Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Collar for Hollow Form

Posts

Collar for Hollow Form

#1

Collar for Hollow Form

Barry Turner

>I have turned a couple of small hollow forms lately, my first two real hollow forms, actually. I have a small problem. I have turned collars for both forms from Ebony. The openings of the hollow forms are 1 1/4" and 1 3/4" with straight sides. The form thickness at the opening is approximately 1/4". I turned the collars with a small lip (1/16") with a drop-in fit into the opening.

Now, it seems the collars or the openings are expanding/contracting at different rates than the hollow form itself and the fit seems to be ever changing. The fit was perfect when I finishing fitting the collars. Now a few days later, it's too loose. With all of this expanding/contracting going on, I'm afraid the fit has too much clearance for a good glue joint. Do I need to use glue that has some flexibility? What type of glue should I use? CA? Polyvinyl? Aliphatic Resin? Gorilla Glue? Is there some fine point of collar fitting that I've missed? Advice please. Thanks.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#2

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Sounds like you turned the forms using wood that isn't dry and is still moving. I suggest that you remove the collars and set the wood aside to dry and become stable.

I use either yellow glue or CA glue. If the opening is very small I use the CA and install the collar after the piece is finished or nearly so. If the opeing is a bit larger I install the wood for a collar using yellow glue, then turn the collar as I shape the rim. In either case, I want the wood for both the vessel and the collar to be dry and stable.

Wally

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#3

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

Mike Andriacco

>Barry,

Don't rule out the idea that the ebony could have expanded from the heat of sanding. You didn't say if the collars have changed anymore since they shrunk. They could have cooled off a bit since then and shrunk.

Mike in Shreveport/Bossier City and back from Afghanistan

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#4

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

tm

>I found some flexible CA glue that MIGHT move enough with the wood

in a situation like you describe.

I turned some ebony last week and it developed cracks even though

I sanded at speeds under 200 rpm so I think Wally is probably

correct in suggesting that the moisture content was still high

when you turned it.

tm

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#5

Welcome Home Mike

tm

>

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#6

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

john lucas

>Barry First make sure they are both dry. Then I build up the smaller diameter using medium or thick CA. I re turn this area to size. If you can't get your finger in the hole of the collar you can use clear silicone caulk to glue the collar in. It's quite strong and permanent. The caulk isn't strong enough to pick up a large vessel with you finger inside the collar which is why I would never use it if they can get their finger inside.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#7

End Grain to Face Grain?

Ron in Drums PA

>Gluing end grain to face grain can also be a problem.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#8

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

charlie belden

>Could also be the grain orientation - woods change dimensions more tangentially than radially (acrossed growth rings vs between growth rings) and almost none axially (along the grain). And woods have significanly different shrinkage values - one may only shrink 4% acrossed the grain while another might shrink 12% acrossed the grain.

Look at the Circle/Oval at the right. Now imagine that your piece has the grain running "up/down" and your collar has its grain running "left/right"

Here's an illustration that might explain how wood changes dimensions as it gains or loses moisture. More useful for Flat Work woodworking but turners have to deal with wood movement too.


img

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#9

the wood movement would be pretty small

john lucas

>I don't have the chart in front of me but a 1 3/4" piece of ebony doesn't move much. I don't know what the bottom wood is and that could be where the wood movement is coming from. I would agree that most likely one or the other wasn't completely dry when freshly turned.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#10

Re: Welcome Home

Danny Wells

>Welcome home Mike, glad your back safely.

Danny in Many, LA

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#11

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

Danny Wells

>Turkey call makers who make what we call pot calls, use Plumber's Goop to adhere slate or glass to the pot. The pot is a flat shallow bowl turned face grain. The goop will fill gaps and is flexible.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#12

Thanks all!

Mike Andriacco

>Thanks for the welcome home and for those that wrote while I was over there. I'm sorry I kinda slipped off the radar but it got pretty busy there for awhile. Danny, I'm shooting you an e-mail right now.

Mike in Shreveport/Bossier City, LA

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#13

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

Barry Turner

>Welcome back. I'm not sure I can tell if the Ebony collar shrank or if the opening in the hollow form expanded. I'm leaning towards the Ebony shrinking. The stuff had been in my shop for a couple of years. You'd think it would be dry by now.

Re: Collar for Hollow Form

#14

Re: the wood movement would be pretty small

Barry Turner

>I'm thinking it's the Ebony. By the way the Ebony collar is turned end grain. The Mesquite hollow form is face grain orientation. The pieces were small and I thought any wood movement would be also. Guess I was wrong.