Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Thompson skew

Posts

Thompson skew

#1

Thompson skew

john lucas

>I just finished a production run of bottle stoppers and hand mirrors. I'm in love with the Thompson Skew. It doesn't do anything my other skew won't do but it holds an edge for a long time. I have trouble comparing my bowl gouges because I sharpen so often but when I as doing this production run I really noticed the difference. It just stays sharp forever. It takes a little tiny bit longer to sharpen but is easily worth it.

Re: Thompson skew

#2

Re: Thompson skew

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>John,

Does Doug also cryo treat his skews? I would assume he does, but don't know for sure. If he does, do you think it's that cryo treatment that affects the longevity of the edge? I own a Henry Taylor Kryo skew and it's edge also has impressive longevity.

keithz

Re: Thompson skew

#3

Steven Antonucci

Cryogenic treatment is good for steel

steve antonucci

>I don't remember all the particulars from Materials courses I took 22 years ago, but crystalline structures develop in the metal during processing. I belive the cryo reformulates and aligns these crystals into a more regular matrix.

Should get sharper and better wear resistance after cryo. (I think?)

Since Doug's starting with a powder metal, I'd bet that also helps. Been 22 years since Materials, so I'm really fuzzy about that lab we did...

Steven

Re: Thompson skew

#4

Re: Thompson skew

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>John, thanks for the kind words,

Keith, The heat treatment is the same for all the tools.

Steve, here's a copy and paste from the site.

This is very involved so let's keep it simple. When steel is first hardened the structure of the steel changes to form austinite which is very brittle. We want to change the austinite that's brittle to a hard structure call martensite, to do this the steel needs to be tempered. This is done by heating the steel then allowing it to cool at a very slow rate. When the austinite is changed to martensite by tempering carbides are formed of each element of the steel. We want vanadium carbides to form and we want lots of them in our steel so after the first temper with heat the steel goes into a cryogenic treatment. Cryogenics is part of the tempering process but when the austinite is changed to martensite by freezing lots and lots of very fine carbides form called "eta" carbides, these are the carbides that we want.

Now the sad news, Not 2 hours ago my steel supplier called and told me vanadium has taken a huge jump in price over the past few weeks (like 2X) this is 10% vanadium. It's time to hold on and ride out the storm then see what happens.

Re: Thompson skew

#5

Everythings rising

john lucas

>OK gas went up and it was tough, food went up and that is getting tough but if they raise the price of my turning tools it will be intolerable. To heck with global warming this is now getting serious. (that's a joke so jump down my throat)

Re: Thompson skew

#6

A sweet tool...

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Like John I am in love with my Thompson skews, 1" & 1/2", both once sharpened and honed seem to just keep going, and I was turning some curly maple and some black locust, the maple was so smooth after the skew that I decided no sanding was needed. I hate sanding, so this pair gets me a little closer to a personal goal: No sanding.

Thank you Doug!

Jorge

a happy turner.

Re: Thompson skew

#7

Re: Thompson skew

Russ Fairfield

>Its the steel and alloying metals that make the tool, the cryogenic treatment just makes it better. Its like the add says, "be all you can be".

My observation is that Cryogenic treatment of an plain M2 HSS is a waste of money. Cryogenic treatment of an M4 or better is worth the money IF we can make use of the better tool.

Re: Thompson skew

#8

Steven Antonucci

Remembered Martensite, forgot Austenite

steve antonucci

>It's funny how as an Electrical Engineering major I hate Statics and Materials. I wish I had spent more time in the steel labs now...

Thanks for jogging an old memory.

Steve

Re: Thompson skew

#9

Re: Everythings rising

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>John, the way it looks right now this steel will jump 4 bucks a pound. Early next week a thousand pound order will be made, like I said before it's time to hold on and hope it doesn't go higher. Steel prices are like any other raw material they do jump around.

Re: Thompson skew

#10

Re: Thompson skew

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Russ, you are correct cryogenics only works on steel the has carbide forming elements in it to begin with. The higher percentage of these elements the better cryogenics works. The next AAW magazine should have an article about our tool steels including cryogenics... fingers crossed this steel does well.

Jorge, "once sharpened" is so true LoL I never learned how to sharpen a skew and it shows.

Steve, I had to jog the memory a few years ago... it's some dry reading to say the least.

Re: Thompson skew

#11

Re: Thompson skew

john lucas

>Long before I heard about cyrogenic turning tools my good friend who was a NASCAR mechanic told me about using cryogenically toughened axels. It made them harder or at least tougher without making them brittle. He said when inspected after races they was noticeably less wear.

That's what we want in a turning tool. Steel that holds an edge as long as if it had been hardened to a higher Rockwell but less brittle than the same steel.

Re: Thompson skew

#12

Re: A sweet tool...

Brian McInturff

>Doug,

I just put an order in for a few more tools. I notice you are sold out of the 1 1/4 Skew. When do you think you will get some more made. When you do, how about letting me know and I'll send a paypal payment for it too. I also have bought a few things from Hannes, any chance you or someone else can tell me how to do his grind? Once I dull it down I'd like to keep to that grind. Plus I have a few other of your gouges I'd like to put that grind on. Thanks, Brian

Re: Thompson skew

#13

Brian, the information

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Brian, the stock is being gound to thickness right now then needs to be sent out to be cut into strips. I be able to start machining in a month or so. They just don't make flat bar stock from this steel so you need to be creative.

This batch will have 1/4 skews, 5/16 scrapers and skews and a few 1-3/8 X 3/8 scrapers and skews.

Re: Thompson skew

#14

Re: Brian, the information

Brian McInturff

>Doug, put me down for a 1 1/4 Skew and just drop me a message when they it's ready. By then I may be ready for a scraper too(or maybe 3). Thanks and as they say - "YOU DA MAN"!!