Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

.007" revisited...

Posts

.007" revisited...

#1

.007" revisited...

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>Seems most answers to "David" of Indianapolis' post regarding misalignment between centers on his new PM3520 were dismissive, "fogettaboutit" type answers. Now, I am wondering if my own thinking is badly misaligned because I couldn't disagree more.

Help me understand. If centers in headstock and tailstock are brought together and the pointy ends miss by .007", and if this misalignment were the result of one end or the other pointing a fraction of a degree off, then wouldn't the projected line from either center widen the gap as the centers are moved apart?

And wouldn't such misalignment show up in nearly every "between centers" application where reversing end-to-end were intended?

Upgrading to a new PM3520 with "dead-on" centers sure has reduced the frustration I used to experience.

Re: .007" revisited...

#2

Re: Mike-the answer is "maybe!" Or ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...perhaps "sometimes."

Re: .007" revisited...

#3

Re: .007" revisited...

Ed in Sptbg.

>The centerlines of the headstock and the tailstock will diverge more and more as they are projected outward, but the "offset" at the points will remain the same no matter where the tailstock is positioned on the bed, given no other variations in the bed dimensions.

Re: .007" revisited...

#4

Re: .007" revisited...

john lucas

>I think it doesn't matter at all on 99% of the projects people do. I've had really lousy lathes up until the Powermatic and I do some pretty precise work. It would show up if you swapped a spindle end for end but that is rarely necessary.

It might show up when drilling because the hole would be slightly bigger than the drill bit but then I've found that if you drill 5 holes with 5 different drill bits they will all be different. That is why I have one drill bit and 1 wrench for sizing that I use for my handmirrors and never change them. This is assuming that the tailstock misalignment is parallel to the bed. If it's skewed then you would have a hole that is larger at one end than the other, however drill bit flex and wandering will cause that much error when drilling wood.

when drilling long holes in wood I doubt very seriously if you could maintain .007" accuracy over 12" with even the best drill bit.

I've been turning with my Powermatic now for 3 years and have never checked the tailstock alignment other than putting the drive and tailpoint together. My points aren't all that sharp so they could easily be .007" off. That's a pretty small gap. I haven't had any problems that I could trace back to tailstock so I didn't check the alignment. If I have time I'll try this weekend.

Re: .007" revisited...

#5

Steven Antonucci

My guess is most wood moves more than .007 @rpm

steve antonucci

>between the wood flexing under rotational load, slop in the headstock, a loose screw in a faceplate, I'm guessing that .007 is there in even the best lathes.

Steven

Re: .007" revisited...

#6

Re: My guess is most wood moves more than .007 @rp

Chris in KC

>Steve,

You're absolutely correct. There will be more than that much movement in the wood itself. Wood moves!

Re: .007" revisited...

#7

007" which way?

Jim Swank

>.007" off what way? There's two ways the points can be out of line. The first is if the headstock and tailstock bores are parallel, but at different heights, or off front to back. The other is if they actually point two different directions. Most likely it is a combination of the two. The part that is height, or is front to back, is probably easy to fix. The part that is angular may be much more complex to address.

I don't think .007" matters a bit for turning most wooden objects, but the same princiles apply to larger misalignments that would matter.

Re: .007" revisited...

#8

Re: 007" which way?

David - Indianapolis

>The 0.007" is a "shift in the horizontal plane, that is, at any position on the lathe bed, the headstock and tailstock are 0.007" off from dead center. What this says to me is that the beds are well machined, the tolerances are good on both the headstock and tail stock but, either one (headstock or tailstock) or both are ground such that they are not in the center of the bed. I posted above, not seeing this post. But, the runout is less than 0.0005 and I have tried multiple drive centers and see the same thing. I posted a picture above and have posted the same here. Bottom line, is I don't know if this is an issue. Was looking for some guidance in terms of others observations. I am planning on speaking with the dealer (Osolnik) to see what the specs are on the machine.


img

Re: .007" revisited...

#9

Re: .007" revisited...

David - Indianapolis

>Sorry, I didn't answer the question you posed. A misalignment of this type will be most noticeable at close distances. Think of it this way, as a triangle with the distance between the headstock and tailstock (if perfectly aligned) as one edge, 0.007 displacement as another edge and the hypotenus is the line between the headstock and tailstock. a*2 + b*2 = c*2. b*2 remains the same at 0.007, thus c*2 approaches a*2 as the distance increases and thus the angle between the long edge and the hypotenuse decreases. Thus the impact in turning a pen will be much greather than turning a long spindle.

Re: .007" revisited...

#10

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: .007" revisited...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

>It seems to me that the effect of an 0.07 inch offset (regardless of whether it is caused by an angular or a lateral displacement of the tailstock relative to the headstock) is essentially zero when turning between centers, regardless of whether you swap the piece end for end. The axis of the spin in either case goes through the two centers and remains the same if you switch ends. A minor error occurs if you cut a tenon on the end of the piece while it is between centers and then mount the piece using a chuck to grip the tenon. In this case, If you try to support the free end of the work piece with the tail stock you will find that the tailstock center now misses the old hole by 0.07 inches. Generally this can be regarded as negligible as discussed by others. Dennis