Question on Harvesting a Burl
Philip Morris
>Can a burl be harvested from a live, standing tree without killing it? If yes, please indicate best way to do it to minimize damage to the tree.
Thanks,
Philip
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Question on Harvesting a Burl
Philip Morris
>Can a burl be harvested from a live, standing tree without killing it? If yes, please indicate best way to do it to minimize damage to the tree.
Thanks,
Philip
The short answer is: maybe
steve antonucci
>It really depends upon how the burl is growing and how much damage the tree will be forced to withstand from the cutting. A tree can be killed by "ringing" it with a very small, shallow cut around the trunk because the outer sapwood carries all of the nutrients.
Personally, I'd never cut something off of a living tree just because I wanted to turn it. Wait for the tree to die naturally, or risk killing it for the burl.
Seems like an easy decision to me.
Steven
Re: The short answer is: maybe
Brian McInturff
>Steve,
I had heard you could cut the burls off as long as you didn't cut into the tree. Basically, if you slab it off parallel to the tree. I'm not all that knowledgeable so I'm only going off what I've read.
Hence the maybe
steve antonucci
>If the burl goes all the way around, you end up cutting more of the sapwood. The sapwood is what connects the leaves and the roots and if you lose too much of it, you disrupt the "system". It also introduces an open wound to allow insects and other diseases easy access.
Could someone cut it and the tree survive? Perhaps, but if you have to ask, it's probably a bad idea.
Steven
Sure.
Dave Winters
>I have many times done this with no ill effects to the tree whatsoever. We're talking about Aspen burls that stick right out from the trunk, and just lopped off plumb.Some going on 20 years ago now.
Re: Question on Harvesting ...
Mike Jones, Redding, CA
>I've cut black oak, live oak, and cottonwood burls with no apparent harm. The black oak scars were sealed with "blackjack" (roof patch) after cutting. If your tree is the only shade tree in your front yard, however,....
Re: Question on Harvesting a Burl
Philip Morris
>Ya'll thanks for the responses.
Steve, I am kindof in your camp. I feel there is enough wood down or being taken down, that I don't cut on trees that are healthy and standing.
This is a tree of a cousin, who wants a bowl. I do think that the bowl just sticks out from the tree. His thought is to just cut it off like one would cut off a branch, then seal it with a cut sealer.
Re: Question on Harvesting a Burl
Dick Hines
>Here we go again. Search for my post "Big Burl" or by my name. I cut a tree down that was going to be cut anyway and the post went on fro weeks about rather to do it or not.
I would not cut the burl off a living tree unless the tree was going to cut down anyway. In my case I took the whole tree burl and all.
Be careful with any wound sealer
Don Orr
>My nephew, an arborist, says the current thinking on wound sealing a cut on a tree is to not use it any more. It holds in moisture as well as any fungus or other pathogen which can lead to more problems for the tree. There is a school of thought on using plain old shellac as a wound treatment, thinking the alcohol in the shellac would kill pathogens and keep them out for long enough for the tree to start healing on its own. A burl may not have the same collar of tissue around it that a branch does and may not heal well, leaving a large open wound subject to infection.
I'm with Steve in that I would not cut a burl off a living tree just to make a bowl. I can probably be done, but pruning trees takes knowledge and experience, just like turning. Pruning done properly can actually enhance a trees' health, done poorly can kill it.
Re: Question on Harvesting a Burl
glenn hodges
>I have done it, but you can use a sealer on the tree if you are worried.
Re: Question on Harvesting a Burl
Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner
>I personally would not take any burl where the cut would cover more than 25 % of the Dia.
Bill in CG, AZ.