Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

12" Disc Sander

Posts

12" Disc Sander

#1

12" Disc Sander

Bryan from Oregon

>Hello everyone, I am in the market for a 12" Disc Sander. I have looked at all brands. I try to do tool reviews on every tool I buy. It looks like the Jet would be the best purchase, however with "Gas Prices on the rise!!!!!" $350 is alot of money. I have not seen any reviews on the Shopfox and the new Rikon sanders. Does anyone own or have experience with these machines? I will be using the sander for Segmented Turnings. Thanks.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#2

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I made one. I used the 12" disk from Shopsmith, two mounted bearings, a #8 bolt for the shaft (cut off the thread), a couple of vee pulleys and a belt, a drill stop, an old motor capable of reversing rotation, a DPDT switch, and miscellaneous plywood and MDF. It was a long time ago, and I had a lot of the things on hand. Seems one could make one for lots less than $350. Yikes!

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#3

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Texian

>Ditto what Carol said. Just completed 15-3/4" home made DS for same purpose. Mine is lathe-mounted. Will be a little unhandy having to swap it on and off lathe, but not a big deal. Most expensive parts are the faceplate and the sanding disc. So far have found 10 discs for $83+. Really just want one, for the moment, to verify that it works as intended.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#4

Re: 12" Disc Sander

John Scheideman

>I have two. I made one. I've used it for about 25 years. I also bought a second one. It was the Delta 12" benchtop for around $150. I think they are up to about $200 now. Check on Amazon.com. I mounted it onto a pedestal and it has run for about 7 or 8 years. The only problem I've had is the switch getting filled with dust. You have to take the switch apart about once a year and blow it out. It is easy to do.

John

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#5

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Stuart Johnson

>This topic came up on another list (I won't add a link as they won't allow WC links) recently. and Malcolm Tibbetts said the problem with a homemade lathe mounted sander is getting the fine degree of repeatable accuracy required for segments.

I have a HF 12" sander and do not recommend it.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#6

Re: 12" Disc Sander

john lucas

>I have a homemade Disc sander made from a leftover shopsmith disc and It's simply not accurate enough. It's fine for all the rough cutting that I've been using it for but when using it to true up segments it's just not there.

I've been drooling over the various 20 machines but will probably end up with the Jet 12" open stand model. It's in my price range.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#7

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Arch

>I often miss something, but why can't a shopmade disc sander be made to the same table and disc flatness, bearing and disc run out and repeatable angular accuracy as a $350 store bought machine ...and for a lot less? The disc face can be flatted and machined to its shaft. The table can be flatted and machined to the disc face, etc. The same lathe bearings ought to be as true for sanding as for later turning.

I accept that this can't work, but why not? Guess it's obvious that I don't sand segments using either side of my brain. :)

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#8

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Nelson

>I also have the Delta 12 disk sander[benchtop] and it works great. With some problems on other Delta products this one of the best tools they make in my opinion, its a heavy little bugger.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#9

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Stuart Johnson

>I think the problem isn't with setting it up to be exact. You would need to go through the entire fine tuning each time you switch from lathe to disc sander.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#10

Re: 12" Disc Sander

john lucas

>Arch My problems a 1. There is excess vibration. This is due to the belt/motor mounting. I have never been able to get it to run really smooth. I've tried several different belts, idlers and mounting platforms and it just doesn't run as smooth. I also have a tiny bit of runout on the shaft which I think is the quality of the Pillow blocks that I bought.

The table moves away from the disc when using other settings. You can get around this by building an offset mounting system. I didn't at the time and don't know why. It is more complex to build but not that bad.

I haven't taken the time to build an accurate miter slot for it. I've used the outer edge as a guide when I need to build a jig.

I think what it amounts to is that to build something that really is accurate you have to spend some serious time on the construction and quality of parts. Even then it will probably only be as good as the $150 disc sanders, not the $350.

I said earlier that I've been looking at the 20" versions. They do cost a lot more but man do they run smooth. I've also used the industrial 12" versions. The same thing. They are so much smoother running than the cheaper versions you can do a lot more accurate work.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#11

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Arch

>Thanks Stuart & John. Your answers make good sense. I was thinking about a lathe driven disc sander while writing about both. :)

Anyway, I can see that the same problems you mentioned would apply to both types of shopmade sanders.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#12

Re: 12" Disc Sander

john lucas

>I do think someone could build a very functional disc sander. Mine works well for most things. With a little more care in the construction and possible better pillow blocks and drive system you could cut down on the vibrations. I thin it would be entirely possible to make the disc out of MDF, it's the mounting bracket that might be difficult.

Mine has been very useful. I've used it for about 6 years now. I just don't feel it's up to the task of really accurate segment sanding.

One thing I've learned over the years is that there is sort of a learning/purchasing curve. Here's how it works for me. You decide you need to improve some technique so you study what your doing and figure out how to improve this technique. You work at it and then improve but then you figure out that the tool you had isn't quite up to the task. So you buy another tool. Now your skills are the weak point so you work on that. They improve and now your tool is the weak point so you work on that or buy a new one. Then your skills are the weak point again, etc etc. It is quite challenging and takes a lifetime to master, and if you go all the way probably a fortune in tools as well.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#13

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Ralph

>Bryan

I looked at that question a couple years ago: Looked at the current model Delta, not solid enough. Looked at the current model Jet, dito. Bought the current model WoodTek (from Woodworkers Supply) and liked, most of it.

I didn't like that the bed doesn't use a standard 3/8x3/4 slot. So I had it milled out to that standard.

It runs smooth and I am happy with it for the $$$ spent.

If I had more $$$ I would get the WoodTek combo (12inch disc & 6x48 belt). If I had even more I would get the WoodTek 20 inch

TTFN

Ralph

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#14

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Dick McNeill

>I own the Jet 12inch Disc sander. I use it for my segmented turnings. I am pleased with it & it is relatively precise. The drawback is that it has no table screws to adjust all corners of the table to the disc. It relies on a trunnion and knob to set the table square to the Disc. This is not a problem with the Delta Disc sander. If I could I would replace the Jet with a Delta, but the Jet does do the job.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#15

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Bryan from Oregon

>Thanks to all who replied. After giving some thought I think I will settle with the Delta. Kurt Theobold uses that one in his DVD Making Segmented wood turnings. I think that because you are able to loosen the top screws to the table top to set the table true to the disk in a relatively easy fashion sells me on it. I only worry about the direction Delta has gone over the last few years. But it is quite abit cheaper then the Jet. Again, thanks to all that responded.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#16

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Texian

>John, Excellent analysis. One should start young, work hard and learn fast, and have enough money to end up with all the very best tools as soon as possible.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#17

Re: 12" Disc Sander

Texian

>It may not be reasonable to expect a disc sander, of whatever description, to yield perfect angles. If segments are cut carefully, with a TS sled or jig in MS and glued to half rings, there will be only a slight mismatch between half rings. A disc sander should be excellent at correcting this slight mismatch. Notice in "Seggy's Dream" video that Malcolm is gluing to half rings.

While not necessarily the perfect answer for "truing" the angles, the disc sander should be excellent for lightly cleaning up the saw cut surfaces to be sure they are flat, and giving an improved surface for glue joints.

An advantage of a lathe-mounted system, if you have the right lathe, is that you have a variable speed sander, and it has little or no vibration, unlike most belt-driven disc or disc/belt sanders.

Just some unproven thoughts, as have yet to find a source of just one or two 16" sanding discs, and unwilling to buy a pack of 10 at this point.

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#18

do you have a TS?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Someone makes sanding disks that can go on your table saw. I have been considering this arrangement to avoid another tool station that I do not have room for. Okay, maybe it would not be as large as a 12" stand alone model, but if your miter gauge is accurate at 90 degrees, seems you could easily jig the rest.

Anyone do this?

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#19

Would a Lion Miter Trimmer, or equivalent work?

Clem Wixted, Jonesboro, AR

>The Lion Miter Trimmer, or a knockoff, might work. I don't do segmented work but this tool claims to make "perfect" joints.

It might take some doing to get the correct angles but you would get a good tight joint.

Clem

Re: 12" Disc Sander

#20

Re: do you have a TS?

Texian

>Tom, Still have a couple 10" discs (like plain, flat saw blades, no teeth)left over from old C'man TS. Problem w/ TS sanding is the rpm is WAY too fast. Found a sanding disc and tested new home-made 15-3/4" DS today. At about 200 rpm it works well for gentle touch up of saw-cut surfaces.