Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

flute lengths???

Posts

flute lengths???

#1

flute lengths???

Mark Paulley

>Hello all,

I am looking at purchasing a new 1/2" spindle gouge and notice most of the flutes are stated at 4-6". So,why are spindle gouges with shorter (length) flutes then bowl gouges?

Just curious?

Thanks

Mark

Re: flute lengths???

#2

Re: flute lengths???

Allen Neighbors

>I'm not sure, but it could be that there is some sort of built in obsolescence... it stands to reason, that the larger manufacturer is in it for the bottom line, and the shorter the flute, means the sooner you have to re-purchase.

I'm glad Doug's gouges aren't like that. His rock!!

Re: flute lengths???

#3

Re: flute lengths???

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Mark

Me thinks it is to reduce vibration

Re: flute lengths???

#4

Re: flute lengths???

Pete in Holland, MI

>Flutes cost money to machine in. You could flute the entire shaft, but will it really do you any good with only 2" of steel sticking out of the handle after years of use?

Re: flute lengths???

#5

Re: flute lengths???

Don Evans

>It has to do with the way the two different tools are used. Spindle work verse bowl work. You need a shorter handle for spindle work in order to keep it from getting in your way, therefore, shorter handle requires shorter steel in order to maintain control.

Bowl work on the other hand makes you use the tool differently. Next time you turn each, bowl verse spindle, note which way the handles are facing, spindle for example will have the handle between your body and the work, while bowl will have it down (shear cut) or off to one side.

Don

Re: flute lengths???

#6

Re: flute lengths???

Fog Tanner

>In a conversation with Stu Batty when he was getting tools from Sorby, he related one of the reasons, at least on Sorby and Henry Taylor lines. The shallow gouge is shorter than the deep fluted gouge because it will flex more. The last two inches are not hardened as a "safety measure". They would rather the tool flex than break. But you also wind up with a shorter flute. As Allen mentioned you don't have that worry with the Thompson gouges.

The two tools are really shallow and deep fluted, but have been associated with either spindle or bowls. You can use either one for either discipline as long as you stay within the limits of the tool. One of our club members bought a 5/8" Thompson detail gouge to turn the outside of bowls. Half the time I use a 1/2" Thompson shallow gouge on the outside where a long reach isn't needed.

Re: flute lengths???

#7

Re: flute lengths??? *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>It also has to do with the rigidity of the gouge. The spindle gouge has half of the steel milled away.

Instead of selling us one gouge, some are selling us 3 gouges in different flute lengths.

CSUSA used to carry them, but I can't find them in their web site any more.

One way to overcome this is having a shallower flute. Thompson has a line called "Detail Gouge" (33% flute) which is a cross between spindle gouge and real detail gouge (20% flute "Shallow flute detail gouge").

http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/tooltype.asp?TYPE=D

http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/tooltype.asp?TYPE=SD

Less flue also means narrower flute width. The sweet spot of the edge is also narrower. Gain some, lose some; we always have to compromise.

Gordon


Hamlet Stuart Mortimer gouges