>I am looking for a shorter tool rest for my PM3520. I have checked out the Best Tools modular system. A couple of questions. What are the positives/negatives for a round tool rest compared to to the flat inclined version. Also, does the fact that it is threaded together compromise rigigity. (Not an issue on a short one but how about on a curved one with a long cantilever.)
>I got 2 Robust toolrests from Bill Grumbine. He is the distributor. The price is surprisingly affordable and the shipping was fast. IMO, it has the best of both worlds. It has a small round rod tack welded to the slanted top, very well made. I don't know what kind of steel that is, but there is absolutely no drag. It allows room to hook my fingers underneath for better control.
I have the round tool rest. It cannot get close to the work because the horizontal round bar is on the center of the tool post. I don't like it for delicate work. I use it for roughing.
I love the Oneway tool rest for its function. But the cast iron top is not slick and needs constant maintenance to keep it super smooth.
I have the short post for the DVR; you can order them with long post for larger lathes. I was told they sold a lot of them to Powermatic owners. I am impressed with the quality of this Robust accessory.
>Funny how many differences there are in tool rests.
Some folks love the round bar tool rests. I find that I can't get as close to the workpiece with that style tool rest. The biggest concern for me is when turning platters. The banjo post extends an inch beyond the round bar tool rest. So the closest I can get the round tool rest to a platter is 1". I prefer a distance of 1/4" or less.
The robust tool rest, (The one in the picture on another response is called the "comfort rest".) can be placed closer but is still limited to 1/4" or more away. The Oneway rest lets me get closer an so that is the tool rest I use.
Two piece rests, (I have used the Sorby "modular tool rest") can come loose but it is very rare as long as the two pieces are securely screwed to each other. I have had more trouble with the rest rotating in the banjo (using any tool rest) than with the tool rest coming apart.
If you like the tool rest that comes with your Powermatic then buy another Powermatic tool rest and cut it down to the length that you desire. The advantage to this is that you will be using a tool rest that has the same tool rest profile you have become accustom to.
>Gordon, I hope no one will accuse me of highjacking this post, but I can't see how you can you hook your fingers under any part of this rest. I find it necessary to do so when using a skew. Otherwise, it looks great.
I use both the round type and the type (both cast iron and steel) that gets the edge very close to the work.
I see no difference in the basic function. The round type does put the rest a tiny bit further from the work but I do not find that a problem. In fact, sometimes I have to move the rest back from the work on purpose.
One difference I find is the round type of tool rest seems to allow the tool to slide more smoothly, both left and right but also in and out. For example, when touching the tool to the work it is sometimes useful to touch first high on the bevel, then pull the tool back while raising the handle gently until the edge begins cutting. If the tool rest is round, this operation is always smooth. If the tool rest has a flat on top as many do, at certain angles of presentation you can "hit" that flat spot during the in/out motion.
As for the Best Wood Tools version, I have a couple of those and they are very sturdy. The machined brass saddle holds the bar well (and looks good!) I think it was J.Lucas who pointed out once that they use a type of steel that dampens vibration. Very nice tools. I also have made some long, round rests by welding up mild steel rods.
>I bought the same modular rests from Woodcraft. They use a threaded post which will accept a variety of straight and curved rests. The posts are inexpensive. I have a short straight rest and a curved one, and I've been very happy with them.
>That works. I've done it with drill rod. I don't think it has the vibration reduction of the Bestwoodtool tool rests but in reality it's pretty subtle. I notice it more on the long curved bars.
I reallly want one of the Robust tool rests. If I was designing a flat tool rest that is the design I would us. Either that or something very close. My only reservations (and I don't have one yet) is the overall thickness. For some spindle work I like to wrap my fingers under the rest to push against the work for stability. it might be too large for that. My powermatic tools rests are too large for that. The round tool rests will let me do it.
>The only negative factor with the typical round bar as a tool rest is one of personal preferrence, geometry, and tool control. The radius of the rod, plus whatever clearance you have between the rod and the wood, is the closest you will ever get to the work. If that longer tool overhang is OK, there is no problem with "round". If you typically work closer to the wood than that, you will be disappointed with a "round" tool rest.