Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

finials

Posts

finials

#1

finials

john lucas

>My best client wanted me to turn 16 of these finials that I designed for him. He is going to put them upside down hanging from the beams in his ceiling. Unfortunately the wood he brought me is terrible. It's pine and tears out very easily. Half of the logs are still green at least half way through and have large radial cracks in them.

The one on the right has a large check in the back and the top broke off while turning. I chose this one as the prototype because I knew it wouldn't be saveable. I don't think I can get 16 good ones from the wood he left me.

The one on the left was the dryest log and it has some small surface checking. I hate to tell him I can't turn them from this wood but it's just plain lousy. I think the guy that sold it to him also ripped him off because it definitly isn't dry and based on the radial checks I think it was dryed incorrectly.

These are 11" tall and 5 1/2" in diameter.


img

Re: finials

#2

Re: finials

Dennis Yoder

>Better to let him know up front than try to explain when they fail after he installs them. Dennis Y

Re: finials

#3

Re: finials

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>And that is a lot of work! How did you do the parallel cuts? Better to do them out of good wood in the beginning. Everyone will be happier.

"Life is too short to turn crappy wood." Wally Dickerman

Re: finials

#4

Re: finials

john lucas

>Carol I did the vertical lines with the router and my index wheel.

Re: finials

#5

Re: finials

Carol in Illinois

>They are gorgeous, though, John. Can you show him the problem and get him to provide you with something better? Or better yet, let you pick out the wood?

Re: finials

#6

Re: finials

John K Jordan

>Speaking of crappy wood, did you get a chance to make something out of that chunk of cocobolo yet? :)

As for the finials, I think I might go find some useful wood, trade for his, throw his in the burn pile and never mention it!

JKJ

Re: finials

#7

Re: finials

john lucas

>Carol I'm hoping he can go back to the guy who sold him crappy green wood and said it was dry, and get his money back or at least get some good dry wood.

Re: finials

#8

Re: finials

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>He's gonna need your help, John. He has no clue what to look for, or look out for. He has already proven that!

I think the time you take to help him will save you time if you have to deal with this crap. And your chances of making him happy over the long term are dim, to say the least. CYA if for no other reason, word of mouth advertising.

Re: finials

#9

Re: finials

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>John, I turned some Douglas fir finials for a contractor last summer. I even posted pictures of them here. Before I took the job, I explained a few things to him.

Me: Do you understand that these will be close in appearance, but not exact?

Him: Yes. They will be 12 feet off the ground and about 40 feet apart from one another.

Me: Do you also understand that this wood that you are providing is going to crack?

Him: Yes.

Me: Is either of these a problem?

Him: No.

So I turned them. The guy came to pick them up, studied them closely, and pronounced them good. FIVE MONTHS LATER he calls me to tell me the architect did not accept them because they were not exact to the drawing, and they were cracking. He would not let me speak to the architect directly, telling me that we were both "sources" for him that he would not divulge. I told him to take me off the source list and that I would give him his money back, but I would not turn them again if I was going to have to deal with an architect and his micrometer.

I learned two things from this job - no more softwood finials, and no more architects. Good luck with your own.

Bill

Re: finials

#10

Dick Hines

Re: finials

Dick Hines

>Bill, I bet the "architect" could not tell them apart at 40 ft. apart and 12" off the ground. A persons eye can't pick up the differances that good. Now, if he was a eagle.... maybe.

Re: finials

#11

Re: finials

Barry Turner

>Unless they are woodworkers......most people don't have a clue what constitutes "good wood".

Re: finials

#12

Re: finials

Darrell Feltmate

>John,

Pine is a pain to turn. Around here dry pine means kiln dried and that means 3/4" thick stock. You would have to glue it up to get a blank. For that matter, most wood you are going to get that is 6" thick will still be wet enough to crack when turned and drying. Why not start with a glued up blank?

Re: finials

#13

Sometimes you just have to fire a customer

Ron in Drums PA

>A lesson I learned long ago

80% of your headaches comes from 20% of your customers

Re: finials

#14

Re: finials

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Dick, I agree with you completely. They would have had to been waaayyy off for anyone to see anything at the installation points. I'm pretty sure the problem with the finials was serious cracking. I saw what happened with the reject pieces that I kept. I think the contractor may have been casting doubt on the closeness of the duplication to get me to buy into the need to do them over again. He was all for paying me for the second try as well. I told him that I could turn them all over again just to have them rejected all over again, and without the ability to discuss it with one of the principal players, it would be an exercise in futility. Not only that, it was a real bear of a job!

I've met hundreds of engineers, mathematicians, scientists, and even (gasp!) architects over the years as I have traveled, and most of them understand the difference between CNC and hand turned. I won't write off architects completely, but if I can't talk to someone who has that kind of control on a project, I am not getting involved again. I've got way too much work coming in to have to deal with that kind of stuff.

Bill

Re: finials

#15

Jesper, Denmark

and........

Jesper, Denmark

>80% of your profits come from 20% of your customers.

The only problem is deciding which 20% a particular customer is going to be in!

Re: finials

#16

Re: finials

Russ Fairfield

>I agree with Bill and Ron and some of the other responses. You need to have a contract that states what you are willing to do with what wood, what you can and cannot guarantee, and for how much. Anything else, and these things will be back to haunt you for months (years) to come. There really are customers who it is best to send to someone else. They aren't worth the time and effort.

If nothing else, there are 2 things I have learned from years of doing custom architentural turnings. You are now dealing with the 1st and Bill had to deal with the 2nd. Remembering them now will keep you out of a lot of trouble later

ONE -

Don't pay any attention to what the customer says in the beginning about the differences in form between multiple turnings, or that warping, cracking, or dripping sap would be acceptable. They are acceptable only because they haven't happened yet. I have yet to meet the 1st customer who didn't complain when the wood started acting like wood, regardless of what they said in the beginning.

TWO -

Never deal with a customer who has an Architect in the picture without being able to talk directly with that architect for all design and product approvals. A good Architect isn't stupid, they do understand wood and its characteristice. A good architect also has a contract with their client in which they have made performance guarantees for products, materials, and services. Architects don't like having clients purchasing materials on their own, and later holding the Architect responsible for their performance.

It isn't any different from the home buyer furnishing special lighting fixtures or windows, and later blaming the builder when they fail.

Re: finials

#17

Yup, and........

Ron in Drums PA

>You are right.

After getting burned once or twice, it's not hard to figure out where they belong.