Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Posts

1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#1

1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Joe Pack

>I am looking at ebay right now (7:20 p.m., edt), hoping to get a new 1 3/8" Lacer Skew, but the bid price just went to $103 plus shipping ($110 as of now). Too rich for my blood, although this particular model is the 2030 steel that retails for +/- $160 at Rockler and such. The regular M2 steel variety goes for about $112 retail. (With the regular 20% off coupons I get by e-mail or with a turners club discount, I can buy the M2 version for about $90 almost any time.) I imagine the $103 is a good price for the "better" steel, but this got me wondering...

For the average woodturner, is the premium price for the premium steel worth the money? It will supposedly hold an edge 2-3 times longer, but is there an added difficulty in sharpening that is a negative for the average person?

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#2

FYI - 5/8 M2 going for $32

Joe Pack

>FYI - With about 30 minutes left, a 5/8 M2 Lacer skew is going for $32 + s/h. Only 2 Lacer skews on ebay right now.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#3

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Cyril Griesbach

>Well, Joe, I'm no metallurgist but I know one and he says that the more expensive steel is not worth it. However, I have several of Doug Thompsons gouges and, while I don't think they are more expensive, they do hold an edge longer than my M2 gouges and I don't do anything different when I sharpen them.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#4

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Joe, Did you get it? I'm not going to say anything but the next batch of skews will have a few 3/8 X 1-3/8 X 9-1/2 skews that will be less than the 2060. ETA about 3 months unless you want to drop by the shop and start milling then it will be sooner.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#5

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Fog Tanner

>While I am hobby turner, I do use skews for most of my spindle work. I have a number of them and usually have 4 laid out so when one gets dull I can pick up the next without breaking rythm. Also gives a good break when sharpening all of them. I started with one of Doug's 3/8" round skews and love the edge, I now use it for finish cuts.

I have a couple of Doug Thompson's skews and for me they are worth the extra money. They do hold an edge better than my M2 skews. I don't have any problem putting a razor edge on them with my Tormek. They actually get sharper than my M2 versions. I typically hone my skews, but found that Doug's tools work a lot better when you hone them - more so than the M2. I have several of his gouges and hone them as well.

There is still one thing missing with the 2030 tools, the cryo treating. This appears to really help hold an edge with the steel Doug uses, along with making the tool tougher. They have been using cryo treatment on Fuel dragster/funny car crankshafts for years - if they don't they crank won't even make a run. I think getting one of Doug's over the 2030 is worth the wait.

Fog

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#6

Too rich for my blood.

Joe Pack

>No, too rich for my blood, especially for something I am not sure I will use to its fullest advantage. It went for $132 + shipping...about $140 total.

Doug, I don't recall if I met you last Sunday or not...I joined North Coast Woodturners when Bill Grumbine was presenting of Sunday. If I met you and forgot, my apologies. I met so many nice, new people I lost track of names.

A lot of North Coast folks recommended your tools, and I have seen the recommends here. I looked at your web site and drooled. I'm new enough to turning that I haven't quite figured out what I do need. I have a bunch of inherited stuff, plus some stuff that I thought I "had to have," but ...

Hope to meet you (again?) at the next North Coast meeting.

Joe

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#7

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

john lucas

>I haven't seen a turning tool yet that I thought was worth $100. I have 5 skews and I do know that the Thompson skew holds an edge longer than any of the others. I just finished 2 production runs of mirrors, wine stoppers and worked with a turner on turning aluminum. These tools do hold an edge longer than HSS there's no doubt in my mind about it.

I don't have any of the 2030 or 2060 steels so I can't comment on them but my friend who owns a couple and has used my Thompson bowl gouge thinks it is as good or better. It wasn't a really good test but I do value his opinion.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#8

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

Gordon Seto

>Before I have the Thompson skew, the 1" Hamlet 2060 rolled skew was my favorite. I like the Hamlet because of its feel. The Thompson is un-handled,therefore I can't make any comparison in this regard. I don't like the Sorby because of the sharp edges; it doesn't slide along the tool rest well.

The best advantage I noticed on the Thompson is that it can be used as a negative rake scraper or shear scraper. Normally using a skew this way, the edge gets dull very quick. The Thompson skew is superior in the "off label" use.

Gordon

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#9

Re: I recommend starting with............

Jamie Donaldson

>....less expensive tools in general until you have learned to sharpen. There is a good "phrugal" reason to practice sharpening on cheaper tools, and then invest in the best when you find that you need them!

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#10

What Jamie said, then....

Cyril Griesbach

>go with the Thompson

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#11

Re: Too rich for my blood.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Joe, we didn't meet but next month we will. I learned a lot from Bill Grumbine's demo on Sunday he made a skew look easy to use. Joe Ott just told me about a couple maple trees thet fell in the ice storm so tomorrow I'm off to my favorite city dump to check them out.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: Too rich for my blood.

Bill Blasic

>When Doug made his first run of skews I got one and forwarded it to Kurt Hertzog who had a great interest in how this steel would be in the skew form. If my memory serves me right I think both Doug and Kurt had thoughts that it would not get as sharp as regular HSS. Here is a link to what Kurt found after sharpening.

http://www.kurthertzog.com/bill/skew.htm

Click on the pics for a larger image.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#13

Newbie's POV: Thompson tools are well worthwhile

wilbur

>When I started, I bought a used lathe that came with some Craftsman and Buck Brothers tools from the 1960's. I found that I could get these tools sharp, but that the sharpness would last for only a short while.

Then I bought some of Doug Thompson's tools. The first tool I used was his 1 1/4" skew. I had watched Alan Lacer's skew DVD where he shows how to make a turning tool handle using only a skew chisel. My problem was bootstrapping. I was going to make the tool handles out of white oak. My old tools wouldn't stay sharp for more than a few minutes working on white oak. So I used the Thompson 1 1/4" skew unhandled (!) to make a handle for itself out of white oak. After mounting the skew in the handle, I then used the handled skew, which was a much more sane approach, to make four more handles for my other Thompson tools out of white oak, and I think I only sharpened the skew once.

I've read that newcomers to turning should practice sharpening on cheaper tools before investing in a "good" tool set. I'm very glad that I quickly moved to getting the Thompson tools. I may waste a little more steel learning how to sharpen and fine tuning the profile of the tools, but overall they make turning much more enjoyable.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#14

I agree

Steven Kubien

>Wilbur, you point of view is contrary to what a lot of others say, but I agree with you. I started with a el-cheapo set and quickly moved to a P&N supa-gouge and their skew. Incredible difference and made turning sooooooo much more enjoyable. The P&N's are really good tools and since those two, I decided to add a few more and I went with the Thompson's. As good as the P&N's are, I like Doug's even more.

For a newbie, I recommend a bare minimum of quality tools to see if you like the sport and getting someone to help teach you sharpening. You may grind away some good steel but I think it is worth it.

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#15

I totally agree... Here's the cost of tools.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>When you decide to invest in the sport the grinder is the first place to put your money. The Wolverine and Woodcraft slow speed grinder is IMO the best.

One good tool is worth more than a bunch of cheaper tools. Most professionals only use a couple of tools all the time, tools that they have learned to use well. When starting out ONE 1/2 inch bowl gouge is enough to turn a 12 inch bowl then you add another when you see a need.

The cost to learn on a good tool is low when you break it down.

-The cost of a 1/2 bowl gouge is $50

-Useable flute length say 4 inches. Cost $12.50 per inch

-It can be ground say 50 times per inch. Cost $.25 per grind.

-Make a huge mistake and lose a 1/4 inch. Cost $3.12

This is a small price to pay... NOW to compare it with something else we use all the time... sandpaper ONE disk is $.20

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#16

Re: I totally agree... Here's the cost of tools.

Gordon Seto

>I never looked at it that way. I saw the tree and missed the forest.

We usually consume more than 1 sand paper grits.

For those who hone instead of taking the tool to the grinder each time, the cost of gouge consumption is almost free.

Gordon

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#17

Re: I totally agree... Here's the cost of tools.

Brian McInturff

>That's a great break down Doug. I never looked at it that way. Your tools are probably the best buy I've ever made. Curious how you came up with the 12" diameter and 1/2" tool. I've not seen or heard that before. But now that I stop and really think about it, I use the 1/2" on just about everything that's under 12" and use the 5/8" or 3/4" on everything over. I have used the 5/8" of course to hog off a lot of excess though when I'm starting out on larger blanks that end up being smaller than 12". Is it just the human instinct to do that? That's pretty wild when I think about it.

Brian

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#18

That's cool

Steven Kubien

>I too have never looked at it this way.

Hey, since I got my belt sander (1" x 42") for $20 and I already had a no cost motor, does that mean I can order more tools? I maaaaayyyyy be able to float that the banker.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#19

Tools are consumables

john lucas

>The best thing I ever did was decide that my tools were consumables, just like sandpaper and finish. What happened was I sharpened more often because I no longer worried about tool life. Two things happened. Because I sharpened more I started turning better which led to using less sandpaper. Because I sharpened more I got better at sharpening which meant I actually used less steel when I sharpened.

In all the years I've been turning I've only used up 2 bowl gouges, 2 spindle gouges and 1 parting tool. I still have my original rough out gouge, skew, round nose scraper and flat nose scraper. All of those tools have many many years of life left.

I agree with your cost analysis. My most expensive consumable is fuel to heat the shop. I'm going to do something about that this next year if I can get any spare money.

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#20

Re: I totally agree... Here's the cost of tools.

Ron in Drums PA

>I've been saying the same thing about sandpaper vs gouges for a long time Doug.

I bet I sharpen more than 100 per inch.

The difference between sharp and dual is about .002"

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#21

Re: I agree

wilbur

>"Wilbur, your point of view is contrary to what a lot of others say, but I agree with you."

Hi Steve,

For a brief second I panicked, thinking that someone else was going to chime in about how the benefits of using a skew chisel without a handle.

Then I read the rest of your post, and stopped hyperventilating. :@)

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#22

Consumable but like you said...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>your grinding skills imporved and that's the key. The better the grinding skills the less pressure is used and the jig is setup correctly. Jamie brought up a good point to learn about grinding with some cheap tools. Grinding is practice and you don't need to see a bunch of sparks fly to sharpen a tool

Ron, I wish you could show all of us how you grind... it proves one thing... it can be done.

Brian, a 12 inch bowl turned with a 1/2 diameter tool is safe. Anything larger creates a lot of stress which a larger diameter tool handles much better. Bill Grumbine is a good example he uses a 5/8 diameter tool most of the time and you will never see him fight the wood. Larger diameter tool and lighter cuts is very easy to control.

It's late...

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#23

Re: Consumable but like you said...

Gordon Seto

>Here is the proof: NCWT had Bill Grumbine for two day demo. He turned several large items. All he used was a 5/8" V Thompson Bowl gouge. You can see from the picture, two extreme kind of shavings from the same gouge. For two days he only sharpened the gouge once. Other than that he used the parting tool for forming the tenon and parting off the nub at the bottom. He didn't even use his famous 80-grit gouge at all. He gave the Oneway 2436 a good work out; the reset button tripped several times. Notice the size of the blank in the lathe.

He also had the bowl gouge clinic on the second day. Members brought in their problem GB for tweaking. He didn't change any angle, he hardly did any heavy grinding. He mostly fixed the bumps and dips of the side grind. Afterwards members use the newly fixed gouges to try on the large bowl blank he set up. He busted the myth that the gouge angle has to be precise to certain degree. He said all we have to do is change our tool presentation angle slightly to accommodate for the different nose angle. He used the Wolverine Varigrind; he didn't even measure the stick out. What counts is the correct shape of the grind, knowing when and where to stop. It was very educational knowing why we have to shape the gouge certain way to be useful.

I didn't bring my BG, because I took his class after his demo for my other Club last November. It was informal, we each learned at our own level and pace. He is a very experienced teacher. I highly recommend his class even if you already have couple bowls under your belt. In order to maximize the time, watching his DVDs in advance is also recommended.

Gordon


img

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#24

Not a bad idea

Ron in Drums PA

>Let me see what I can come up with

Re: 1 3/8" Lacer Skew: metal types

#25

Re: Consumable but like you said...

Bill Noce - Jefferson, Ohio

>I agree with what Gordon said about the Sharpening clinic Bill Brumbine did at Northcoast Woodturners Demo. Bill's sharpening method was remarkable it opened my eyes to the fact that you don't need all the marks on your variable jig for different bowl/spindle grinds or the distance that the tool sticks out from the jig. I tried Bill's way on my Ellsworth PM gouge when I got home and low an behold it was perfect without all the extra set up. If you get a chance to see Bill Grumbine do a demo it will be a enlighten experience.