>I inherited a couple of old skews...one that is only 1 3/4" long that barely reaches the wood and is ready to be put to rest, and one that is made from an old file.
I vaguely remember a discussion of skews made from old files, remembering that some said this was not a good idea because of danger of shattering. Is this true? Should one use a turning tool made from a 1" x 3/16" file? Why or why not?
>The original suggestion I'd run across was of making a scraper out of an old file. I was warned that unless the file was heat treated to temper it, that the metal, made extremely hard so's to be able to cut metal was therefore also brittle and could possibly shatter
>I recommend that old files be used for something other than turning tools. As mentioned before, the steel in files is very hard and is brittle and can break if used very far off the tool rest. I had that happen once in one of my classes. A student was injured slightly. Since then I haven't allowed files to be used in my classes. Also, unless a lot of grinding is done to get rid of the file teeth it would be very rough on tool rests.
>I know I wrote an article on using files as turning tools. I did so because I ran into many turners who were told using a file was fine, mostly by older turners. I did a bunch of research and testing and found out that in fact you could make a file into a usable tool with proper heat treating so I wrote an article on how to make a file into a reasonably safe tool because I felt that people were going to use them whether I told them to or not. I thought I was doing a service by instructing people how to anneal and temper a file to make it less dangerous. Maybe that was correct or maybe I just enhanced the desire for turners to use a file as a turning tool.
Here's why not to use a file. #1 GRinding off the teeth is a pain even if you've annealed it. It's really hard if you haven't annealed it. As Wally said you gotta get those suckers of there unless you really like ruining your tool rest. #2 If you don't do anything to the file it's flat out dangerous. It will shatter when broken instead of just breaking off or bending.You could easily be injured by high speed projectiles. #3You don't really know what kind of steel it is so you don't know what hardness you have achieved by the tempering process. A steel that is too hard will shatter. #4 It is so much easier to make a tool out of a known steel that you can easily and inexpensively purchase and can get exact heat treating literature to properly temper the steel.
Last but not least. If it were a tool that you hang over the tool rest 1/4" or so I might say go ahead, it would be hard to break it. However a skew not only hangs over the tool rest further but is easy to get a catch by the less skilled. This can easily lead to a shattered piece of steel. It's just not worth it.
>Both skews were made by my wife's grandfather sometime between 1930 and 1970. I think they will look just fine hanging on my basement "antique tool" wall.
>I had bought a box of old files at an auction for this purpose (actually, scrapers). Aside from the hours I spent getting it to an edge and removing teeth, the shattering issue is very real. I was lucky that mine just snapped and the piece flew in the other direction, but it's not a good idea.
You'd be better off buying steel at the store and working forward instead of backwards...
Having a catch on a skew is real. I have seen it happened to very famous professional turners as well. It only takes a little off concentration. It just doesn't happen as frequent as we and they can use the skew and tell jokes at the same time.
A Harbor Freight 8 pc HSS set is only thirty something dollars with coupon. It is averaging about $4 per tool. In each set it has 5 flat tools that you can regrind to skews including the skew in it. I converted some of mine to special scrapers.
If you consider you are paying yourself half of the minimum wage, grinding old file to skew is more expensive than the HF tool. They are Chinese HSS, not the same quality as Sheffield tool steel, not even close to the Thompson tools. But it will be much safer than converting old files.
I'm not much of a tool maker, and wouldn't try to make one. I just have a couple of homemade, inherited skews that were made from files that I have never tried to use.
You are right about the Harbor Freight set. I have one that I use (at least some of the tools) regularly. In my hands, they do just as good a job as my more expensive "name" tools. I learned from the last meeting that what I thought was "sharp" was like calling a table knife sharp, then being introduced to a razor edge. No wonder I couldn't cut with my skew...it was probably closer to the edge of a 2x4 than what Mr. Grumbine showed in his demo.