Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Temple box is finished, except for.....

Posts

Temple box is finished, except for.....

#1

Temple box is finished, except for.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... the final finish. I stuck with the original design to emphasize the rounded center section- had considered a square top, but decided to stay round. 12"Wx8 1/2"H spalted maple


img

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#2

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

Mike Brazeau

>Excellent work Jamie. I like!

Mike

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#3

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

Steven Kubien

>Not what I envisioned but I really like it. I see an old samurai, wearing his brain-bucket, going to battle. Very cool.

Steve Kubien

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#4

Steven Antonucci

I'm not sure...

steve antonucci

>if it's because it didn't match what I saw when you posted the base, or if it's something else, but something "off" for me?

Finial appears short and thick?

Lid "breaks" the eggplant shape below?

Don't know why, but I'd mock up another one...

Steven

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#5

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

Carole Valentine

>Jamie, this definitely falls in the "howdhedothat" category. All I can think of is "Ouch!" I like it, but I think the finial is too ordinary for this piece. The box is different - the finial needs to be something simple that won't detract from the main piece. Something that will be "different" in it's own right, yet complimentary. Don't ask me what...I haven't thought of anything yet. :)

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#6

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

GaryG in MD

>Jamie,

On an absolute scale, this is a wonderful piece. But... With all due respect to your obvious skills and to this excellent work (that I certainly don't have the skills to create), I have to go with Steve on this one. It just doesn't quite feel right to me. The finial seems heavy (not enough 'swoop', if you know what I mean) and a bit short, and I'm not sure the sharp cone shape of the top complements the base to the best possible extent. Perhaps the aspect that most grabs my attention in an undesired way is the squarish step at the bottom of the finial. That abrupt form seems out of place with this piece of lovely curves. I think if that were more curved, I would like it better. Again, overall, it's a wonderful piece -- just being ultra picky here because I think that's what you're after in asking for comments. ...Gary

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#7

That's It!

Ron McKinley

>The top really completes the piece. Very nice....Ron

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#8

Jamie, I printed your photo and

Ruth Niles

>I rarely comment on pieces, my first reaction was "perfect!", then I read the critiques, printed your picture, saw what the others were talking about, sorry, I still say "perfect!"

A thinner finial is a woodturner's challenge, the bowl is pleasantly rounded, the finial follows that form "perfect".

The center part could sit very nicely alone making the collar flow through that form very sweetly.

This piece presents different forms that flow and blend in a most artistic manner.

It's Perfect.

Re: Temple box is finished, except for.....

#9

Re: That's nice to hear Ruth, thanks!

Jamie Donaldson

>