Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Pith - The Pits!?

Posts

Pith - The Pits!?

#1

Pith - The Pits!?

charlie belden

>(also posted this question to rec.craft.woodtrurning so if you saw it there, skip it here)

Unlike some here who have BIG lathes, and probably the chainsaw and bandsaw to go with them, I turn on a JET mini/midi - 10" nominal swing and maybe 13" between centers. Though I have a chainsaw and a bandsaw with a 12" throat capacity, I often find myself turning branches that are readily available from neighbors and friends and require no cranking up the chainsaw and no bandsawing out a bowl blank.

Problem is The Dreaded Pith. Pith is the pits!? Unlike folks who chainsaw a blank from a log, being careful to avoid The Dreaded Pith, I often turn "pith in" branches, usually "green" fresh cut stuff. Lately the wood has been plum. playing with pinch pot hollow forms, through a half inch or 5/8" hole. Because of the pinch neck and small opening, it's hard for me to judge wall thickness, especially the bottom thickness. Having blown through the bottom and on a few occassions, the side wall - I err on the side of caution and quit while I'm ahead.

THAT may be part of my problem. I turn a nice form in some nice wood that happens to still have the pith in it. I drill out the remaining pith in the bottom of the piece, turn a plug for it out of dry maple or mahogany, epoxy it in then apply a carnuba finish to the outside using an unstitched wheel on the buffer, then pour some oil inside, slosh it around, maybe put t back on the lathe and spin it in hopes of forcing some of the oil into the wood then pour any excess. Sometimes I give the bottom a coat of two of thin CA glue. Then it's stuff some paper towels inside and try

1. paper bagging

2. paper bagging under a pile of semi-damp shavings

Sometimes all that works - and sometimes it'd don't.

So what is it about the pith that seems to make it propogate cracks, even after it's been drilled out and the space plugged?

Pith is the softest wood - spongee and porous - so it dries quicker than the heart or sapwood. But even when drilled out and plugged, cracks seem to propagate from the pith, or where the pith was even after it's been replaced with a denser plug.

Normally the direction of a crack, outside in or inside out will indicate a drying rate problem. If the crack starts on the outside and goes inward then the outside dried too fast. So if the crack starts at the pith and goes outward then the inside dried too fast.

But some wood I've turned with the "pith in" and left it in haven't cracked after being inside the house for over a year. Pieces turned from "pith in" English Walnut with no dark heartwood have held up well. And the same goes for Magnolia and Black Walnut. Fruitwoods - cherry, plum and apple all seem proned to pith propogated cracking.

So now I'm thinking it may be the concentricity of the grain that's the culprit, or at least an active member in The Dreaded Pith Plot to crack my "pith in" green turnings. Could it be that the smaller diameter innner growth rings are drying faster than the larger diameter outer rings?

Now if you've looked at a wood shrinkage table, you'll not that the Tangential Shrinkage % is ALWYAS greater than the Radial Shrinkage %, sometimes twice or more greater. Maybe the RATIO of tangential shrinkage to radial shrinkage is one of the culprits in the "pith in" cracking problem. If the combined shrinkage mwere closer to being equal then the original form might be maintained, just made smaller proportionately in all dimensions,

Here are some Tangential/Radial Ratios for various woods, examples grouped low to high. Note that the two fruitwoods are close to 2.0 while walnut and magnolia are closer to 1.0. Could this be the indicator of which woods are proned to "pith in"cracking and which are not?

Birch, Yellow 1.3

Black Walnut 1.4

Yew Pacific 1.4

Basswood 1.4

Birch,Paper 1.4

Bubinga 1.4

Mahogany 1.4

Magnolia 1.5

Apple 1.8

Cherry, Black 1.9

Holly, American 2.1

Madrone, Pacific 2.2

Maple, Soft 2.2

Teak 2.3

Willow, Black 2.6

Lacewood, Australian 2.9

Pine, Eastern White 2.9

Anyone have a theory about why "pith in" turnings are more proned to cracking than "pith out" turnings?

charlie b

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#2

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>I think the problem is that you are putting a plug in it. I turn many with the pith in and have few that crack. Since the wood is green and as it drys, it shrinks, with a dry plug in it, the plug will not shrink since it is dry and has already shrunk. The hollow form is green and trys to shrink but the plug won't let it so it cracks.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#3

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

john lucas

>I agree with Gary but you didn't give us a vital piece of information. How thick are the walls. There are 3 things I do when I keep the pith in something. First is remove it. your doing that. You may have to remove a little larger hole.

The second is wall thickness. The walls have to be the same thickness throughout. The thinner the better. Thin wood tends to warp instead of crack but some woods (especially fruitwoods) are more prone to problems than others.

Shape. As you saw in your chart wood shrinks and it shrinks at different rates when it drys. End grain loses moisture faster than side grain. This is why most things crack. The end grain loses moisture and shrinks and the side grain doesn't so it stays the same size. You can't have one circle getting smaller while one stays the same. Something has to give. Closed vessels are the worst.

If you have a cone shape such as a vase it will get taller and narrower as it shrinks but usually won't crack. round pieces with the pith left in will go football shaped because of the different shrinkage rates.

So what do you do? Get rid of the entire pith and maybe a little extra. Turn the walls thin and then let it dry slowly. Then fill the bottom with a plug and turn a lip for the top.

Another thought. Get your self a wedge and a sledge and split the logs. Then get a tree saw (they are cheap) and cut is to length. The cut off the corners. Now you have something to turn bowls out of. Or you can turn smaller hollow vessels. This is basically what I did when I first started turning. I still have the bow saw.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#4

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

charlie belden

>Gary wrote:

" I think the problem is that you are putting a plug in it. I turn many with the pith in and have few that crack. Since the wood is green and as it drys, it shrinks, with a dry plug in it, the plug will not shrink since it is dry and has already shrunk. The hollow form is green and trys to shrink but the plug won't let it so it cracks. "

The plug was an attempt to prevent the default if the pith is left in - cracks startng at the pith and radiating out as the piece dries. seemingly from the pith outward. Why is the question.

I'm leaning for the ratio of tangential to radial shrinkage percentages as the main culprit with concentric grain green turnings.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#5

it's in the book

John K Jordan

>>...So what is it about the pith that seems to make it propogate cracks

Charlie,

R. Bruce Hoadley's writes about this in his book Understanding Wood. In a section titled "Abnormal Wood" he discusses the early growth of a tree and describes area around the pith as juvenile wood and states it may have "abnormal shrinkage properties, which result in greater tendency to warp..." Hoadley also indicates a wide variation of abnormality is found in various species and specific trees.

Add this to what we know about the normal forces in the wood from T/R shrinkage ratios and it's not surprising that wood near the pith may crack even if the pith itself is removed.

(Based on the geometry of the forces, I think your suspicion that the increased curvature near the center also plays a part, but I think primarily on thicker pieces. I once plotted force vectors in a log to try to understand what was going on, and it seems a testament to the strength and elasticity of the fibers that ANY wood stays together!)

PS. I think that book should be required reading for anyone with more than a "Home Depot interest" in wood!

JKJ

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#6

"I once plotted force vectors in a log"

Toney Robertson

>John,

Now that is dedication to the craft!

And I might add, more brain power than I have. VBG

Toney

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#7

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

Barry Irby

>I also think the problem is in removing the pith and some surrounding wood and then installing a dry plug. You have replaced wet wood that might have shrunk with dry wood that won't. I also agree with John Jordan about the Juvenile wood. Juvenile wood has shrinkage characteristics that are many times worse than mature growth wood. And, John Lucas is right about wall thickness also.

I have turned a number of pieces with the pith in and what I did was turn the bottom so that it was a dramatic dome up into the bottom, like the bottom of a champaign bottle. My thought was that this allowed this dome to flex and to react almost independently of the sidewalls.

And, I would agree with the suggestion of cutting a larger hole in the bottom and letting it dry. Then install a plug. You will have to remount it and clean up the hole to install the plug.

I also tend to agree with those who say it only a fellow turner that will care or even notice that there is a plug in the bottom.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#8

Re: Cracking from the pith

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Charles,

I once had a friend give me a good sized, 14"-16" dia, cherry log that had been on the ground for a couple of years. Needless to say, I was thrilled with the opportunity to harvest some good sized bowl blanks.

Obviously, the ends were already cracked pretty good, so I decided to start in the middle and work my way out. Imagine my surprise to find that the center of the log was cracked radially from the pith in at least three different directions. I mean, severely cracked. Till then, I never saw a log that cracked in the very middle where there was no exposure to the air except through the bark.

I agree with John J. Get Hoadley's book. It has lots of info about why wood does what it does as it dries. There are also publications on drying wood which are available on the Forest Products Lab website. They make good reading if you have an interest in wood.

Gary

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#9

Re: Cracking from the pith

Don Orr

>So far I agree with what has been said. A dry plug in a wet vessel leaves no where for the wet wood to shrink. Wall thickness, type of wood, etc.

As an aside to Gary's post, I got some fresh cut crabapple from a neighbor last year. Looked real good in the center, no apparent checks. I took it to work and put it into an MRI scanner to see if I could get an image-needed very wet wood. OK, I know I'm kind of strange sometimes, but it worked. I got very nice images, but much to my surprise, there were heart checks throughout! Very distinct. When I ripped it in half to make bowl blanks I could not see them, but found them easily when I turned the bowls. I managed to get a decent natural edge bowl to give to the neighbor.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#10

Re: "I once plotted force vectors in a log"

John K Jordan

>It wasn't too bad - like my piano teacher always said, everything's easy once you know how! I did this as part of a casual analysis of why boards cut from straight-grained logs can still twist when sawn on an angle to the axis of the log. Hoadley states this as fact but I wanted to understand why. As part of that I plotted the shrinkage forces on sections sliced from the log to try to understand the stresses. The hard part is visualizing it in three dimensions. I just retired from years doing scientific visualization so I had a leg up in the process! :)

I find the structure and dynamics of wood fascinating. BTW, those who haven't seen it might be amazed at the view through a stereo microscope of a small cube of wood sliced cleanly on three sides, turning the cube in your fingers. I wish I could take some good stereo photographs.

JKJ

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#11

Re: Cracking from the pith

George Van

>Now that MRI process would definately raise the cost of bowl blanks! ;-))

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#12

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

charlie belden

>Hopefully this post will show up AFTER George Van's post to keep things in time order.

Gary:

You've turned "pith in" pieces and they didn't crack. So you're the guy to start with

- what wood?

- what shape (plate, bowl, semi closed formm etc.)

- how thin were the walls?

- how'd you deal with the bottom?

flat

curved

concave domed

same thickness as the sides? Thicker? Thinner?

John L. suggests:

1. remove the pith AND some adjacent wood

2. uniform wall thickness, the thinner the better

3. plug the hole were the pith was removed

(plug while piece still wet or wait 'til it's dry then plug it?)

Barry notes the following

1. pith wood is different from the other wood cells - they're

juvenile wood cells. This makes sense. A newly sprouted

stem must behave quite differently from the wood of a

mature tree, or branch. The emphasis for juvenile wood is to grow tall or long quickly - AND - remain flexible enough to not be snapped off by wind or rain or the weight of a half dozen leaves. I suspect that they're more like grass cells than true wood cells, more fiberous and flexible.

2. to avoid a relatively wide expanse of end grain on the (flat?) bottom of the piece - make it a concave dome similar to the bottom of a champagne bottle. This allows the wall thickness to be kept thin while keeping a "bottom" large enough to make the turned piece stabile and standing upright (don't want the sucker sitting tilted, or rocking and rolling off a table)

3. If you drill out the pith, let the piece dry BEFORE gluing in a solid plug

John J

HIghly recomended R. Bruce Hoadley's book on wood as a

Must Read for anyone with other than a passing interesting

in wood.

Hoadley's book was one of the books I acquired about a year

into my woodworking journey - when my interest was in solid

wood furniture making - mainly focusing on how BOARDS behave. Boards don't normally have pith running down the

center of them - for good reason. Most of the Non-Board

information was scanned for relevancy to boards and skipped

over if not applicable. Until I got into turning I was more

interested nooks with info about types of woods, their

appearance and working qualities - The Wood Book being one

of several books of that type.

Now flipping through Hoadley's book I can see that the answer

to the "pith in" cracking problem is likely in there amongst all

the photos of cross sections, end grain and side grain pictures

and charts and graphs.

The idea of trying to visualize stresses and strains in a log

would is a challenge, but doing the math to develop the

data to be visualized is beyond my interest level at the moment.

But I think we all agree that wood is a pretty amazing material.

Have attached an illustration of what I think is why "pith in"

pieces crack - or more accurately - SOME "pith in" pieces

crack.

Gary E's experience with an "on the ground for several years"

cherry log was not surprising. I assume it was an orchard

tree which is pruned year after year to keep the fruit accessible.

As a result, orchard tree grow differently than those that are

left to develop naturally. In part because they are cared for

for several decades, and kept low, I suspect that their wood

is not as "hardy" / "sound" as their wild grown cousins.

Gary O's experience with Crab Apple and "heart checks" is

not surprising if it was an orchard tree or "maintained"

decorative tree which got annual pruning. And given the

fruit weight loads on the branches and hence the trunk

might be a contributing factor to the formatio of heart

checks. The idea of using an MRI to "see inside" is

interesting. Perhaps that might provide info on what's

going on inside a "pith in" piece as it dries.

Forest Products Laboratory is a great source of

technical info on wood - though not easy to find

what yoy're looking for and when you do find it, the

presentation can be a bit duh-l

Still believe that, all other things being equal, it's

the T/R ratio that's the begin determiner of what

would will likely "pith in" crack and which won't.

More input please.

charlie belden


img

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#13

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

Gary in Zirconia,NC

>You have got some very good responses. I turn mostly maple, cherry, walnut, and other wood native to North Carolina. I turn mostly traditional vase forms when leaving the pith in. These hollow forms are quite thin (1/8 to 3/16 inches). The bottoms are concave and nearly the same thickness (as close as my nerve lets me). Also, if I think the area may crack I soak it with CA glue as soon as I take it off the lathe. Examples of my work can be seen at www.beneaththebark.us .

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#14

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Charlie

Thanks for the pith crack pic. It goes in my note book I take to art and craft shows. It will provide good info for new turners as to why we split logs in 1/2.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

#15

Re: Pith - The Pits!?

charlie belden

>Bill:

Before you share the illustration of what I THINK is going on it might be better to wait and see what others here think of this explanation of the process.

The attached is a macro view of the shrinkage induced cracking of "pith in" logs along with some info on alternative ways to cut a log for bowl blanks. I took info from a presentation John Brugo of West Bay Area Woodturners gave at our turning club and I illustrated his ideas. They make sense to me, both from personal experience and my understanding of physics.

Not the stuff about "tension" and "compression" wood - the location of the pith being a tip off as to which is which. This "compresion wood" and "tension wood" may also be a factor in "pith in" cracking.

charlie belden


img