Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Lucky me

Posts

Lucky me

#1

Dick Hines

Lucky me

Dick Hines

>I was driving pass a friends home this morning and low and behold what did see, not a fat man with a team of deer but but a large cherry burl. I stopped to ask if I could collect it. YES!!! Gald there were no cops in my end of the county. I made the 8 mile round trip in 10 minutes flat.

After looking at the tree I noticed there was a smaller bulr up a little higher. The tree was about 10" in D. I cut the tree and away I went The big burl was measured at 16"x16".

Now I have to figure out how to cut it. I could get 2 large bowls or one XXL hollow form. I guess I will spend a while just looking at it until I deside what to.

NO! I am not going to send it to any of you guys. I know what you are thinking.

Re: Lucky me

#2

Better lock you shop!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Lucky me

#3

Re: Better lock you shop!

John K Jordan

>Some of the small sawmills give those nasty things away. One guy told me he used to burn them until he found out woodturners like them, so now he throws them in the corner. Last time I visited I got one and turned down another because it was too big for me to manage. I called him a few weeks ago and he said sure, there were some, come help yourself.

Anyone who needs turning wood might ask at the local sawmills.

JKJ

Re: Lucky me

#4

Steven Antonucci

Don't say it too loud!

steve antonucci

>Someone in my neighbor is likely to learn my little secret! I've been in cahoots with the locals for years doing just that. Can't fit a burl through the mill, so they cut em off an pile them for me...

At the Woodworks show today, a well known dealer of hardwoods had apparently thought they could win the lottery on some of their burls. Apparently, they didn't realize most turners own a chainsaw...

Steven

Re: Lucky me

#5

Re: Better lock you shop!

Carole Valentine

>No sawmills here anymore. When there were they only processed pine. :(

Re: Lucky me

#6

Steven Antonucci

Did you cut a standing tree just for the burls?

steve antonucci

>At least that's how I'm reading it? There are several trees in my neighborhood that fit your description, but I personally enjoy them standing more than turning. I only cut down dead-standing trees or from trees that are already downed.

What did you do with the rest of the wood?

Steven

Re: Lucky me

#7

What's the difference?

Raymond Overman in SC

>Steve, this is somewhat in response to your post below but referencing the post above.

You have no problem with partaking in the bounty of burls where someone else did the dirty work of "cutting the standing tree" yet you seem to have an issue with Dick harvesting a tree himself. I don't see the difference either way just because you're once removed from the process.

I don't see an issue with taking a tree if you have permission from the owner as long as the rest of the tree isn't left to rot.

Re: Lucky me

#8

Steven Antonucci

Since you asked...

steve antonucci

>Philosophically, I don't see cutting a tree just to satisfy my hobby as being something I would do. I've cut deadstanding trees because of the hazard they create (falling limbs, falling trees...), and if there is anything salvageable, I'll process it into turning blanks. The tree is already dead when I do this, not because I did it.

I don't buy wood all that often, because I don't know a whole lot about the practices used to harvest it. If I spend $100 in a year on wood, it would surprise me. I try to use things locally available that are destined for a landfill. People cut trees, they fall in storms, or die of old age- there is so much wood available that taking a living tree seems, well, wrong.

A 10" cherry tree isn't very old, and probably had another 50+ years left if left alone. Since he only talked about the burls, I assume the rest of it wasn't very interesting. I know of several burls in my area that I could probably go get, but I think more of the tree than my hobby.

You don't have to agree with me, but it struck me as not the best idea...

Steven

Re: Lucky me

#9

Re: Since you asked...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>When I was a kid in high school in the 30's I worked summers in a logging camp in the Pac. NW. In those days a lot of what was left in the woods was burned. The same in the mills. Much of the air pollution in the NW was smoke from the lumber mills and logging operations. Today that has changed. In the woods they don't burn and there is a huge replanting operation ongoing. The lumber mills have very little waste. What used to be burned goes into products like chipboard, etc.

However, almost any home built in the NW has a wood burning fireplace, and they don't use it for heating their homes. (a few are nat. gas). The sale of firewood is a big business.

Here in the SW desert we treat trees with a lot of respect.

Wally

Re: Lucky me

#10

Re: Since you asked...

John K Jordan

>>...The lumber mills have very little waste.

I watched a local large commercial hardwood sawmill operation and there was no waste. Every cubic inch of what didn't get sold for lumber was chipped for mulch. They collected and sold the sawdust too.

Something curious I see near here every week - long lines of railroad cars loaded to overflowing with wood chips. I'm told in the mountains a bit north of here someone is clear-cutting. Every tree, regardless of size or type, is chipped and shipped to make manufactured wood products. (I don't know if this is fact or rumor, but the railroad cars continue to come.)

JKJ

Re: Lucky me

#11

Re: Since you asked...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Steve,

I had the same reaction as you. I know Dick and I admire his work, but my practice is to not take down a tree for my own profit unless it is already doomed by disease, age, or circumstance, i.e., someone else is already planning on taking it out.

Trees are alive. To extinguish that life force for selfish motives seems demeaning to me.

Like you, I scavenge wood from wherever I can. Turning it back around to other woodturners is a necessity to keep from losing it to natural degradation.

No offense, Dick,

Gary

Re: Lucky me

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Did you cut a standing tree just for the burls

Dick Hines

>Check above post. Tree was not cut just for the burl. And I tool some of the larger trunk too.

Re: Lucky me

#13

Re: Since you asked...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Tremendous amounts of woodchips are used in this country and also shipped overseas for the manufacture of paper.

Wally

Re: Lucky me

#14

Steven Antonucci

Saw that. Thanks!

steve antonucci

>

Re: Lucky me

#15

Re: Lucky me

Mark Williamson

>Wow. What a way to burst a bubble. I for one am excited for your find! I have a small cherry tree in my front yard right now that I have been thinking about sacrificing to the turning gods! This thing has burls all over it! The bottom bells out quite a bit so I am actually debating digging the thing up just to see if it is burl at the bell! I don't like the idea of leveling all the trees of the world however, since man has been around we have cut trees for our personal gain! Imagine if you will your favorite wood to turn! NOW, imagine that there is that tree in your back yard and you just KNOW that it is full of figure and burls! Your saying that you would rather it rot out and die than to one day cut it and use it's offerings to make many wonderful things that will give that tree meaning and purpose for possibly hundreds of years to come?! Did all of you build your houses useing no lumber? When was the last time you bought a 2X4 just to get it home and hack it up into pieces only to use it for something temporary? At least as someones turning block, it is a good chance that it will end up being something beautiful that will bring much joy to someones life instead of falling to the ground only to rot away and be forgoten forever. (If the tree was ever noticed to begin with.)

My wife bought me a 4X6X6 block of amboyna burl for valentines day! I have never had a piece of wood that cost $85! This single piece of wood has gotten more attention than it would have ever gotten rotting on the ground! I am SO very glad that someone, somewhere, saw this beauty and decided to whack it down for a profit! LOL

Congrats on the cherry find! Woo Hoo!!!

Mark

Re: Lucky me

#16

Steven Antonucci

Thankfully, this wasn't Dick's attitude.

steve antonucci

>When I go to the SF Bay area, I always walk through Muir Woods. There is a single redwood tree there that I always marvel at. On the side, about 40' up it's 20' diameter trunk is a burl the size of a Volkswagen Beetle. I marvel at the fact that this tree is a living thing that has seen way more of human history than any of us ever will and is thankfully protected from man's need to destroy the environment. I would never consider touching this tree just to take the burl for my own need. I don't understand what makes one tree any different than another, so I'd never consider it with this cherry tree either.

If it fell, I'd be the first one there with a truck and a chainsaw.

As far as building timber goes, we've all used 2x4's for temporary structures. On the side of my house, there's a small pile that I rummage through when I need one instead of buying a new one. Partly because I'm cheap, but moreso because I realize that a tree was the source of the wood. Most of that timber comes from managed forests, and it is replenished tenfold to meet demand. Think of it as a crop.

Social responsibility should be a part of the hobby. If you are cutting live trees, you should also be replanting them. I want to leave the world a better place, and it's better with trees.

I'd stop turning if I had to kill trees to do it. Luckily, I don't since there no shortage of already downed timber.

YMMV

Steven

Re: Lucky me

#17

Re: Thankfully, this wasn't Dick's attitude.

John K Jordan

>>...since there no shortage of already downed timber.

I passed three downed trees just this morning, being cut up for disposal - large bradford pear, a hard maple, and something else, I couldn't tell. Most city/county/private crews cleaning up trees seem glad for you to haul off logs and pieces since it saves them work.

JKJ

Re: Lucky me

#18

Steven Antonucci

Me too. Either oak or ash from a quick glance...

steve antonucci

>Couldn't have lifted it if I tried. At least 2' in diameter, and nowhere to park.

S

Re: Lucky me

#19

Dick Hines

Re: Me too. Either oak or ash from a quick glance.

Dick Hines

>If it makes everyone feel better I waited for 3 years for a dead white oak tree to fall before I got the burls. It was not an easy wait though. There were 25 burls on that tree. It was in a wild live mangement area and could not be cut down. Once it fell it was fair game. I made the 30 mile trip out of my way about every 2 weeks for three years before the old oak gave and came down. I got all the burls and a friend got all the good wood for his fire place.

I felt sorry for the big oak. It put up such a great fight.

Re: Lucky me

#20

Steven Antonucci

If a white oak fell in three years, you got lucky

steve antonucci

>In my neighborhood (NW NJ), there are a few standing dead White Oaks that are as sound today as the day they died. The hemlocks are all punky, but they've been dead 40 years.

I started cutting the hemlocks because they drop branches everywhere and they've been attracting woodpeckers since they're so buggy. My house is cedar sided, and has a few dozen holes from the birds banging on it.

Now a dead tree with burls on it is another story. It's coming down sooner or later, and you can't kill what's already dead...

Steven