Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

for JKJ re small spheres...

Posts

for JKJ re small spheres...

#1

for JKJ re small spheres...

GaryG in MD

>John,

In looking back at your original post photo, I see that you did it in end-grain orientation. I'm wondering, is that a requirement, or would it also work side-grain?

Thanks, Gary

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#2

In a sphere, there is as much side as end grain.

Craig Daymon

>The only difference is where you start. The only complete end grain lies at a single point perpendicular to the grain orientation. The only complete side grain lies at a single point parallel to the grain orientation.

In other words, it should work just as well for end grain as side grain.

-Craig

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#3

Except...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You are more likely to break the sphere free before it is done if the small tenon is side grain.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#4

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

John K Jordan

>I agree with Brian - I broke some off even when turning end grain so I can imagine grain running across would be much more fragile. But it might work Ok depending on the type of wood and how thick you left the support.

I've made a bunch more since I posted that first picture. I wish I had some quality steel for the little tube gouge - it dulls quickly.

JKJ

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#5

Steven Antonucci

How big do you need?

steve antonucci

>I have a box for you, and I might have a short length of O1 somewhere? What diameter and length? If I don't you can buy it at the Home Depot (cold rolled) and drill out the center an inch.

Steven

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#6

True, but final piece has equal amounts.

Craig Daymon

>I was thinking of the final piece, not getting there.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#7

Steve...

GaryG in MD

>Off hand, do you know of a source of HSS tubing? Enco or otherwise? Thanks, Gary

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#8

Steven Antonucci

Never ordered tubing

steve antonucci

>I've heard that you can regrind a hole saw, but never tried it.

Steven

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#9

Re: How big do you need?

John K Jordan

>>...I might have a short length of O1 somewhere? What diameter and length?

I have plenty of cold rolled, but I'd like to find a piece of tool steel that can be worked then hardened, perhaps .5" in diameter. I have a friend with a metal-turning lathe so I guess I could drill out the center.

JKJ

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#10

Agreed.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#11

Did that. It likes to dig in. Abandoned it.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#12

You can't harden cold rolled steel.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Cold rolled is a mild (low carbon) steel.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#13

I looked for tubing...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>All of the temperable tubing I saw very expensive with an 8' minimum order. The reasonably priced tubing was all mild steel.

It looks like the best bet is to drill out the center of some O1 drill stock.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#14

Steven Antonucci

Probably right, but

steve antonucci

>It will still take an edge even if it won't hold one. I'd burn a wood fire to introduce some carbon into the steel and see if that didn't help. Worst case, you have a red hot poker in you barbeque.

If it doesn't harden, it can still cut wood, just not very long.

Steven

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#15

304 Stainless Stl seamless tubing *LINK*

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>After reading John's first post on these, I tried making a few using some 3/8" ID seamless Stainless steel tubing. My first efforts were bad, but I got the hang of it. I put a a beveled edge and I got some catches at first. I'm thinking of trying a not so sharp bevel with a burred edge instead. This is based on the method that Phil Irons recommends when using a hole saw with the teeth ground off.

The 304 tubing holds a edge better than the cold rolled.

Here is an olone source, but I have not ordered from them.


304 Stainless steel tubing.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#16

Thinking out loud here.....

Barry Irby

>I've never tried using a tube to turn a sphere, so I am totally unqualified to comment, but could you do the same thing with a piece of flat stock with a hole drilled in it? Near the end and round the end off?

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#17

Re: Probably right, but

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>There is a process called case hardening to diffuse carbon into mild steel so it will hold an edge. It is a little more complicated than just heating the steel in a wood fire.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#18

Re: 304 Stainless Stl seamless tubing

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Eddie, That's great info. ...Gary

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#19

JKJ ... John,

GaryG in MD

>What would you say is a good tube thickness for, say, a 3/4" OD tube -- I'm guessing something like 1/16"?? ... Gary

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#20

Re: JKJ ... John,

John K Jordan

>>What would you say is a good tube thickness for, say, a 3/4" OD tube

Yikes, I haven't tried one that big. It seems like the wall thickness would only need to be enough to keep the tube from flexing or deforming so I would try at least the 1/16", perhaps 1/8". Based on my experience with the smaller tube, a 3/4" (ID) tube should be pretty good for spheres around 7/8" or so.

I made a pile of the 1/2" spheres and it was good clean fun - I need to find some different tube sizes now!

JKJ

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#21

unfortunately...

GaryG in MD

>304 stainless has a Rockwell C hardness of only around 14, so it's less than ideal. Perhaps that's the best we can do, but I'll try looking around. ...Gary

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#22

Re: unfortunately...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Plus it can not be heat treated, only strain hardened.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#23

Don't need a bevel, just a burr, no heat treat

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Last night I used a Dremel to remove the teeth on an old 1 2/4" dia/ hole saw. I then ground the edge to a uniform flat edge using the side of the grinding wheeel and with a light touch. Phil Irons states that you use the inside burr of the hole saw to remove material and create the ball. Hole saws are heat treated steel so I don't know how the heck he created a burr. I left mine as is with no bevel and crisp edges and I was able to quickly create some wooden balls. I got close with the gouge and then performed a "scraping" function with the hole saw. On cherry I got some burning and a bit of chatter, but that due to not holding the hole saw firmly. I ground off the bevel of the tubing I had and created a small burr on the inside and it worked better than with he bevel. The thing is though, is that you have to get closer to taget size with a skew or gouge.

Oh, if the hole saw swallows the wooden ball?... POW!

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#24

Re: unfortunately...

Ed Karch

>How about some tubing from junk bikes? That could be fairly hard.

Re: for JKJ re small spheres...

#25

thanks...

GaryG in MD

>Eddie,

Thanks for reporting on the results of your experiments. This is all very interesting info. It seems like we all have a lot to learn about the possibilities. Trying various things is fun. Thanks for the renewed warning re size.

...Gary