>There are dream woods and devil woods - the dream woods turn nicely and behave during and after drying. The devil woods seem fated to self destruct no matter what you do. And "Pith In" turning seems to bring out the worst in even the dream woods.
So I'm searching for Predictors of Dream Woods and Devil Woods and I think I've found one - the ratio of Tangential shrinkage to Radial shrinkage values - the T/R Ratio.
If you've done some pith in turning with any of the woods in the T/R Ratio chart on the attached web page I'd like to know if your experience agrees with the T/R Ratio chart. I'd be particularly interested in hearing from some experienced turners who have found a drying method that works consistently for them to eliminate drying rate problems and focus on the characteristics of the specific woods.
Wood is such an interesting materilal. The more understanding of it, the easier it is to play with.
>Several ways to handle this. One of easiest is to use Cole jaws on your chuck to hold the ring. Flatten one side by taking a light facing cut then sand using a sanding board. To make up a sanding board use the belt (80 grit) for a belt sander glued to a piece of 3/4" plywood cut 4" wide and as long as the belt you will use. I use spray adhesive and after cutting glue it to both sides of the board. Hold the board up and sand at a slow speed watching the end of the board to make sure it isn't rocking. I mark all over the surface with a soft pencil and then sand until all the lines are gone. Check to see if it is flat with a straight edge. My next step is to then stick the chuck with the ring still in place in the tailstock using a chuck adaptor and glue to the prior ring using pressure from the tailstock. Wait an hour and then face off and sand the other side and go to the next ring.
If you don't have Cole jaws you could use two sided tape and stick it to a large faceplate for the initial sanding.
>Mesquite, which is not on the list, should be at, or near the top of the list. I would place Pacific Madrone at the bottom of the list. It moves like no other wood I've turned when wet.
Here are a couple data points. I work a lot with Black Oak and Pacific Madrone, freely available to me. Two of the worst in the chart you presented. The Madrone is a major challenge, even when turned thin (1/4".) Black Oak is very forgiving. Both dry quite oval, Madrone a bit more so. But the Black Oak rarely cracks, even when over 10% of diameter, and if it does typically hairline cracks. I think other factors are at play also, water content, fine vs open grain, straight vs. wandering grain, binding between the cells, something, many somethings...
Another observation: The surface of a dryed Madrone shows clearly the undulations of variations in cell collapse (a feature I like) but the Black Oak has almost no surface evidence of cell collapse except at bark inclusions or the like. This makes me think that the Oak may start out as somewhat dryer wood, with more consistent traits of "give" or cell collapse as it deforms and shrinks.
My guess is that this is a very complex phenomenon to model, with indicators that are not all available and correlated at present. A bit like global warming.
Your chart doesn't make sense. For exampe, I see several entries for "Ash" (with a comma) ranging from about 1.5 to 2.0. The comma is used elsewhere in the species list to separate the primary common name from the sub-name. Perhaps the formatting of the text dropped part of some names. Also, the size of the chart makes it difficult to read - I had to drop the graphic into graphic program and expand it before my aging eyes could read the text. (I did like the instructions at the top and bottom of the page - maybe every page on the internet needs that! VBG)
I think there are several problems with trying predict the inclination of a piece of wood to crack solely by considering the T/R ratio. One is that the T/R ratio can vary widely in members of the same species, and even in different places of the same tree. For example, as mentioned earlier the juvenile wood around the pith may behave differently from that of mature wood, as will reaction wood.
Another thing (which I didn't see in your earlier analysis of shrinkage around the pith) is the effect of the rays. From what I read, the rays are instrumental both in providing strength as well as limiting shrinkage in a radial direction.
However, rays, especially large rays, are evidently also a major contributor to radial cracks. A ray is strong along it's length but very weak across it's width. Hoadley states it this way, "The rays, consisting totally of parenchyma cells, represent planes of structural weakness in the wood. In drying wood, stresses often create checks in the plane of the rays." Since shrinkage of any wood fiber is more across it's small dimensions than it's length (due to the greater percentage of cell wall to cell dimension in those directions), and a ray is a bundle of fibers with little transverse strength, shrinkage from drying can pull the ray apart providing a pathway to propagation of a larger crack, especially in exposed end grain.
Given most fibers in a tree are oriented longitudinally (the reason we can split firewood), it seems to me that the presence of these interlocking radial rays (and more specifically, their size, number, distribution and strength) are both the primary reason for the magnitude of tangential to radial shrinkage ratio AND the reason cracks and checks tend to form radially. There are few (any?) circumferentially orientated fibers in a tree to provide strength in that direction.
Also, I suspect the variation in plasticity of the cells in specific type of wood contributes to it's strength while drying. Anecdotally, I've had some turnings warp badly but not check, while others warped less but did develop checks.
>Wood certainly is an amazing material and fun to work with.
What I prefer to do is work with and not against it. And in order to do that I need to understand certain things about it. In this case I want to turn wet "pith in" branches and not have to fight with wood that doesn't, by its very nature, want to cooperate. While there are probably several dozen factors that contribute to "pith in" cracking I'm looking for one, or a few, MAJOR "indicators"
I think the T/R Ratio MAY be one readily available "indicator" of how to tell "cooperative wood" from "uncooperative wood" - specifically or wet "pith in" turning.
Getting the T/R Ratio info into an understandable and easy to use form takes some work - like getting things legible -without squinting or standing on your head.
So I've redone the T/R Ratio to Common Wood Names graphic to make it a little more User Friendly. Would like some more feedback if you'd be so kind.
>Some of your entries are still ambiguous, for example "cedar", is it white, red, eastern, western?. From the numbers, perhaps it's Alaska-cedar or Cedar elm. What is "rock"? I assume "Pignut" and "Shagbark" are both hickories?
Here is a longer list if you want it, perhaps more complete. (source, WOOD.XLS: Wood Handbook-Wood as an Engineering Material; Forest Products Society; Hardwoods of North America; USDA; etc.)
1.22 magnolia, Southern
1.30 birch, yellow
1.37 birch, paper
1.38 birch, sweet
1.39 pine, pond
1.41 pine, slash
1.41 basswood, American
1.42 persimmon, common
1.42 walnut, black
1.42 juniper, western
1.43 hickory, mockernut
1.44 oak, live
1.47 pine, longleaf
1.50 hickory, shagbark
1.50 cedar, Port-Orford-
1.52 cedar, eastern redcedar
1.54 pine, loblolly
1.54 ash, green
1.55 sassafras
1.56 pine, lodgepole
1.56 ash, black
1.56 Douglas-fir, interior west
1.57 locust, black
1.57 honeylocust
1.58 cedar, incense-
1.58 Douglas-fir, coast
1.59 pine, ponderosa
1.59 ash, white
1.60 hickory, pignut
1.63 baldcypress
1.66 hickory, shellbark
1.66 spruce, black
1.66 alder, red
1.67 pine, shortleaf
1.68 sycamore, American
1.69 elm, rock
1.69 magnolia, cucumbertree
1.69 redwood, old-growth
1.70 ash, pumpkin
1.71 tupelo, black
1.71 pine, Virginia
1.74 spruce, Sitka
1.76 fir, California red
1.77 magnolia, sweetbay
1.78 poplar-yellow
1.78 pine, jack
1.80 pine, western white
1.81 tupelo, water
1.82 Douglas-fir, interior north
1.82 elm, slippery
1.82 hickory, pecan
1.85 hackberry
1.86 hemlock, western
1.86 cedar, Atlantic white-
1.87 spruce, Engelmann
1.88 oak, white
1.88 butternut
1.89 pine, red
1.91 aspen, quaking
1.92 cherry, black
1.92 maple, bigleaf
1.92 oak, willow
1.92 sweetgum
1.93 fir, noble
1.93 pine, sugar
1.94 maple, black
1.96 birch, river
1.97 chestnut, American
1.98 ash, Oregon
2.00 tamarack
2.02 larch, western
2.05 maple, red
2.05 spruce, red
2.06 pine, radiata (Monterey)
2.06 holly, American
2.06 maple, sugar
2.08 cedar, western redcedar
2.09 fir, Pacific silver
2.12 fir, white
2.14 cedar, Alaska-
2.15 oak, Northern red
2.16 beech, American
2.17 elm, cedar
2.19 elm, winged
2.21 fir, grand
2.21 madrone, Pacific
2.23 oak, water
2.23 cedar, Northern white-
2.23 redwood, young-growth
2.25 buckeye, yellow
2.26 elm, American
2.27 hemlock, eastern
2.36 cottonwood, eastern
2.38 fir, balsam
2.39 tanoak
2.39 cottonwood, black
2.40 oak, overcup
2.40 maple, silver
2.40 oak, Southern red
2.48 oak, laurel
2.52 oak, black
2.64 willow, black
2.85 fir, subalpine
2.90 pine, eastern white
If you don't have WOOD.XLS, you probably should. Great resource.
>Most of the data is for heart wood, which is the commercially important part.
In my experience, sap wood and heart wood can have very different properties while drying.
For example, I've played with shagbark hickory a little. A disk that is pure sapwood will not crack on drying. A disk that has heart wood in the center (about 1/2 the radius) will split wide open every time with the split running all the way to the pith.
On the other hand, oak sap wood (both red and white families) seems to have a larger tangential shrinkage on drying than the heart wood, leading to radial cracks that are in the sap wood only.
>Very interesting chart, and it seems to agree with my experience. Persimmon is probably my favorite wood, in part because of its stability. Honey locust is very stable -- it looks and behaves like mesquite. Magnolia and sweet gum rarely crack but often warp. I have had many unhappy experiences with various oaks. The champion cracker is one of the most beautiful of native woods, dogwood, which did not appear in the chart.
Cracking and warping obviously involve complex factors and probably different factors are responsible for cracking versus warping. Taking the risks is part of the fun of turning wood.
Now, how about a discussion of repairing cracks? Repaired cracks can become features and add character.