Rottenstone
Bill Crommett
>Does any one know the place on the FEPA scale for Rottenstone and Pumice ? I know there is F-2 and F-4, but where do they stand in relation to P 2000 sanding paper ?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Rottenstone
Bill Crommett
>Does any one know the place on the FEPA scale for Rottenstone and Pumice ? I know there is F-2 and F-4, but where do they stand in relation to P 2000 sanding paper ?
Re: Rottenstone
john lucas
>I tried on day to find out how things related such as 0000 steel wool and )) steel wood to sandpaper grits or white buffing pads. This also relates to white buffing compound and Pumice and Rottenstone. I'll be very interested.
Scotchbrite ratings.
john lucas
>I know this doesn't answer your question. I'll keep looking until my next client gets here (there alway late).
COTCHBRITE GRIT CHART (courtesy of Charlest) back to top
3M Scotch Brite Nylon Pads:
7445 - White pad, called Light Duty Cleansing - (1000) 1200-1500 grit
7448 - Light Grey, called Ultra Fine Hand - (600-800) 800 grit.
6448 - Green (?), called Light Duty Hand Pad - (600) 600 grit
7447 - Maroon pad, called General Purpose Hand - (320-400) 320 grit
6444 - Brown pad, called Extra Duty Hand - (280-320) 240 grit
7446 - Dark Grey pad, called Blending Pad (180-220) 150 grit
7440 - Tan pad, called Heavy Duty Hand Pad - (120-150) 60(?)
Green Scotch Brite is available EVERYWHERE. It's 600 grit.
Blue Scotch-Brite is considered to be about 1000 grit.
(The value inside the parentheses is directly from 3M.)
3M Chart
Re: Rottenstone
Cyril Griesbach
>Good question, Bill and I have also wanted to ask if anyone used rottenstone on turnings as a finishing step. I know that the Amana Furniture Factory in Amana, IA uses rottenstone on the furniture it produces and the silky smooth satin finish is, INMHO, fantastic.
I hope I didn't hijack your thread.
Re: Rottenstone
Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner
>I did find a link on use but not Grit size.
Pumice and rottenstone as a polish for a furniture finish
Pumice and rottenstone
Pumice and Rottenstone, about 3/4 of the way down the page at this link, are weathered limestone. Pumice is a very fine abrasive and rottenstone is a very very fine abrasive. Pumice is used to polish a furniture finish to a lustrous sheen and rottenstone is used for polishing to a high shine on furniture finishes, brass and other metals, glass and just about anything else that needs a high shine.
If you want a high shine start with the pumice and rub the whole surface then go back and rub the whole surface with rottenstone.
Furniture cleaner and felt pads
You'll also need some Prelude Furniture Cleaner and felt. The furniture cleaner is for the final cleaning after your furniture finish polishing job and the felt for making polishing pads.
You'll need a sanding block, either a commercial one with a hard surface or a block of wood. A section of 1x4 or 2x4 cut about 6 inches long will give a good size block that would be comfortable for most hands. Cut a piece of felt large enough to cover the bottom working surface and fold up over the sides of the block to insure that there are no sharp edges to scratch the furniture finish.
Lubricant for pumice and rottenstone
The pumice and rottenstone needs to have a lubricant to make them work. Pumice and rottenstone can be mixed with water or with a light oil as a lubricant. They're more abrasive and cut quicker with water than they do with oil. I always suggest that first time pumice and rottenstone polishers use oil as the lubricant to get the feel of how it works, because if you're not really careful you can go through the finish.
Mix the furniture polishing compound
Just about any light oil will do as a lubricant. Vegetable oil is a good one for starters and it's generally available in most kitchens.
Start out with one cup of oil or water and add one tablespoon of rottenstone. You can vary the amount to suit your needs after you get the feel of the polishing power of the pumice or rottenstone. You can increase the amount of pumice or rottenstone for more cutting action.
On to the furniture polish with pumice and rottenstone
Keep the mixture of pumice or rottenstone and lubricant stirred up to keep the abrasive in suspension.
Soak the felt pad with the polishing solution and start rubbing the furniture finish. Rub only back and forth in the direction of the grain. If you rub in an arc motion or a circular motion you could end up with little swirls in your final finish.
Work in a small area until you get the sheen or shine that you desire, then keep moving to different areas until the whole surface is done, then go back and with long sweeping motions back and forth blend the areas together.
The surface will be white from the pumice or rottenstone while your working with it. Keep a soft cloth handy and wipe the residue frequently so you can see how your work is progressing.
After the pumice or rottenstone for an even higher furniture polish shine
If you'd like an even higher shine than you can get with pumice and rottenstone you can follow the steps on our French Polish page.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Rottenstone
Ron in Drums PA
>FFFFF rottenstone is equivalent to #00000 steel wool.
Tripoli is made from rottenstone.
Rottenstone is powdered decomposed limestone.
Re: Rottenstone
Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner
>I did a little more searching and Rottenstone / Tripoli does not have a grit rating.
Bill
Going with the grain...
Steven Kubien
>I understand that in typical furniture situations you go- with the grain with either pumice or r-stone but what about with turnings? I realize that wood is wood but since a lot of the finishes we use are applied on the lathe with the piece spinning I wonder if it is appropriate to use these on a spinning lathe as well.
What say you?
Steve Kubien
Re: Rottenstone
Bill Crommett
>What a great response> Nobody hijacked my thread, but I still didn't find the answer to my question even though I learned a lot about Pumice, Rottenstone, Scotchbrite, Tripoli, and steel wool, as well as the proceedure for using the Rottenstone and Pumice on fine furniture.
John: the Scotchbrite grades have been a question to me for some time, even though I have been using them in four grades for years. I have copied your response and it will hang on my supply cabinet door along with my directory sheet on sandpaper with different standards.
The reason I asked the question in the first place is that after applying 20 or 50 coats of Deft spray to an Urn I am making, I learned that Mark Kauder says that Deft is a NO-NO, apparently because it is too brittle and will deteriorate with wood movement. So I am in the process of removing the Deft, which if you have never tried it , is a difficult procedure. That is when I discovered some Rottenstone and Pumice that has set in my cabinet unopened for many years, and I am nosy.
be careful with the green...
GaryG in MD
>Perhaps they are some other brand (not Scotch), but there are green pads out there that are very coarse -- say 100 grit. ...Gary
Re: Going with the grain...
john lucas
>Steve it depends on how thick your finish is. My experience on furniture was that if I had a high build finish the final steps didn't matter on direction because all you were doing was polishing the finish. If you have a low build that still shows the pores then following the grain is important.
So to answer your question, I think if you are trying for a perfectly glass smooth finish the final polishing steps shouldn't matter if you follow the grain. I have limited experience with this on turnings because I seldom do this kind of finish but the above holds true for what I've done.
Re: Going with the grain...
Steven Kubien
>Thanks John. I will file this away for future reference.
Steve
Re: Rottenstone
Ron in Drums PA
>Close but not exact
F - 0 -- 60~80 grit
FF - 00 -- 100~120 grit
FFF - 000 -- 220~280 grit
FFFF - 0000 -- 400~500 grit
FFFFF - 00000 -- 800~1000 grit
Since rottenstone is F5....
Bill, I can't answer your question...
Allen Neighbors
>but I can say this: Someone's post above, said something about rottenstone being white. I've never seen it in white.
Now I will tell you that I've only used it once, and that might have been the wrong way to use it, but it ruined a beautiful bandsaw box I was trying to get to a hand-rubbed look.
The Rottenstone I bought at our local lumberyard/hardware store was in a pint, cardboard "milk carton". It was black powder, sort of dark gray, actually. It stained the wood I was using it on to a murky bog-water yuk... (how's that for a description?) It's the only box that I ever changed the color of the natural wood on. I threw the rest of it in the dumpster.
Re: Bill, I can't answer your question...
Fog Tanner
>Allen,
I got mine in a 1 pound bag, and it is a gray powder as you describe. I also bought some alledged "fine" pumic which turned out to be rotten stone, so now I have about 2 pounds of it - along with a pound of real pumic. No way I'm throwing 2 pounds of that away, even if I have to mix it with epoxy and use it as a stone finish...
I mixed up some in some wax as a polishing compound. I tried it on a test piece of bare wood that had been sanded. I use the EEE-Ultrashine in the same fashion and never had any problems. It is a wax with an abrasive in it also. The results were not what I had gotten with the EEE, so I shelved the jar of wax/abrasive. Like you I was looking for a hand rubbed surface on the bare wood.
Later I was reading my handbook on polishing and found that the rotten stone is used in French polishing on a film finish like shellac. I have a piece now that I am trying various flavors of shellac (have several pounds of that too), and I plan on trying my mixture on that when I get down to the final finish.
Re: Bill, I can't answer your question...
john lucas
>Obviously you both learned that pumice and rottenstone aren't used on bare wood. The same is true for the dark wet/dry sandpapers. The dust fills the pores and looks terrible. These are polishing tools to polish the finish. Even tripoli and White diamond are not good on bare wood. Tripoli will fill the pores of Ash and color it and white diamond will do the same to Walnut and ruin it. I will skip the white diamond when buffing walnut even when it has a light finish. I skip the tripoli on light woods. If you fill the pores with finish or a pore filler then you can use any of the above.