Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Spindle turning

Posts

Spindle turning

#1

Spindle turning

TiO

>I've been practicing beads. Can you take a look at my results and make any suggestions?

I used a piece of construction lumber, a 2x8 reduced to 1.5" square blanks as recommended in Alan Lacer's video.

A series of v cuts were made 1.25" and .75" spacings across the blank. Working from right to left, the first 4 beads were cut with a 3/4" skew chisel. The next two were cut with a 3/4" spindle gouge. A 1 1/4" skew with a curved edge were used on the next two. And the last two on the left were cut with a 1" straight edged skew.

Now, while looking at the blank, I realize that when I turned it to round with my roughing gouge that I only used a skew chisel on the right hand half of the blank. The left hand side of the blank shows a slightly rougher surface due to the roughing gouge.

Continued practice will result in improvement, no doubt, but I wonder if experienced spindle turners can see any particular problems that might be caused by tools or techniques.


img

Re: Spindle turning

#2

Re: Spindle turning

robo hippy

>A good start. Like my Kung Fu teacher said when I asked if I was doing it right, "10,000 more times!" But teacher, that is what you said the last time. He smiled that 'I have forgotten more tricks than you will ever learn, but there might be hope for you yet' smile and walked away.

robo hippy

Re: Spindle turning

#3

Re: Spindle turning

john lucas

>Very good start. I find starting with the big barrel shaped beads and then working toward the steep sided beads works best. It looks like you aren't moving the handle far enough. The V shaped beads give me this clue.

To do a barrel shaped bead you rotate the handle while lifting it slightly. The more straight sided the bead the more you have to move the handle. This is because the gouge is sharpened like a V. Place the gouge against one side of the straight sided bead with the bevel flat against it. then you will see how far you have to move the handle to get this shape.

I like to start from a barrel shape and then go to a ball shape and finally a straight sided bead shape. Progressing from one to the other helps you gain a feel for rubbing the bevel and how far you have to move the handle both sideways and up.

Re: Spindle turning

#4

Re: Spindle turning

George Van

>John, do you mean you first turn barrel shapes, then go back on the same piece and change them all to ball shapes and lastly go back and change them to straight sided beads? I too need practice and a routine would help.

Re: Spindle turning

#5

Re: Spindle turning *LINK*

charlie belden

>Maybe some illustrations of some of what John Lucas described might help.

Making a rolling cut is sort of like patting your head while you rub your stomach - only there's a possibility of a startling "catch" involved. You're moving the cutting edge left or right as you're rolling it on its long axis - while your pivoting it on the tool rest. Roll too fast and you end up with a donut, too slow and you end up with two intersecting Vs.

When doing side by side "balls" or "balls and barrels" you have to work both sides of the cut alternately, deepening the "V" without widening it too much. You're working on some small diameter stuff and the size of the skews and gouges may be limiting how deep you can cut the "V". Try a half inch skew - preferebaly with a curved cutting edge - that long point on a straight edge skew can be pretty catchy.

To get into really tight "V"s a single bevel tool - a 1/4" or 3/8" bench chisel or a 3/8" bedan work well.

Practicing on wood that "behaves" also helps. Mahogany is SO easy to turn, as is cherry. Pine, though readily available, is tough for beginners. Poplar dowels - straight grained - is available at local hardware stores - ACE for example - as well as BIG BOX stores like Home Depot or Lowes.

Sharp tools help as well. Forcing a dull tool to cut a bead is just too much work and it's easy to think your technique is wrong when it's actually a dull tool that's getting in your way.

But once you find a tool that you like and practice sharpening and using it, all the thinking you're doing now while making a cut will go away and you'll start cutting where and how you want to.

Spindle turning is the crack cocaine of turning - quick feedback, sometimes even gratifying feed back, and cheap - little pieces of wood are easy to get.

You're on a very slippery slope here. And it gets much slipperier - and expensive - once you start sliding down the turning slope.

But just remember to keep it fun!


rolling bead cut illustrations

Re: Spindle turning

#6

Re: Spindle turning

john lucas

>You could do that. What I do is turn a barrel shape on one end and then gradually work my way to straight sided beads on the other end. I'll turn them all not trying to get them perfect just trying to get the muscle memory of the movements the same. You end up increasing the movements as you move from barrel to ring.

It really doesn't matter. you could do exactly what you suggested. When I haven't been turning in a while and need to do some spindle work I'll just throw a chunk on the lathe and turn a bunch of beads and coves. It sort of gets you in the frame of mind and brings back the muscle memory so you can start on your spindles with confidence.

there is not doubt the skew is tricky. I worked and worked on turning beads and would get catches and now know why, even though I knew mechanically why they happen. Then one day I could just turn them. I don't really know what i did different other than just practice. If I had to point at one thing it is probably to slow the cut down and control it with your body. You should be able to freeze exactly where you are and not move the gouge. The cut will stop. You can then make really tiny movements to change the direction of cut and then proceed.

Re: Spindle turning

#7

Great illustration. Thanks.

john lucas

>

Re: Spindle turning

#8

Re: Spindle turning *LINK*

Chuck Engstrom

>All the advice given so far is right. 10,000 beads etc.

For beads I use, mostly, a 5/16" square bedan or beading/parting tool or whatever you want to call it (photo, also 1/4" version from H Taylor). Homemade from HSS stock from ENCO, $7.42 today (link). Sorby makes a slightly larger one, for much more $$$. I use the 5/16" on almost anything over 1", the 1/4" mostly on smaller stuff. 47 - 50 degree included angle is about right, by the way.

It's easy to figure out that you need to move the handle varying amounts on different axes, including rotation, as you cut. Getting it all together smoothly all at once is where the 10,000 comes in... My simile for all this is that it's like learning to drive on snow -- staying in control is a matter of practice, experience, finesse, and the "feel" for the road that you've developed over those many prior miles.

Two other thoughts:

1. Don't try to cut too much at one time. You'll have to push harder and that just invites a greater calamity.

2. Don't grip your tool too tightly, for pretty much the same reason as #1. If you are double-tense, any catch will just spiral back all the farther.

There is no substitute for practice.

Best--

Chuck


img

Enco 5/16" sq. x 8" HSS

Re: Spindle turning

#9

Re: Spindle turning

George Van

>Thanks for the help John, I will follow your advice!