I'd finish first.
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I always apply the finish first. That way the piece is done! Plus I don't have to worry about cutting through the darkened layer if I need to sand it again.
The one caveat is to make sure the Danish Oil has time to cure before you put it in direct sunlight, especially the first coat. Otherwise the heat will cause the oil to bubble out, which is a real nuisance.
A chemical stain like lye will hasten the process and give you significant head start. Unlike Steve, I've never seen a difference between using lye, potash, dichromate or sunlight.
Remember that cherry darkens different amounts depending on who-knows-what. I made a cherry tool cabinet and used a piece of cherry from a different source for the door panels. After twenty years, the panels are still lighter than the cabinet was when it was first made.