Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

Posts

How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#1

How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Is there an easy way to distinguish between honey locust and black locust, without looking at the leaves? For instance, if a tree has been felled and cut into logs, and I am told it's locust but not sure which, how can I determine if it's honey or black? I live near Washington, DC, in case it makes any difference.

Thanks much.

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#2

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black loc

Ralph Watts

>Honey locust has a slightly rosy tint with a small variation in the summer/winter growth rings. Black locust has very dark and light growth rings. If the log has bark, the honey locust will have thorns looking like your worst nightmare while the black locust has none.

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#3

Re:Black locust does have thorns, ....

Jamie Donaldson

>.....but nothing like those on honey locust. Black locust is usually a slightly yellowish/greenish variation, and has a somewhat rougher bark, and annual rings that are darker than honey locust.

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

Land and street-scape Honey locust rarely ....

Leo Van Der Loo

>have the big thorns, even wild grown Honey locust occur without the large thorns, and yes Black locust has small thorns on the branches and a pair of thorns at the leaf scar.

Like was said, the Honey locust has more a plate like bark and Black locust a much more ridged bark.

The wood color from Honey locust is reddish in color and the Black locust is a greenish yellow

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#5

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Land and street-scape Honey locust rarely ....

Leo Van Der Loo

>Here are a couple of links that show both the Honey and Black locust tree bark and more

HTH

http://www.fcps.k12.va.us/StratfordLandingES/Ecology/mpages/black_locust.htm

http://www.oplin.org/tree/fact%20pages/honeylocust_thornless/honeylocust_thornless.html

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#6

Here's a good source

GaryG in MD

>Hi Ilya,

This site has some good answers:

http://au.answers.yahoo.com/answers2/frontend.php/question?qid=20070804141515AAQfT4A

The other good way to tell them apart is the bark -- the black locust has ropey bark, while the honey locust bark is better described as "scaly".

Hope to see you next month, Gary

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#7

Thanks!

Ilya Zavorin

>Big thanks to everyone.

Ilya

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black locust?

#8

Re: How do I distinguish between honey & black loc

robo hippy

>The seed pods are different also. The ones on the Black locust are small, about the size of a pea, with small seeds inside. The ones on a Honey Locust are much bigger, and have seeds that reminded me of milk duds. Wild life eat them, and I have heard that some people have used them to brew with their beer. There is a Moraine Locust which I was told is a hybrid of the Honey Locust and doesn't have the thorns. It also gets fairly large, up to about 30 inches diameter that I have seen. There are also several varities of this. Black Locust is supposed to glow under untra violet light.

robo hippy