Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

Posts

Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#1

Aage Rendalen

Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

Aage Rendalen

>I love my Ellsworth gauge. That's all I use, with the exception of a detail gauge for the foot when I reverse turn. On the inside of bowls it works perfectly. I have no need of a second gauge as I transition from the side to the bottom. And I get a very smooth finish off the gauge.

But not on the outside. That is, when I use pull cuts on the outside, working from the tenon to the rim, I get serious tear-outs. Push cuts, when the tail stock allows for the it, work fine.

What's happening?

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#2

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

john lucas

>Is it a sidegrain or endgrain bowl? On a side grain you should go from foot to rim. The problem may be that you have the edge perpendicular to the direction the wood is traveling. I lower the tool rest a whole lot so I'm still cutting at or above center but I can hold the tool, handle down so the edge is cutting at an angle. You can't do this at the foot but as you proceed out the bowl you can usually change the angle by lowering the handle to get more of a shear cut.

If it's an endgrain bowl then you should be turning from the rim down toward the foot when on the outside of the bowl.

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#3

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

Darryl

>John's probably correct. Drop the heel of the tool. Try to get Edlsworth's video it shows the various cuts very well.

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#4

Look at the edge

Steven Kubien

>John is right in that you probably need to drop the handle, so much so that it will be the side or wing that is doing the cutting. That edge should be a low angle to the oncoming wood...45� or less. What you get is a similar action to a paring chisel fine tuning a joint or a finishing plane taking the last, fine pass.

HTH,

Steve Kubien

Oh yeah, this is all easier to control (in my experience) if the side wings are flat when viewed from the side, not humped or rounded. To get this you will have to spend more time grinding the wings of your gouge, particularly the front third or so.

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#5

Aage Rendalen

Ellsworth's hump

Aage Rendalen

>My bowls are all side grain. Since I have not lowered my tool rest, the cutting tip of the gauge rides fairly high above the center line. I'll try to lower the tool rest.

By the way, what are the plus or minuses of keeping Ellsworth's high wing "hump"?

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#6

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

GaryG in MD

>Aage,

I'm no expert, but from what I've seen on videos, a pull cut is a roughing cut meant for rapid removal of material. It is not a finishing cut, regardless of which direction you take it. I could be wrong, but that's the way I understand it.

JM2c, Gary

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#7

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

john lucas

>A pull cut can be very clean depending on the angle of the grind on the wing and how steep you can use it on the wood. I started doing this cut many years ago when making my hand mirrors. At the time I didn't know some of the techniques I know today so I developed a grind and a pull cut that I thought were my own. It turns out Avelino Samual had the same grind that he had been using.

I developed this grind because I had to go from the center out to cut down hill with the grain on my mirrors. This required a pull cut using the wings on the side.

Our grind (and since then I've seen some others) has a long wing, about twice as long as Ellsworths. I also grind this on a steep sided bowl gouge. Because of this the wings are very sharp, about 25 degrees. When you put this sharp of a cut at a steep angle you get a very clean cut.

The downside is that your lathe must have the capability to lower the tool rest far enough that you can achieve this steeper angle. Also the control of the gouge must come from your body because you are riding the side bevel. This means rotating the tool is the control over the cut. If your riding the nose of the tool you have the control of the length of the handle. This provides a very fine control over the cut where the side grind pull cut relies on a twist of the handle for much of the control.

For the outside of a bowl it cuts very fast when the cutting edge is more or less horizontal to the rotation. Once you have the shape close rotate lower that handle so the cutting edge is about 45 degrees and you get a very clean finishing cut. It does require some skill in tool control to get a perfect shape.

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#8

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

Dennis in Southern Oregon

>The 45-degree bevel rubbing cut is very effective for many woods, but I occasionally find that I get chip-out with curly grained woods. In that case try a shear scraping cut. Use the same low rest position and 45-degree angle, but rotate the gouge until the flute is almost pointing toward the wood (but still scraping on the lower edge of the flute). With a very light touch, you can usually get a very nice finish. Dennis

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#9

what's an ellsworth gauge?

M Meyers

>gauge: a measuring instrument for measuring and indicating a quantity such as the thickness of wire or the amount of rain etc.

never have seen an ellsworth gauge? what's he measuring?

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#10

Re: Hump?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Explain please? The profile on a properly ground gouge has a bit of a curve that get a bit steeper toward the node, but I'm not sure what you mean about a "hump". Here's a pic of his grind to help.


img

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#11

Re: Hump?

Steven Kubien

>Mark,

I think "properly ground" is a relative term since I doubt there are 5 of us with the exact same grinds. The way Jamieson explained it to me was that he removes that curve you illustrated, so that the tool is a straight line from the tip to where the wing disappears. I cannot speak for others but it sure makes shear-scraping and push cuts easier without that curve.

Steve Kubien

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#12

Aage Rendalen

Thanks. I'll try it out today

Aage Rendalen

>I appreciate your help (even with spelling--English is a second language for me), and I'm looking forward to trying out your suggestions on the rest of my cherry blanks.

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#13

Re: Okay

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Now I understand. Don't agree, but understand. A curved edge against a curved surface gives (me anyway) more control over the tool and the cut since I hold my gouge horizontal. I do shear cutting from rim to foot with the tool in the same position and the curve at the nose of the tool works to slice while the trailing wing finishes the separation. Gives me lovely angel hair almost as fine as those produced by a shear scrape. I could not do that with a flat cutting edge.

As always, Steve, different strokes

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#14

Re: Hump?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I've tried the "straight" grind and didn't care for it. Seems to me it would be difficult to shear scrape the curved surface on the inside of a bowl with a straight grind.

Wally

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#15

thanks, John...

GaryG in MD

>That's good information. I don't have a gouge sharpened like that, but I'll have to try one some time. Seems a little scary though, working out on the wing like that -- sounds like a catch waiting to happen (for me, anyway). ...Gary

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#16

Mark and Wally

Steven Kubien

>Yup, different strokes. I have only been sharpening the gouge this way for a few weeks, since my time with Jamieson. So far, I really like it and I haven't a catch. Push and pull cuts, scraping and shear scraping. We'll see as time passes if I keep doing things this way.

Cheers!

Steve Kubien

Re: Ellsworth gauge pull cut tear-outs

#17

Re: The Lucas Grind

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>John,

You should put a pic in the Tool Grinds Library.