - at Woodcraft it is called the Wall Street II Click.

Good Luck!

Scott.

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#5

Ditto...Woodcraft = Berea; size is the issue

Joe Pack

>Almost every problem I have had with a click pen, regardless of style, has been in the sizing of the blank. These are extremely length sensitive. If they say 2 13/16, they mean exactly that. In this case, size DOES matter! Once I figured this out with the help of Larry at Berea (now retired, unfortunately) my problems disappeared...except for the occassional small smidgeon of glue in the barrel I might have missed.

As for wear, the gold in any brand will wear. Unless I can get titanium for a good price (all my pens are sold at shows, and my customers have a price point they won't go over, it seems), I use chrome. The chrome sells as well as the gold, and it will last almost forever.

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#6

Thanks!

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

Thanks for the responses. I like the look of the Sierra pens so will give them a try. I've got a few more of the Woodcraft kits and will try them again, being extra careful with the length.

Thanks again,

Mike

No shop time today in Apex, NC...

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

#7

Re: Question for the Pen Turners

Sam Scalzo

>Hi,

I have made several hundred pens. Most of them were the twist but I just started making the Wall Street II click. Purchased fgrom Woodcraft. I think it is one of the best so far. Give it a try.

Sam in Arizona