Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ellis

>Well, in the better-late-than-never category, here is this month's survey question. I'm interested to know your thoughts on woodworking classes. There are degree programs (e.g., College of the Redwoods), private schools (e.g., Mark Adams), weekend tutorials (e.g., Ellsworth), seminar programs (e.g., Woodcraft and Lee Valley stores) and probably other outlets.

Which, if any, of these types of classes have you availed yourself of?

What do you regard as the pros and cons of the different types of programs? Do you consider them cost-effective for what you learn?

Do you have any recommendations for other channels of woodworking education? What does the future hold?

As usual, we will grind, chop, puree and digest your replies into a column for the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. You can visit previous survey topics in our News & Views department.

Thanks for participating in our survey.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#2

Steven Antonucci

You forgot Symposium as education

steve antonucci

>I've only taken one paid class with David Ellsworth. You can learn to turn for much less, but you get so much more from his class if you ask for it. Turning is the mechanical part of the craft/art form and frankly, what a lot of people probably seek in a class. To me, it would be analagous to learning to be a house painter from Michelangelo. David's class was worth every penny.

But you forgot another channel- Symposia. For me, the first one I attended was like drinking from a fire hose. There was so much information available and so much talent accessible, it was impossible to not learn something every minute of the day!

For anyone looking to expand beyond the "what angle" or "what brand" aspects of the hobby, a symposium is the single best way that you can expand your knowledge. Any time a couple of hundred (or thousand) people convene on a topic, there will always be an opportunity to learn- no matter what your skill levels.

Steven

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Cyril Griesbach

>I, too, spent a weekend ( and $ ) with David Ellsworth and I must agree with Steve. Later, I also did a hands on day with Mike Jackofsky where I learned even more. Now putting it to use is another matter. I also have to agree with Steve on the Symposiums. Often the name turners are demonstrating tools and equipment in the vendor area in addition to the classrooms and even some hands-on may be had.

Let's not forget club demos. These are a wonderful opportunity to learn new techniques and procedures a lot more up close and personal than the Symposiums. I've been to club demos with Bill Grumbine, Stuart Batty and others that have been real learning experiences.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Stuart Johnson

>I am all for good woodworking classes. When I was in eight grade I made a very poor wastebasket out of plywood in what was called a shop class. My next attempt was 30 years later when I got the bright idea that if I had a radial saw I could make a couch out of borg 2x4's. You can imagine the results.

Twenty years later I still had the idea that I would like to be able to do woodworking but had no idea how. My wife and I went to a show and back in one corner was a Homestead Heritage booth displaying items they taught at their WW school. I signed up for the entire set of courses they then offered. There was a one day this is a chisel, mallet and saw course. The next one was a two day simple dovetail box and dado hanging shelf course. This was followed by four and five day courses that all built on what you learned in the prior sessions. When all was done I had several boxes with progressively better dovetails, a coffee table and a mortise and tenon rocking chair. All built with hand tools. Now the stock had been roughed in advance by the instructors using machinery but from that point on it was all by hand.

The end result is I learned how to build with wood and to not be afraid to have a go at any project. It also taught me there is a place for power and a place have handwork. I would never have been able to take the steps or accomplish what I have without the hands on instruction.

My wood turning steps have been different. In this case groups such as Wood Central have been my instructors. However, I feel I would be much further along with some hands on lessons and at some point will probably inflict myself on some poor sole and hopefully be broken of my bad habits.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

bowlman

>Before the birth of AAW, I was a self-taught turner ... that is a dummy teaching another dummy. My first exposure to better woodturnings were the articles in Fine Woodworking on David Ellsworth, Al Stirt and others. Then along came Arrowmont and its "Vision and Concept" gathering in October 1985. All this time I had been truggling along. Now I had a chance to meet and learn from the big guns.

Since then, I have availed myself of every opportunity to learn. This includes syposiia both national and regional, local gatherings (Indy Fest), private lessons, AAW Chapter meetings, invited turners like Clay Foster, Mike Hosaluk, Jamie Donaldson and so many others. I have also managed to foist myself onto a few turner teachers as their shop assistant.

All of these have their merits. Now that I'm on a severley limited fixed income, the cost of schools like Arrowmont, Marc Adams, and others is rather daunting. National Symposiia as well ... especially with the price of gas these days.

Out of all of the resources available, I would say that the "most value for the buck" would be a mentor from a local chapter. Learn all you can and move on from there to local gatherings and regional symposiia, National if you can afford it. Regional symposiia give you exposure to big names but in a smaller, more intimate arena. AS was stated earlier, a National AAW Symposium is like trying to drink from a fire hose. Plus it can be overwhelming and intimidating to see the vast array of wood, tools, lathes, people and topics of all the different rotations. Still, if I could afford it I would attend every National Symposium and all the various regional ones as well.

One last word about private lessons. Again, if you can afford them, by all means go! My experiences have taught me that a few days with an excellent teacher (David Ellsworth, the late Rude Osolnik, John Jordan, Mike Hosaluk, Betty Scarpino, Clay Foster, Don Geiger, just to name a few) is an opportunity to learn by immersion and saturation.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#6

Re: Hands On, Hands Down

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>[Not you Hoarshack!]

I've spent a Weekend-With-David [Ellsworth] twice (ok, so I'm a slow learner). I found the immediate hands-on experience to be essential to the learning process. Turning is an intensly physical process linking the turner to the wood through the tool. While standing/sitting around watching someone else do it may peak our interest and awareness of new or different techniques, they are essentially lectures, and the great span of time between the symposium or club demo and actually getting to try to use what we see in the session renders much of the information conveyed "lost" because it can't be tried out until much later. In my view, there's just no substitute to standing elbow-to-elbow with the demonstrator as they do what they do, and then walking over to your lathe and doing it yourself. No video, whether live or on disc, can yet put the viewer into the action. While I've gone to a number of technique demonstrations, I go, not to learn the technique that I really can't see or feel, but rather to have my consciousness raised by new ideas and different ways of viewing the process or piece that I may be working on at any given time.

Conversely, doing flat work is the opposite, in my view. Monkey-see-monkey-do works just fine for flatwork because, while they don't run themselves, the particular machines and their set-ups and tooling are what produce the actual result. Demonstrations and videos coupled with a measured drawing, or other graphic, work very well as teaching methods in this context. Granted, the use of hand tools in flat work (and carving) is a very personal effort, but their "pace" affords the woodworker much more time to adjust their technique for the desired result, so a time lag twixt see and do is not so important.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Greg Haugen

>I've turned since 2005. I'm a "high honors 4.0" graduate of a 2 year technical woodworking/carpentry program. There wasn't a large amount of turning in the program but to an extent woodworking is woodworking. The issues of finishing, sanding, wood movement, grain, and figure are true if it's flat or round work. In any event that can drasticly shorten the learning curve. My club is very "progressive" in the demos and hands on we get in. Grumbine, Stu Batty, Ellsworth, Sing, and Rosand have been here and now John Jordan will be coming next month. I've also traveled to Chicago for Trent Bosch demos. You can't learn turning without a tool in hand. So in my opinion books, demos, and videos can only go so far. I'm from Wisconsin and only an hour and half from Alan Lacer. I've gone a few times there for a day or half day of turning. The $35 an hour 1 on 1 charge is priceless. My club is incredibly fortunate to have a person named Duane Hill in it. He has opened his shop a couple times a month for "open shop" nights since the club began. Anyone can come with either just questions or wood in hand to turn. These opportunities are worth the price of dues alone. My big issue with some of the bigger schools or symposiums is the size they allow in demos and classes. If you're in a class with 15-20 other people and one main instructor and a few assistants. How much can you really be learning. I think you're better off taking that same amount of money you spend in the 5 days and take it to spend it on a small group or 1 on 1 time with said instructor for 2-3 days. You'll probably get more out of it. In any venue I think the ratio of instructor to student to be more important than the school or symposium's name. I think that's forgotten often.

Just my two cents.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>An excellent source for learning is a mentoring program at the local clubs. Turners from all skill levels get together snd share knowledge and techniques.

Demos at symposiums and local clubs are great for inspiration and ideas, but are no subsitute for hands-on learning. I've been teaching turning classes and doing one on one teaching for a lot of years. Over 450 students and still teaching. Most of my classes are for beginners and for intermediate turners in bowls and hollow forms. In these classes we work on tool sharpening and we spend time on developing good form and design before we do any turning.

I've had people question me on why I stress good form and design in a beginners classes. Well why not? The basics of good form aren't too difficult to learn for most people, and the pleasure that the student gets from seeing a well formed first-ever bowl is the best part of the class for me, the teacher. I feel that getting the student to recognize the value of basics in form, such as the rule of thirds, or the beauty of a good curve is as much a part of learning as is learning the techniques and skills of using the tools.

The classes that I enjoy teaching the most are the advanced classes, usually in hollow forms. There we can be more creative and can share ideas and thoughts on form and design, and also on tool techniques. The students sometimes come to class with a new tool which the group can evaluate. I often come away from those classes with new ideas for my own turning.

I need to get out and take some classes myself. I would really like to spend some time with any number of turners whose work I admire. I've never been involved with classes of 3 to 5 or more days. Some day I'm going to sign up for one. There is much to learn out there.

Wally

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ed Karch

>I learned from three levels of adult ed classes, club skill enhancement days twice a month, club demos with national known turners followed by one day workshops with these turners, symposia, Ellsworth's school, 5 days with Jimmy Clewes. Which was the best totally depends on what level your skills are. You can learn to turn from Ellsworth as a newbee but it really is a waste of a valuable resource.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

john lucas

>I would have to say I am magazine, club demo and symposium taught. I've only had 2 actual classes, one with Joe Looper when I was first learning and then one a few years ago with Binh Pho. I've learned just about everything I know by being inquisitive. Reading all I can and then observing very closely when I go to club demo's or symposiums.

I do think one on one is the best way to go followed by taking a class. I could have avoided much of the trial and error with a good insructor however I did learn a lot by occasionally doing something wrong and having to figure out how to make it work.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>When I started turning in late 2002, I was on my own. I was a stumbling bum until I found the local turning club, which I quickly joined. What an amazing source for learning the necessary techniques for turning and getting the desired results. Today, I like to get together with members of the club and talk and turn. You can't help but learn something.

Easily the biggest impact I've ever had was at the End-o-Pond fest at Indy. Bill Grumbine attended and was very forthcoming with tips and advice. While doing an informal demonstration very early in the weekend, he showed me how to properly present a bowl gouge. What a revelation! I also attended a club demo he gave to the Central Indiana turning club that weekend. My club has a demo done by a club member every month and has a well-known turner in twice a year. I have also attended several regional get togethers (Indyfest and The 2006 Gathering at TD's in Georgia for example) and have learned a lot from everyone.

Wood Central and other forums are great places to learn about wood and get inspired. Knowledge is as close as asking a question. You are sure to get some answers, often time multiple answers, and all are from a different point of view. This leads to thinking, which leads to new places in your evolution as a woodturner.

I have to agree with others in that the national symposium is like drinking water from a fire hose, but it is an incredible source of inspiration and it is impossible not to learn something every waking moment. I attended Louisville, plan to attend Richmond, and hope to attend them until I can't afford to attend any more.

Keep 'em spinning

keithz

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#12

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Steven Kubien

>I wish I could afford the time and money to attend symposiums and take more small classes. This past month I was lucky enough to be one of 4 students in a class with Lyle Jamieson and it was stellar! Videos and demos are great but I think turners are most fortunate to have the vast number of clubs and guilds available to them. These are great resources. I do not know if flat-workers have such clubs and get the hands-on opportunities we do.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Bill Clark

>I�m just two years into serious turning so I�ve got a ways to go in regard to expanding my abilities. Two years ago our turning club president spent 3 hours with me, one-on-one, and got me started. Later after a club demo given by one of our advanced members I spend some time with him and was shown many subtle tips and tool handling techniques that really turned the corner for me. Like John Lucas, I�m very inquisitive and observant. I�m also big fan of DVD�s. If they are produced properly they can be excellent teachers. For example, while the two Bill Grumbine DVD�s are relative basic stuff, I have found them an excellent reference source that I view often.

One of my biggest inspirations was attending the AAW Symposium in Portland last summer. I took through notes and have been able to refer to those notes when duplicating techniques or processes. While you don�t get hands on training at a Symposium you do get exposure to many different techniques, ideas and answers to, �how did they do that� questions.

I�ve also been fortunate to attend full day demos with Cindy Drozda and Jimmy Clewes. These were both fascinating and while I did not get any hands on training the tips and techniques from these master turners were another great learning experience. I would like to do some one-on-one training with a master turner sometime. This would probably be the ultimate learning experience.

Most importantly, there are multiple sources of training available. All are valuable. I have yet to sit in on a demo, view a DVD or talk to another turner that I did not learn something.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

gary s clarke

>Classes are great, you always learn something, even if it is what not to do. That said, when I retired I took beginning woodturning and advanced turning. Then I took night classes in woodworking at a local community college. These lasted for 2 quarters and I was going to take the advanced fine woodworking class but the school canceled it. I have also taked numerous classes and demonstrations at AAW and at local clubs. I have enjoyed every class I ever took. But I am a life long education person and after had a college education and post college( for 9 yrs) and in my life work (at least 100 hrs of continuing ed every yr ). I really enjoy the woodturning classes and meeting new people. When your too old to learn you are dead. The road to success is always under construction.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#15

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Bruce in Saint John, N.B.

>How is the the Ides of March related to this subject? Seems to me the Ides were on the 15th of the month, perhaps Iam missing something.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#16

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Barry Elder

>I have learned through mentoring, DVDs, books, and, on the Saturday after our club meeting, Jack Shelton has everyone over and we cover various subjects with lessons and demos right and left. It's great to be able to watch a DVD at home and then get answers to the questions that always pop up. These club workshops provide meaningful "hand on" time that's hard to beat.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#17

The importance of Classes

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>For those pondering the idea of taking a class of any kind I would strongly encourage it. For the most part I think woodturning is learned in a solitary environment. We struggle along by ourselves in our workshops and we get pretty good at learning bad habits or improper techniques that are later hard to reverse. Classes offer the opportunity to broaden not only our technical skills but also our creative awareness. We learn so much from the other people in the classes that we attend. One of the things I love about taking a week long class is the simple fact that I am fully immersed in something I love to do and am not interrupted by telephones, daily household commitments, carpools, cooking meals etc. I am on vacation and all I am responsible for is me and being creative. Ah, the thought of it. I think sometimes we don�t realize our potential for being creative until we do fully immerse ourselves in a week long or weekend class. If you�re like me and have a full time job and parenting responsibilities, achieving a 3 hour block of time in the shop, uninterrupted is a miracle in itself. So for me, that is the most wonderful part of taking a class. We�ve worked hard all our lives and we deserve the pampering and delight of a woodturning get away. The other thing that I mentioned is the ability to work alongside other turners and share creative ides. People who love the same thing we do. Who love to talk all day about it and share their tips and tricks and ideas. We get inspired by each other just by being there together. I�ve taken classes where the dynamic of the group was fantastic. The other people in the class were wonderful and we became good friends. So much so that we all met up the next year and took another class at the same place. What a great thing to look forward to. When you leave a week like this you feel so refreshed, so full of new ideas and new skills and a whole new excitement about where you are headed on your creative path. I can�t express enough how much I encourage everyone to try a class of some sort. Whether you are young, old, beginner, experienced, shy or love being around others, you will find that taking a class will truly add to your love of woodworking no matter what type of work you make.

Jennifer

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#18

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Doug Turner

>I have taken 1 day seminars from John Jordan, Richard Raffan, Vic Wood,and Malcom Tibbetts. All were inspiring and worth the money. I took a 3 day class from Mike Mahoney at WoodCraft Supply that was great. I have watched videos of most of the professional turners and read most of the books & learn something evry time. I will be attending the symposium in Provo, UT this spring for the first time.

I have probably learned most of my turning skills thru club demos which are a tremendous value for the money.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#19

Lyle Jamieson

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Lyle Jamieson

>As a demonstrator and instructor Ill put my opinion out there. It's in the hands-on sessions that I see the most progress and excitement. It is really a hoot for me to see the "light come on". Why are we turning?? Because its fun!! If we can shorten the learning curve sooner or later, why not sooner? Many times its a matter of removing obsticles that are produced by trial and error. One-0n-One is the most fun for me. Many of my students say they wish they had taken hands-on classes much earlier in the learning curve.

Turning is a journey. Once you get to the place you want to go...it opens up all kinds of new possibilities. It's a journey where you never reach the end of the road.