Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Not the typical bench grinder question

Posts

Not the typical bench grinder question

#1

Not the typical bench grinder question

wilbur

>Reading the recent thread about which bench grinder made me think about something. I know why a slow speed grinder is good for turning tools. This begs the question, when would you want to use a fast speed grinder for, other than for making tools get blued faster?

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#2

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

john lucas

>I high speed grinder is actually the correct grinder for High speed steel tools according to the people who make the steel. You do need a light touch and the proper wheel to keep from blueing the tool but it doesn't hurt High speed steel.

The reason I prefer lower speed is simply I feel safer. The wheel isn't spinning as fast. The other reason is the less I heat up the tool the sooner I can touch it. Most of the time my fingers are well away from the edge but sometimes I have my left hand on top of the tool and a hot tool is uncomfortable.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#3

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Fog Tanner

>That's easy, for when you want to remove metal quickly and know what you are doing. My father-in-law was a machinst for over 50 years. When I worked for him, I watch him sharpen drill bits freehand and they drilled perfectly. I tried that and they never drilled a striaght hole again - at least not the size intended. I did learn to reshape carbide cutting tools in a hurry though. In a machine shop time is money and the time to sharpen tools is part of the production time. I have known some guys whose only job was shaprening tools and cutters and wouldn't use anything but a high speed grinder. But, they also had a touch and lots of years of experience of doing that all day long.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#4

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Bill Howatt

>A lot of things get ground that aren't tools and there is no concern about overheating when grinding things like mild steel or whatever.

Bill

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#5

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Wilber, like you and the others have said for sharpening woodturning tools a slow speed grinder is best. Now a high speed grinder will get you in trouble in a hurry but it's fast. The wheel needs to be dressed often to prevent burning but it's fast. Put a very agressive wheel on and it's faster yet.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#6

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Texian

>In addition to what John said, the lower speed gives you an extra couple of milliseconds in which to quit screwing up what you just realized that you are screwing up. An additional safety factor, as it were.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#7

Both...

Peter Teubel

>When I was turning full time, I used a high speed grinder. Dressed/trued/balanced wheels. Smooth as silk. It saved me a couple seconds every time I had to resharpen. When production turning, those seconds add up. But for any other situation, slow speed grinders are more than adequate.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#8

If you want to grind fast and cool try this. *LINK*

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryZPoA43GU3Ns+ew

>These little spray mist units really work great, and are very reasonably priced. They can be used on any grinder, and will make it grind cooler.


http://www.littlemachineshop.com/products/product_view.php?ProductID=2725&category=

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#9

Re: Both...

john lucas

>Peter my woodcraft grinder takes so much longer to get up to 3450 that I can use the 1725 setting and be back at the work before the grinder reaches full speed. It has 2 speeds. I'm sure this is not the case with High quality grinders.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#10

Rob Wallace

Re: If you want to grind fast and cool try this.

Rob Wallace

>I'm sure the coolant would allow cooler grinding, but I couldn't imagine using this at all during a regular turning session. The mess created by spraying coolant coming back at me from spinning grinding wheels, let alone the mess around the grinder, etc. would render this a non-starter for me. I'll stick to a 1725 rpm grinder and a light touch as I've done for the past 15+ years without problems. (I suppose it would be different if I was working in a metal/machine shop.)

Rob Wallace

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#11

Re: If you want to grind fast and cool try this.

Andy Blackwell

>The misters are not used as a flood system. The mister is adjusted so that the air coming out is humid and if you put your finger in front of the air stream it should feel cool and moist but not have visible water droplets. I use similar systems on my metal lathe and mill and never have visable liquid. They do cool the metal and prevent overheating if properly setup with out the mess that is associated with a flood system.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#12

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Russ Fairfield

>Just a couple observations:

Learn sharpening with 1/4" gouges and a high speed grinder. It will force you to develop a light touch at 3600 rpm, make you appreciate a slower 1750 speed, and wish for something even slower.

If you can't wait for the grinder to rev up to speed, just leave it running all the time, and there is no waiting.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#13

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I have yet to see or hear a convincing reason why slow speed grinders are better.

A slow speed grinder with 8" wheels has 67% the surface speed of a high speed grinder with 6" wheels. Not a lot of difference there.

High speed steel is designed to hold its temper and be usable at a dull red heat. Bluing of the steel at the grinder is of no consequence for this type of steel.

p.s. I currently have three grinders, all high speed. If I need to replace one of them, it will be with another high speed grinder.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

Keith Tompkins

>I think there are more misconceptions about sharpening than any other aspect of turning. One "Pro" says never use a grinding jig or fixture. The next says use a low speed grinder, the next says use a high speed. One says grind "A" is no good, and regrinds every student's tools to his grind. (Which they cannot duplicate, especially without a jig). I have seen gouges a full 6" shorter than new because turners cannot achieve the results they want...without completing a bowl.

I have never understood the arguement for low speed grinders. Using the same grit wheel, the finish off the high speed grinder is far superior, easily demonstrated for yourself.

I often hear that turning your HS steel tools blue won't damage them, yet turners shy away from the high speed grinders for that reason. Still, I see many, many tools sharpened on low speed grinders that are severely discolored from heat.

It's not the speed of the wheel alone, but excessive pressure on the tool, and holding the tool stationary for too long in one spot that causes overheating. In most cases, the weight of the tool alone is enough, many times I cradle the tool being ground with my hand to relieve pressure against the wheel. Almost never is pressure needed against the wheel.

With practice, it's not difficult to sharpen any cutting edge on a HS grinder, from chisels, plane irons, to turning tools without overheating the edge, and the results are faster and the cutting edge keener.

I guess the low-high debate is a pet peave of mine.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#15

Re: Both...

Peter Teubel

>Absolutely true. When I'm turning (production) I don't turn off the grinder. It'll run for hours. Again, it's those seconds here and there that add up.

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#16

Very well said Keith.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#17

Rob Wallace

Re: If you want to grind fast and cool try this.

Rob Wallace

>OK Andy..... I didn't know it was a MISTING system - All I have ever seen is flooding of the material being worked (CNC, milling machines, etc.). What is in the the cooling liquid being atomized and misted for the cooling? Is it just water, or are there surfactants or other lubricants in the liquid? Do these leave a residue on the metal that could be transferred to the wood? I'm just curious about this.....INQUIRING MINDS WANT TO KNOW!!

Thanks,

Rob

Re: Not the typical bench grinder question

#18

There is a rust inhibitor which mixes with H2O

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryZPoA43GU3Ns+ew

>It is perfectly safe, and doesn't leave any residue that affects anything that I know of.

You can set the mist very low, so that most of it will go into the air. I have a couple of them, on different grinders. When you can get one of these for $30, and use it on your high speed grinder, I have to wonder why anyone would want to spend ten times that amount for some of those slow wet grinders.

The first time I posted a link to this on this forum, I also posted a photo of a 3/8" ball bearing that I ground half of it away, while holding it between my fingers, just to show how effective it is at keeping the metal cool.

A quart of the inhibitor will last me five to ten years,