Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Suspended development? I'm done with...

Posts

Suspended development? I'm done with...

#1

Suspended development? I'm done with...

Jamie Donaldson

>... the base except for final finish, but haven't decided about the top- a rounded black dome with short finial, or flaired lid with taller finial? This is a another variation on the square pieces I've been making for years, but this is the tallest "bag of sand" shape I've made for the center vessel. I didn't properly anticipate the abuse my finger tips would suffer trying to sand that inner top area! So give me some feed-back on the top!


img

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#2

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

GaryG in MD

>That's nice work Jamie -- I like it. I understand your quandry -- you may have to make two or three tops and try them out to see which you like best in place. ...or, of course, you could ask us again. ;-)

It's a pretty substantial form, and I think it will support a pretty substantial finial -- not one of those "delicate" ones.

I can see it in one of two ways:

1) Put a black or red lacquer domed box-lid type top on it that overlaps the lip by a fair amount and has a thin, Japanese-style "handle" that mirrors the shape of the main support wings and is attached at two fairly closely spaced points... or...

2)if you want to go for a tall finial, my reco for the height is to make the top of the finial, when in place, exactly twice the height from the contact point to the top of the shoulder (not including the lip). I realize that's not a typical "magic" number, but it seems right to me. I'd try for something like an onion dome on the lower end and finish it with a flame at the top.

JMOs, Gary

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#3

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Steven Kubien

>Gary, picture this...

A shallow dome with a U-shape support coming out the middle. Across the upper arms of the U would be a turned spindle which would extend slightly past the arms of the U. Is that what you mean by giving it an erastern flair? If so, then I whole heartedly agree. Make the dome and cross spindle the same colour (black or deep red) and the upright arms of the U a piece of that spalted maple(I thnk that's what the rest is) and then I think we would have a winner.

Steve Kubien

OT Trying to type with my ring finger in a splint because I crushed it in a car door...sucks!

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#4

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Mark Paulley

>Jamie,

Cool looking piece. Why not just photo and make copies that you can draw on to shorten what will work and what will not.

Just a suggestion

Mark

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#5

Re: Mark- photos I can do, but draw I cannot!

Jamie Donaldson

>.....

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#6

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

GaryG in MD

>Steve,

Very sorry to hear about your finger. ...and in a car door... I know you want so badly to "take it back". You'd almost feel better if you had done it on the lathe. I hope it heals up really soon.

Re the lid, yeah, my one idea is for a lid with what I would call a "crosspiece" supported from two closely spaced inserts or one into a "U", but with a fairly wide wingspan in a shape that mirrors the wings below it -- as you say, all one color.

This is such an interesting form that I think a number of things could work well with it.

...Gary

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#7

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Steven Kubien

>Ok, that's what I thought you meant on the eastern theme for the lid. Again, I think it would work but it's not my piece.

Yeah, I slipped on some ice as +I was closing the door on my van, grabbed what I could (the closing door) and then said some things that would make a drill sergent blush. What sucks more than not being able to type is that I was hoping to grade for my nidan (2nd degree black belt) in May. I have no idea how these sorts of things heal but right now I cannot even grip a sword and can't imagine trying to hold on to one as someone tried to knock it out of my hands. Do you think sak�� will help? I'll go try that now....

Steve Kubien

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#8

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Texian

>A very cool piece indeed! Please tell us the dimensions and type of wood. For those of us (well, for me) with limited "artistic vision", Gary's suggestion (make several tops from cheap wood and paint as needed) works best.

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#9

Steven Antonucci

The lid should be pretty tall

steve antonucci

>I'm thinking about 1/3 the overall height of the existing vessel. Finial, Japanese horizontal handle, - your call. I think the finial would need to be pretty tall, or risk being underwhelmed by the piece.

I like it how it is. Why do you think it needs a lid?

Steven

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#10

Re: Texian- this is spalted red maple....

Jamie Donaldson

>...from my shop stash, and is 12"Wx5"H. I'll work on the top this weekend.

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#11

Are you going to teach that .

Charlie Anderson

>at John C Campbell this summer?

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#12

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

GaryG in MD

>Sake' may not speed the healing, but you won't care as much! ;-0

Or, as Judy Carne once said on Laugh In, "It may be rice wine to you, but it's Sake To Me". Whereupon, they did.

...Gary

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#13

Re: Charlie-my square turning class....

Jamie Donaldson

>...at the Folk School is Mar.16~22, but I won't attempt something like this with beginning turners. I don't like to see bloodstains on turning projects, and it can't be disguised as spalted box elder!

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#14

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Mike Brazeau

>I am with Steve A - I don't think it needs a lid. I really like it the way it is. If anything not a tall finial and I would make something out of the same wood if you have any left. Maybe a short little stem of ebony or ebonized wood to pick the lid off. The spalting is busy enough to mask any matching problems. A lid contrasting color will draw away from the form, which is already excellent.

Must have been some delicate turning getting the shape in the upper portion of the vessel.

Very nicely done Jamie.

Mike

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#15

Thanks, Jamie.....

Texian

>

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Suspended development? I'm done with...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jamie, I would call this piece finished as well.....It's all good! In my opinion, for a lid/finial to work, the form has to flow through the wings, right up into the lid, and then the finial. As it is, the top of the vessel and the rim pass through the wings at nearly ninety degrees....adding a lid will create an abrupt change that will be hard to visually rectify. I think a lid with finial has to be designed in, right from the start. Imagine a streamlined water droplet passing through the wings....a good flow with no breaks in the line.