Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

New PM3520B lathe - Comments

Posts

New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#1

New PM3520B lathe - Comments

David - Indianapolis

>I recently purchased a PM 3520B lathe and table extension and after setting it up, have a few comments and question.

Purchased the lathe through Osolnik Machinery. Mr. Osolnik seemed to have a good reputation through this site and offered a good deal on the lathe. Not the best, but with a $2500+ purchase, a couple of bucks difference is not an issue if it comes down to customer service. The best price I have seen online is through toolnut. Mr. Osolnik was pleasant to deal with, provided lots of communication and responded promptly when I let him know that the hinge on the door covering the belts was damaged.

The lathe itself was packaged nicely, and arrived undamaged (other than the hinge). During the assembly, everything went together well except for the bed extension. I found that I had to drill out the three mounting holes on the bed extension by 3/64 to be able to center the extension with the main bed. Preferred to do it this way as I didn't want to wait for another delivery. Also, not a big deal for me but it may be for some trying to drill through > 1/2 of cast iron with a large bit.

Otherwise, fit and finish were nice, all the parts went together well and this lathe is quite an impressive piece of equipment.

Now for my question. Across the entire lathe, the alignment between the head stock and tail stock centers is the same. However, the alignment is off by approximately 7 thousandths. Is this an issue?

While I would prefer it to be perfect, is this going to make a difference when working with wood.

In terms of chucks, I would like to purchase one (if I can) and am thinking about the oneway stronghold or talon. Any other recommendations or comments on these?

Thanks,

David

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#2

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

don lewonczyk

>David I just ordered the 3520b today and I'll pick it up either tomorrow or Friday. Hope I don't have any problems but it looks like it will handle the job. My Polish luck has been everything I buy is either screwed up or damaged when I get it thats why im picking mine up at the warehouse. Anyway based on everyones valued comments on the machine I know I won't be sorry. I have two stronghold chucks and I wouldn't trade them for another brand however if I had bought one of the other quality chucks out there first I would feel the same about them if they preformed as good. I also have a Nova super 2 chuck I caught on sale at woodcraft for $149 with #2 jaws but no insert but I already had one so that was a deal for me and the fit and finish and operation is excellent also. I know you will get a lot of feed back and sometimes its tough to decide what to buy because as soon as you do or shortly therafter there is a better deal or newer gadget that appears. Well luck to you, DonL

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#3

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

Russ Fairfield

>Forget about it and turn wood. You never would have known there was 0.007" run-out anywhere in the lathe if you hadn't measured it.

You have just discovered why the Powermatic sells for half the price of a Oneway or a Robust. Accuracy to within 0.002" will cost you an additional $3000. The wood won't know the difference.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#4

Great answer Russ.

Norm Smith

>

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#5

Re: Chucks *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>Which chuck depends on what you want to do with it, how accurately you want to do it, how long you want it to last, and most important of all, how much money you want to spend.

Take the link to my opinions on chucks -


Buying a Chuck. Which one??

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#6

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

John Kyler

>Looks like a great price, as a few dollars is nothing. Having a great dealer even at a higher price is worth it when they stand behind it and support you down the road. Olsolnik is one of those! I have bought from them before.

The last three lathes I have set up (all PMs)were better than that, but unless you are just turning very small stuff (micro), I dont think you will ever notice a problem. And even if you do that small likely you wont have that many issues as it will likely be done face place/chuck. And as for the more expensive lathes... They have problems too..

So price is not always the issue.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#7

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Follow Up

David - Indianapolis

>I think perhaps I haven't made myself clear. This is not runout, i.e. the lathe headstock does not spin out of round by 0.007. Actually, this number is less than 0.002. What I mean is that the linear relationship between the drive center to the tailstock center is slightly displaced, or shifted, by 0.007 across the entire lenght of the bed. So when you push the tailstock center up against the drive center, the points do not meet exactly in the center of both. Thus, the runout is fine, the bed is ground well, but either the head stock ways, tail stock ways or both were ground such that one is off by 0.007, or the combination of the both is off by 0.007.

Again, I am merely trying to ascertain if this is typical as this is my first wood lathe though I am accustomed to working with metal lathes. I know the tolerances in metal working are much tighter, but is this reasonable or should I be trying to correct with the manufacturer.

Thanks,

David

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#8

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

Bill Neddow

>With a big lathe like this, get a Stronghold or a large Vicmarc chuck. Look at the two carefully and decide which one you can live with forever. The reason for this is that it is dangerous to mix the two. The jaws are geared so they close in different directions -- so if you are used to a Stronghold, and go to close a Vicmarc, you are actually opening it. Guess how I found that out!

Otherwise, they are both really good chucks. Don't try to save a little by buying one of the cheaper brands, especially if you are worried about run-out.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#9

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

John Dillbeck

>I found mine to be about the same on mis-alignment. After I leveled the bed it came into alignment. I leveled the bed by using a laser level projecting on a wall about 15ft away.Project a dot from one end and mark, go to the other end of bed and project on the mark, Adjust the feet until the two projections overlay.It worked for me. Good luck with your new lathe.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#10

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Leveling

David - Indianapolis

>I have leveled the lathe with a Starrett level, accurate to approximately 0.002. Still have the same issue.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#11

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Leveling

georgetroy

>You can look at different drive spurs and live centers also for checking, who knows if there is a difference until done. Another check, put a spur in your chuck jaws and check it out. Run out the tail stock extension a ways and check. Move the headstock to different positions and take a look. Maybe the sliding headstock and tailstock needs a little break in and use.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#12

Re: You likely have some twist in the bed.

Al Crandall -NW of Indy-

>Bed twist is usually the reason for misalignment of the centers. Even metal lathes with their heavier construction are subject to bed twist if they are not set up properly. Plus the twist in a metal lathe will cause it to turn a taper when the saddle traverses the bed length. Lathes don't have to be level to work properly, but getting them level is the easiest and best way to insure a twist free machine. Level it roughly along the bed length, and then level each end of the bed across the short dimension to as close a tolerance as you are able. I bet a lot of your problems will disappear.

Our shop recently set up two metal lathes and we used a precision level graduated in "one half thousandth per ten inches".

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#13

Re:David- I was curious about what.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...what you do for a living, and working with a metal lathe and metal tolerances explains a lot. Some "woodturners" are more interested in playing with their tools rather than turning wood, and you appear to have that "engineers" attitude. This is wood, a much more "relaxed" material, so loosen up and turn some wood that moves as it dries. Put away your dial indicators and micrometers and have some fun making wood shavings! Woodturners get nervous when we have to deal with dimensions smaller than 3/16" in thickness!

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#14

Re:David - What I do.

David - Indianapolis

>Fair enough question. Not an engineer but a scientist. Similar mindset only I work on the scale of atomic resolution (angstroms). I am a tool guy, but not really from the perspective of playing with my tools. More that I spend some extra time setting them up and checking them out at the beginning such that I don't have problems in the future. The point of the message is that I don't know what is acceptable. If this works for wood, then I am finished and can get on with the business of turning and having fun, which is my goal. If this is a problem, I would rather know now such that I can work it out with the manufacturer rather than 2-4 years from now where I become accomplished enough (hopefully) such that this becomes a hinderance to what I want to do.

Thanks,

David

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#15

Way to see if this matters

wilbur

>Take a longish piece of wood, and mount it between centers. Use a skew chisel to turn it into as even a cylinder as you can. Then reverse the piece of wood, and mount it again. If the cylinder still spins true, the 0.007" difference doesn't matter. If it's not spinning true, you can decide if the amount of inaccuracy matters to you or not.

In any case, this is a great way to get some skew chisel practice in. :@)

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#16

Re:David - What I do.

Don at Central Illinois

>If you turn any green wood, it will move more than .007" as it dries. As Jamie said, we don't really worry too much about anything less than 3/16". Have fun, make shavings, if it still doesn't seem right to you, I'll drive over and take it off your hands. You shouldn't have to work with a machine that is not 'right on'.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#17

Re:David - What I do.

Brodie Brickey

>David,

Turn some pens using a pen mandrel.

If you have problems with the wood not being circular or you get a lot of chatter, you have an issue. If not, no more worries.

.007 shouldn't cause a problem. If there is one, it will only be between centers. Once you're using a chuck for a bowl or anything else, it won't matter.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#18

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>David

You did not say the direction of the error.

If the .oo7 is consistent along the length of the ways it sounds like equipment error not leveling. Why not just shim the head stock or tail stock to bring it to alignment?

Remember wood is not like metal--IT MOVES. So even if the lathe is perfect there will be error when you remount the wood. I clean up wobble all the time and I have a Oneway 2436. Just relax and enjoy the art.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#19

Re:David - What I do.

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>David,

I believe that .004 is acceptable misalignment on most wood lathes. My last lathe had a misalignment of .006 and it drove me bonkers. On some of your work you will want to reverse the workpiece and the deviation could compound. Fitting box lids perfectly and many similar operations, can be very frustrating at .007.

Ask Mr Osolnik. Follow his advise for possible corrections and fine tuning. If you say the problem is along the entire length of the bed, I must assume that you are moving the headstock. Check also the alignment with the quill fully extended and fully retracted, as this could provide some clues.

Good Luck!

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#20

forget the 007! turn wood

robert davis

>

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#21

Re: You likely have some twist in the bed.

John Kyler

>I would agree if it gained from close to far. The bed twist would be a factor.

But likely the headstock or tail stock was machined a little off center from relation to the center line.

If it makes a difference put a shim under one side of the headstock (it stays put most of the time, tail stock is always sliding) and line them up.

Simple fix and go turn.

Otherwise call PM and see what they suggest.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#22

Not given a fair shake...

Jay in Tx

>Russ,

I enjoyed your short treatise on scroll chucks. I have to take a couple of exceptions though...

"Titan by Tecknatool

The Titan is a new and larger version of the Nova. It is heavier and used three (3) screws to attach the face jaws. That means there is no interchangeability with the other Nova chucks. This chuck appears to be an attempt to get into the same market territory as the Oneway Stronghold. Those who are using it have favorable comments. I have no comments because I have never used one of them."

Hmmm... you can use any Teknatool jawset on any Teknatool chuck, they're designed that way (except maybe the Titan Powergrip Jaws, which have the three holes you mentioned; I'll have to check them on my Supernova2 and report back) If nothing else, all but titan specific jaws are interchangable with every Teknatool chuck body, including the Titan. Appears to be an attempt?!? Rather subjective and I'm trying to stick to the facts; with the Titan powergrip jaws on my visual analysis says that there is comparatively less gripping surface area on the largest Oneway jaws. Provided the 'squeeze' of the 2 different chucks is equal for any one given user, the Titan would kick the Strongholds patooti any day, any day! Just some of my comments referencing your comments, of which you had none...

Remember to smile and laugh a little after reading this. Although it is factual, it is also a bit tongue-n-cheek!

~Jay... tired of reading and interpolating doctrine for application in applied warfare studies! Breaks over, back to writing about less desirable topics.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#23

Dick Hines

Re: Not given a fair shake...

Dick Hines

>You can't use Titan jaws on other Nova chucks. But you can use nova jaws on the Titan chuck. I have a set of Power Grip jaws,the ones made for the Super Nova chuck, on my Titan.

I like the heft of the Titan but I don't like the large jaws.The tendon has to huge.

The 75mm jaws will also fit the Titan also.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#24

.007"= 2 hairs

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>And after a few years of use, normal wear will probably result in enough slop between the tailstock and bed that you can lock the tailstock down perfectly in line with the headstock by nudging it in the right direction first.

A tiny piece of foreign material wedged in a place where it shouldn't be can throw your alignment off by a few thou, as can a nick in a morse taper shank or socket.

There's one situation where precise alignment helps on a wood lathe, is when drilling a deep hole with the tailstock. Still, a 5- or 10-thou misalignment can be dealt with while working with wood by feeding the whole tailstock into the hole instead of using the quill.

Being a serious hobby machinist for 25 years, I'm no stranger to precision and I don't think Powermatic or Osolnik would consider .007" an issue but I could be wrong.

Re: New PM3520B lathe - Comments

#25

Thanks for the input Dick

Jay in TX

>Saves me the 5 minutes of digging out the jaws, swapping, etc. You're right about the powergrips and BAT (Big @$$ Tennons), the standard powergrips least diameter tenon is big, the Titan powergrips are just plain hew-mong-gus (and that's not even looking at potential length for the tenon)! I wasn't arguing that point, even though it helps one of my original points, that the Titan can grip a chunk of wood like a divorcee on an alimony check, like a 16 year old behind the wheel on their first driving lesson, like my endless grasp on bad and off-color metaphors ;~)