Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

walnut and checking

Posts

walnut and checking

#1

walnut and checking

Mark Paulley

>Hello all,

Does walnut check easier then most woods, like Maple and Cherry, Hackberry? I have (for now) some walnut logs that have been in my barn for about 4 years. All about 18" long and about 8-10" in dia. I cut in half long ways and then cut the ends 2-3" off each end to remove checking, however the checking is still there. So I cut again and checking still there. I put some on the lathe thinking I could turn down to an acceptable size and the checking would be gone but NO-still there.

Just curious if others have checking problems with Walnut. I guess fire pit will need to be started up!

Any assistance is approeciated and thanks for your help in advance

Mark in Kentucky

Re: walnut and checking

#2

Re: walnut and checking

Ruth Niles

>Mark, I've found that happens with Walnut. I have a lot of Black Walnut and it seems to crack inside even when the outside is ok. Maybe it's just the nature of the beast. Some pieces come out beautiful and clean, others can start out 8" diameter and end up toothpicks.

Re: walnut and checking

#3

Re: walnut and checking

john lucas

>I've had the opposite experience. The walnut logs that I got lasted much longer than the Hackberry. The Cherry logs seem to check the most for a short distance but the checks don't go in as far. I didn't split either one at the heart which I usually try to do. These just got dumped in the yard. The Box Elder is holding up well and so is the poplar. Maple is starting to check. These logs are much newer than the Walnut.

Re: walnut and checking

#4

Re: walnut and checking

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It is always interesting for me to read how the same species reacts differently in different areas. I probably have less trouble with walnut cracking than any other wood I deal with. The exception has been any small walnut that has grown quickly. I have had a cant split explosively as I have been sawing a board off.

Are these splits radial or around the growth rings?

Re: walnut and checking

#5

Re: Mark- I've had lots of walnut....

Jamie Donaldson

>...develop interior checks and voids as well as exterior, and there's not much we can do to prevent it? It isn't really the same as wind or heart checking, and happens in random manner in differing sizes of trees?

Re: walnut and checking

#6

Re: Mark- I've had lots of walnut....

Mark Paulley

>To all,

Thanks for the posting and the info. Thought I was going crazier then I already am.

Barbara,

The checks are radial.

I love the color of the wood with the sap showing when others post thier works with this wood.

Just hate to throw wood on the burn pile!!!!!!!!

Thanks again for everyone's help and info

Mark

Re: walnut and checking

#7

Re: walnut and checking

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>You guys should livwe here in AZ. where everything cracks and checks overnight.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ

Re: walnut and checking

#8

Re: walnut and checking

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I haven't had much problem with walnut, but I always seal the ends with AnchorSeal.

On the other hand, I've had a bit of a problem with thick oak blanks, especially white oak.

Re: walnut and checking

#9

Mark- a lot of times when we get...

Allen Neighbors

>logs, we need to consider what the tree has been through in it's lifetime. I have cut a lot of wood out of Roosevelt's dust bowl 'shelter-belts'. These trees in this part of the country have been through many wind storms, some fierce, and have checks throughout, that are radial.

I've gotten a lot of wood (Large Bois d'Arc) that was cleared from an area where they built a golfcourse. They were taken down with a large machine that grabbed the trunk and chopped the bottom like a hoe, and it ruined the wood for bowls. Pith and radial checks.

Mesquite just pith checks... it doesn't need an excuse. :)

Your Walnut could have been through some rough times before you got it. :)

I've had a walnut tree 24"dia trunk and large limbs piled out on the ground on 4x4s, and laid there for 2 or 3 years... still got a lot of good bowls out of it. Not a lot of checking either way.

Re: walnut and checking

#10

I agree, Barbara

Ruth Niles

>Every species, every tree reacts so different in various locations. I think trees are just like people, no two are the same, no two react to wind, dry, cold or heat the same, even in the same yard.

Heck, you can cut up one big tree and parts of it will react totally different than another section of that tree. Isn't it wonderful.

Re: walnut and checking

#11

Re: I agree, Barbara

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>lol Trees are like Forrest Gump's chocolates.