Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Thompson tools and Tormek ???

Posts

Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#1

Thompson tools and Tormek ???

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Actually, my question is limited to Thompson skews. Have you sharpened these excellent tools on a Tormek system? If so, were you pleased with the results? Did you notice a difference between a Thompson skew sharpened on a regular wheel and one sharpened on a Tormek?

Now address the same question for other Thompson tools, please.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#2

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Ed

I was very unhappy with my Thompson detail gouge until I started using my Tormek. I grade the wheel with the fine side of the stone before I sharpen. My Thompson bowl gouge is still sharpened on my other grinder because I only use it for roughing. When I want to get a super fine cut I use a Crown PM gouge.

Terry

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#3

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

wilbur

>I don't have a regular grinder so I can't make a direct comparison, but I have a Tormek and have been using Doug Thompson's tools. In fact, the first Thompson tool I used was a 1 1/4" skew. I've very happy with the edge that I get off of the Tormek with this and my other Thompson tools.

When I first tried sharpening the skew, it took a little while because I wanted to give the edge a curved profile like Alan Lacer has in his skew videos. But once I had the profile established, resharpening takes almost no time.

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#4

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

john lucas

>The juries still out for me. I have the Sheppack grinder which is similar to the Tormek although the quality of the machine isn't quite as good. I first sharpened my skew on an 8" white wheel grinder and then honed it with diamond hones followed by a strop with green compound.

The next time I decided to use the Sheppack which I just purchased. It seemed to do an excellent job but I had to run to the house to get water because I don't have running water in the shop.

As long as I can hone it on the green leather wheel it works great. If it gets to dull for that I prefer to use the diamond hones to restore the edge. It removes less metal than going back to the grinder.

I don't like sharpening spindle gouges and bowl gouges on it because it's very easy to groove the wheels and I purchased that sharpener to handle the duty of plane irons, chisels, and carving tools. I don't want to damage the stone for that. I've been perfectly happy with my 100 grit white wheels for the thompson tools although I do touch up the inside with a diamond fish hook sharpener

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#5

Thompson tools and ... ???

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Jet wet grinder. I just ordered one from Woodcraft (actually, back-ordered) since it looks as if this Jet and the Tormek are about equivalent, except in price.

The comments here and my suspicions caused me to want to try these excellent tools after sharpening them on a water wheel. I also make the 1/4" round skews like Bob Rosand makes and I think a final sharpening on a water wheel might be good.

Thanks to all who respond(ed),

Ed

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#6

Jet and Tormek

wilbur

>I've found that the build quality between the Jet and the Tormek are different enough that I went for the Tormek. There have been several reports about the Jet regarding the bar that the jigs ride on flexing or not being truly square with the rotation of the wheel, and the motor not being up to snuff (see links below). YMMV, but make sure that you check these things out when your sharpener arrives. I also know people who are very happy with their Jet.

It's kind of like choosing a Thompson bowl gouge over a regular M2 steel bowl gouge. Both will make you a bowl, one will be nicer to use.

http://www.joewoodworker.com/tormek.htm

http://www.yucholian.com/woodwk/jet_sharpener.htm

http://www.yucholian.com/woodwk/tormek.htm

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#7

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

Fog Tanner

>I sharpen all my Thompson tools on a Tormek. This would include my flat and round skews. My Thompson skews actually get sharper than my M2 skews on the Tormek. I usually use the 1000 grit but will occasionally use the 220 for gouges. I sharpen all my gouges on the Tormek now. I was useing my 8" slow speed Delta with a 100/120 grit stone for my 5/8" bowl gouges, but all I use it for is scrapers now. I found how to set the Tormek to get the swept back grind ("Ellsworth") so now I sharpen those on the Tormek as well. The edge is definatly sharper than the 100/120 grit dry grinder.

I do hone the skews and sometimes the gouges on the leather wheel. I will typically alternate between the stone and the leather wheel. I go to the sone one time and the leather the next. This appears to put the razor edge back for me. I do this on both the M2 and Thompson tools. I do notice more of a difference in the Thomposn tools when using the 1000 grit and leather wheel, than I do with the M2. In my usage, the Thompson will have a sharper edge than the M2.

I don't know how that will work with the Jet, I have read that their wheels are softer than the Tormek. There is a Japanese water stone that will fit the Tormek, but it is too soft too. It is the same color as the one on the Jet and may be the same stone. You will just have to use it and find out of the wheel wear is excessive. I use the wheel with the rotation away from me, which is different than described in the Tormek book. It is less agressive, but I am addressing the bevel and not reshaping.

On the Jet, you may want to check the material that the shaft is made from. It it is not stainless steel, it would be a good idea to remove the stone and grease the shaft with water pump grease every 6 months of so. The stone will rust to the shaft (regardless of that fool comparsion article - was done by a bozo that never used his Tormek), and it takes some work to get it off without breaking the stone. Just replaced my Tormek with their stainless upgrade, so I know they stone can get "welded" to the shaft if you use the tool.

Fog

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#8

Re: Jet and Tormek

john lucas

>When I got the Sheppac the motor was really weak which I found to be a common complaint. I simply installed a spring to pull the motor into the wheel. I'll be it pulls as good as the Tormek now. I don't think they are the same quality but I can't justify the price of the Tormek and got the Sheppac for $100. It looks like many of the Jet and Griz and Tormek accessories will fit it.

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#9

Wilbur, thank you for ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>your comments and the reviews. I read them all and have reached the conclusion that none of these machines is perfect, nor are the wheels that are on them. But used properly, each of the machines will do the job very well. My conclusion at this point is that I MAY have saved $200 by purchasing the Jet Sharpening System. And as you said, my mileage may vary.

My intended use is for skews, which I sharpen freehand on a platform so that I can get a good rounded (Lacer) edge. However, I want a good straight edge on the 1/4" round skews that I make and that is accomplished freehand without a platform. These edges burn easily and I don't want evidence of burning on the completed tool, hence a water-cooled machine comes to mind.

One accessory I will need is for sharpening scissors. My wife is an accomplished weaver and she asked the other day if I could sharpen her scissors. Okay, you see the wheels beginning to spin in my little head, the flashing red light that indicates "You can buy a tool here!" is going off, and the little smile appears on my face as the plan emerges. And I hear myself say, "Sure, I can do that for you, honey.".

And I am starting to wonder just how the new Thompson 1 1/4" SRG will respond to the JSS. (Okay, Jet Sharpening System)

Ed

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#10

Tormek and scissor sharpening *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>"One accessory I will need is for sharpening scissors."

I now use my Woodcraft grinder and Wolverine for my turning tools and rarely use my Tormek. This is more because of the hassle of getting water and setting it up rather than the quality of the sharpening.

One thing that I always use it for though is sharpening my wife's sewing scissors. This feature alone is almost worth the price. Take a look at Jeff's demo video. If you follow it you can't go wrong.


Tormek Video

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#11

Re: Tormek and scissor sharpening

John K Jordan

>I agree - the Tormek is great for sharpening sissors. (I use it for most of my turning tools as well.)

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#12

Re: Tormek and scissor sharpening

Terry Q

>Since I cut all my sandpaper with a scissor I use my Tormek attachment a lot. It was well worth the price.

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#13

Thank you, Stuart, ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I watched the video and was pleased to see that it was as easy as I thought it would be. I haven't managed to save the video to my computer, but I am sure that it can be done.

Ed

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#14

pair of *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Oops, I mean "scissors" not "sissors". I have no idea what a sissor is but I'd hate to try to sharpen one.

I did find out that a "scissor" is just one blade, making sense of the term "pair of scissors". Guess you can't cut out a pant with a scissor.

JKJ


http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-pai1.htm

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#15

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

Pascal Oudet

>same experience here: I wanted to change the wheel (after ~6 years of good service it was quite small), the nut was rust-soldered to the shaft and I had no other solution than breaking the wheel to remove it. where can you order stainless steel shaft ? thanks

Pascal

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#16

Pascal, ask these folks ... *LINK*

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I hope that you get a response.

Ed


Tormek/Fr

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#17

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ??? *LINK*

Fog Tanner

>Mine was about the same age. It is a great machine except for that one issue, which is fixed on the new models. I can't complain about mine with the job it has done and the usage I have gotten. I use it several times a day 5-6 days a week, everyday I turn.

I did get it off without breaking the wheel. The nut actually came off after using some Liquid Wrench. I had to drill the washers almost through to the stone and then split them apart. I drilled part of the shaft away in the process and finally the end so I could use a piece of 1/2" rod to drive it out. The wheel was supported during all this, but I stll lost a little of the plastic insert around the center. The shaft will never be used on a Tormek again, but the wheel is still good. Everyone I know that has a Tormek that is about the same age and actually uses it has the same problem. I have another one to rebuild right now for a friend of mine.

I bought all the new replacement parts from Sharptools USA. I replaced the shaft, washers, and nut with stainless steel. I also replaced the bearings. This brings it up to the current model. And since I was doing that, I stripped the paint off and reprimed and painted the frame. The new ones are powder coated, and I looked at that. But for $125 I could buy a number of cans of paint and primer. Runs like it was when it was new and looks better.


SharpTools USA

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#18

Re: Wilbur, thank you for ...

Fog Tanner

>I sharpen all my skews, both flat and round, using one of the Tormek jigs. I prefer the slight radius that Raffan uses and the jig will achive that while holding the tool flat. All my 3/8", 1/2", 3/4", and 1" have the same radius and bevel angle that way. The radius I get is the same as the one that Raffan put on one of my tools when he sharpened it during a workshop. I did use the platform for my scrapers, but decided to use the dry grinder for those.

Re: Thompson tools and Tormek ???

#19

Re: Pascal, ask these folks ...

Pascal

>thanks for your answers Ed and Fog. I'll try to contact them

Pascal