Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Glue block broke...HELP

Posts

Glue block broke...HELP

#1

Glue block broke...HELP

Jim(IN)

>Hi All

Been lurking for quite some time here and at other woodturning sites and been absorbing as much knowledge. I don't post much because I can't talk(type) fast.

As a beginning turner I have tried my hand a few times at segmented turning with varying degrees of success. I recently(just an hour ago) was in the shop and I was turning a bubinga bowl and was turing the outside, got a catch and the bowl went flying. Broke off right where the jaws clamp to the glue block. Inside has been smoothed out a little but my faceplate jaws will not hold onto the inside(too big) or the outside(too small). Tried to rechuck it numerous times and get an incredible wobble when turned on.

What can a budding woodbutcher...um...I mean woodturner do in this situation. Any advise other than don't get a catch.

I was using poplar as a glue block. What is the best wood to use in this situation? Tried plywood and that didn't last long with catches

I have a VS Jet mini.

Thanks for all the past knowledge and tips you all have freely posted here and at other sites.

Jim

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#2

Steven Antonucci

Find local help

steve antonucci

>Save the good wood for a later date when your mistakes won't be as expensive. The best advice you can get is to find a local club and seek out the more seasoned turners for advice. Beating your head against basic techniques will only leave you woozy...

Steven

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#3

Re: Find local help

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I agree with Steve. Get some hands on help. If you have any store that sells turning tools ask them about a turning club or the name of a turner. I have never met a turner that was not willing to help a new person get started.

Remember prectice makes permenant not perfect. Learn to do it the correct way first.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#4

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

gary s clarke

>Jim, poplar is a good inexpensive wood to use for a glue block. I like to use a face plate ( not a chuck ) to attach to the glue block. Just my preference. I also use the face plate to attach to the bowl which will be the inside of the bowl. Then shape the outside and turn a tenon on the base. Make sure the tenon has a sharp flat inner edge and that the outside of the chuck jaws rests flat on the bowl adjacent to the tenon and not on the tenon itself. After turning a little of the inside recheck the jaws and tighten again as sometimes they tend to loosen. Hope this helps some. Do not give up and keep trying. You might want to purchase a video on bowl turning. Bill Gumbine has an excellent one and there are others. good luck.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#5

I agree to some extent.

henthorn

>I guess I don't understand why a glue block would be used with a chuck. A better grip would be obtained if the glue block were screwed right to a face plate. That also makes it much easier to get at the base of the turning and do what you want with it. After the major turning part is finished than one can part it off from the glue block, reverse chuck it and finish the bottom. I generally prefer to use a glue block screwed to a face plate than to use a chuck to hold the work. Of course I am PSC (Pre scroll chuck) so I learned the old way.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#6

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Jim, poplar is kind of "splitty" so not the best choice for a glue block but if it broke somewhere besides the glue joint, I'd glue it back together. In the future, a good wood would be Elm with it's interlocking grain which is hard to split. Easy for me to say, Elm grows like a weed around here and White Elm dies off when it reaches a certain age from Dutch Elm disease so it's plentiful.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#7

musings on various methods...

GaryG in MD

>Don,

I know you've been turning for years, and I know you like face plates. Many turners use them, so I'm not disagreeing, but with due respect, giving an alternate point of view.

Jim,

You'll get as many different answers as there are turners. I've been turning successfully for several years. I use glue blocks as needed, and have never had a failure (knock wood). I use Borg 2x4s cut up into 3.5" circles with a tenon for my medium-size chuck jaws. I suppose harder wood would be better if you're planning on having big catches, but then you'll just tear the whole thing out of the chuck, or, if it's on a faceplate, you may hurt yourself. Frankly, a broken glue block or tenon is a pretty good safety valve. I'd say, with some of the above posts, that you'd be better served to get some help with learning proper tool control so you don't have the bad catches.

I have never, ever used a faceplate, and frankly see no reason to do so. I don't like them. I have a 12" lathe (Jet 1236), and I turn 11.5" pieces all the time on a chuck tenon -- either turned directly on the piece or on a glue block if there's not enough natural wood. I've turned many wet, relatively heavy pieces this way, and I don't have a bandsaw to make them perfectly round. Neither do I have sandbags for extra weight. If you start with a decent, chainsawed octagon, properly centered, you shouldn't have a problem.

My favorite way of beginning with a raw piece is to use a screw chuck in a drilled hole in what will be the top (hollow) of the bowl or whatever. I cut a square-edged tenon on the back, shape the outside, reverse onto the tenon in a 4-jaw scroll chuck to hollow, and then use a jam chuck in the headstock and cone center in the tailstock to turn off the foot. It works for me.

...Gary

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#8

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

George Van

>Jim, I got to agree with Gary, sounds like you had a good safety valve. I only use glue blocks when I do not want to waste any of the blank I have available for a tenon to chuck in the jaws. With your bubinga blank that may be the case.

I mount most of my bowls between centers so I have the option of how I orient the grain in the bowl, if that is not the case I start to mount as Gary described on a screw chuck.

It sounds like the best advice is given above, find someone to give you lessons and practice on some wood you are not afraid to practice on. A catch that can break off a poplar glue block is best to avoid.

Have fun and turn safely!

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#9

methods of work

John K Jordan

>>...I guess I don't understand why a glue block would be used with a chuck.

I use a glue block with a chuck when my stock is too thin to waste thickness by cutting a tenon, say when turning a bowl from a 8/4 stock. A faceplate would not be appropriate the way I do it:

- Glue a round block mostly centered on the "bottom" side of the board. (I sometimes fasten the glue block after the next step instead.)

- Drill a hole in the "face" side and mount on a Glazer screw chuck and turn the outside.

- Turn the glue block concentric, slight dovetail.

- Reverse and grip the glue block with a chuck.

- Turn the inside of the bowl.

- Reverse and remove or turn away the glue block and finish the bottom.

For glue blocks I use a stack of disks I cut once from a 3/4" red oak board.

A friend of mine works differently with a faceplate and no glue block:

- Fasten the "top" of the blank to a faceplate with screws.

- Turn the outside of the bowl.

- Flatten the bottom of the bowl.

- Apply a layer of two-sided tape to the bottom.

- Apply a layer of two-sided tape to a faceplate.

- Stick the blank to the faceplate, carefully concentric.

- Reverse and turn the inside of the bowl.

- Remove the glue block.

- Reverse and jam chuck to finish the bottom.

JKJ

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#10

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

Barry Irby

>I read your post and all the answers above. I am wondering if you wanted a general answer or a specific one, or both?

Generally, the advice has been good.

1. Find a local club and start going.

2. Find someone to work with you and help you get it right to start with. Easier to learn that to relearn.

3. Get some good videos. (Bill Grumbine's comes to mind, and there are others.

4. Practice on cheaper or even free wood. I taught my son to turn and he about broke me turning cocobolo and red heart and .... The other day he looked at one of his early triumphs and said, "you should have shot me."

On a slightly different topic, if you are getting giant catches, it sound like you may be inattentive. If I am right and your attention wanders, I sympathise, being ADD Boy myself. Keep your mind on the work at hand. Don't try to learn to turn when you are stressed or tired.

The advice others gave you on glue blocks is good. There are stronger woods than poplar, but none of them will completely save you from giant catches and you should need them once you stop getting the catches.

Specifiacally, how to rescue the bowl you are working on?

It would help to know what other tools you have besides a lathe, but lets assume you only have a lathe.

Reverse chuck the blank/bowl and turn the glue block off it and install another.

You said the bowl was hollowed a little. You could use a jamb chuck. Turn another scrap of wood to fit into the hollow and bring the tails stock up to hold or press the blank against the jamb chuck. Or you could put a flat dick on a faceplate or chuck and just jamb the face of the bowl against that. You could turn the disk down to exactly match the outside diameter of the bowl to help with recentering it while you glue on the new glue block. If there is enough of the old glue block left, you may be able to just true it up and use it.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#11

Glue Blocks and DF Tape......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I got started using glue blocks many years ago when I had access to a lot of highly figured wood that was just under 3 inches thick. No wood to waste so glue blocks allowed me to use all of the thickness in the blank. I continute to use glue blocks today for some of my turning, along with a screw chuck. Works well for me. I can't think why I would want to use a chuck instead of the screw schuck.

Double faced tape has been sort of forgotten by woodturners. It has many uses such as in cutting the backside of small collars for Hollow forms. I use double faced tape when turning platters. Again, no wood wasted on thin blanks.

One thing to remember when using double faced tape is that it won't work on wet wood. Must be dry. Also, use the right tape. My choice is Permacell as sold by Craft Supplies. Carpet tape can't be trusted to hold well.

How to remove the piece when using DF tape? Simply remove the piece from the lathe. Insert a small wood plug of the right size into the threaded opening of the faceplate, then mount the faceplate back on the lathe. As you thread the piece on, the plug just pushes the piece off the faceplate...couldn't be simpler. That little trick earned me $75 from Wood magazine several years ago.

Wally

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#12

yes, but...

John K Jordan

>>...How to remove the piece when using DF tape?...Insert a small wood plug...

This should work fine if the base is thick and strong enough. I'd be afraid to try that if the bottom is potentially fragile (burl, thin, etc).

What my friend does is inject solvent (acetone?) into the tape from around the side with a hypodermic syringe which loosens the tape.

BTW, he has used the tape method many times with very heavy chunks of wood to make LARGE bowls and vessels and has never had one come off since he started using the two-layer method. The problem with using just one layer it is difficult to get enough pressure between the faceplate and the wood for a good bond.

If you apply a layer of tape on each part separately, before removing the backing you can burnish each side with a great deal of force using a small smooth tool. Then place the two halves together for an adhesive-adhesive bond.

JKJ

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#13

Very nice summary, Barry.

GaryG in MD

>

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#14

Re: yes, but...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Sounds reasonable....however in the past twenty something years I've turned at least 100 platters using tape and using the plug for removal and haven't cracked one yet. I've had some thin ones where I proceeded very slowly. Sure beats messing around with messy solvents etc. Don't knock it if you haven't tried it.

Tell your friend to try it...I'll bet he'd like my method. Lots of my friends do after they've seen me do it .

Wally

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#15

Re: yes, but...

John K Jordan

>Don't worry, I'm not knocking your idea. I think it is good to know an alternate method in case it's needed. Your idea is a nice one.

I have indeed tried it (just not with your plug idea), using the "pressure through the center hole" method to remove pieces the few times I've used double-sided tape. There was plenty of wood and strength in the bottom. I believe my friend also uses central force where appropriate but uses the solvent for stubborn pieces. Note that an 18" bowl may require considerably more holding power than a flatter platter due to the side forces, thus the double layer technique, and might be more difficult to remove than a single layer of tape.

Another thing to consider: the center force method, plug or otherwise, might not be appropriate if there are voids in the bottom near the center. Some of the pieces my friend turned seemed like they were more air than wood! He turns and finishes the outside first, then wraps the outside with strapping tape to hold the piece together while turning the inside.

If I did a great deal of mounting with double-sided tape I would consider drilling and tapping several holes through the face plate, evenly spaced for balance. Several machine bolts tightened through the back could spread the force over a wide area.

BTW, I found quality double-sided tape a few years ago at Woodcraft.

JKJ

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#16

As long as we are sidetracked, a question?

Barry Irby

>I don't understand about the plug? Does your lathe have a flat face for the plug to press against? I have a Nova DVR and it is conical. I'm not sure there is a flat surface for the plug to press against? (I'm not home right now, or I would go look.

On the subject of double stick tape, I like the idea of the two layers. Burnishing it on is a good idea and I think the two thicknesses might compensate for a less than perfect fit of the surfaces.

I have seen that "time" is important. Press the pieces in place for several minutes. The bond is not instantaneous.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#17

Re: As long as we are sidetracked, a question?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Barry, the spindle nose pushes the plug against the base of the platter or bowl or whatever as the faceplate is threaded on. The plug should be just a little less in dia. than the inside of the faceplate. Works like a charm.

If you get on WoW, I have a tutorial with pics on turning a collar. I use DF tape while turning the backside of the collar. The pics show the use of the plug. Go to Reviews and type collar.

Wally

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#18

Re: As long as we are sidetracked, a question?

Barry Irby

>Thanks Wally. I was thinking about the holes that some of my faceplates have, near the perimeter.

Now, I believe you are describing an "extension of the shaft". I will look and see if I have face plates that have a center hole. I think I do, but at the moment I am not at home near my shop and suffering a CRS moment. I can see that if there is a hole, it would work great. Thanks for the idea.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#19

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

Allen Neighbors

>Jim, the only thing I can think of to do in the case of a failed glue block, is to make a new one.

First off, make a jam chuck by turning a piece of soft wood to fit pretty well inside the little bit you have turned. Bring up your tailstock, and fuss with it, turning it by hand, until you get it pretty well centered. Turn off the old glue block, except a little nub in the center (under the tailstock point) and then remove the nub by hand.

Get some fairly dense hard wood to use as a glue block. In my opinion, Poplar is too soft. Glue on another glue block large enough to make a tenon on. After it sets, remount the bowl, and fuss with it some more until you get it centered. Turn another tenon. Remount your bowl, and true up the outside.

Hope this helps you a little.

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#20

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

Jim(IN)

>Thank All

I appreciate your help and guidance.

Going to attempt the jam chuck method and see how that works out. Never done one before.

Hopefully I can get the bowl on straight and turn the glue block so it will be concentric when I rechuck it.

I have to admit that I am really green bowlturning and I do get numerous catches when I turn. S'pose I'll search out a local(within 50 or 60 miles)turner for lessons on how to properly turn.

Thanks again

Jim

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#21

Jim, if you're using a bowl gouge...

Allen Neighbors

>to turn the bowl, it's easy to get a catch with a sharp nose angle when turning the corner. I have a gouge with a slightly more blunt angle, and I hand grind the bevel to about 1/2 depth... if that makes sense... which gives me a double bevel of sorts. I don't know the degrees of the angles.

Having the double bevel makes it easier to transition from the bottom around the corner to the side... and vice versa.

John Lucas can explain this double bevel thing a lot better than I can... he's much more articulate. :)

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#22

Re: Glue block broke...HELP *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>Jim,

You can check which AAW club is closer to you from the link.

BTW, "Turned Bowl Made Easy" dvd by Bill Grumbine has every information you will need to get a good start.

Gordon


AAW local Clubs

Re: Glue block broke...HELP

#23

Re: Jim, if you're using a bowl gouge...

Jim(IN)

>Actually I was using a round scraper. Seems to work better for me with my limited experience. A bowl gouge would have sent the segmented bowl flying before I even got half of it turned.

Gonna have to get the DVD

Thanks for your help

Jim