Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

DIY dying *LINK*

Posts

DIY dying *LINK*

#1

DIY dying *LINK*

john lucas

>I know this doesn't apply to many of the folks on this board based on what I read but I'm seeing it in my clubs and classes. Many of the people taking up turning have done little if any mechanical hands on kind of things in their life.

Many new turners don't have any idea how to work a lathe with problems or tune up a bandsaw. Little things like drilling and tapping a hole are new procedures for them. One of my strongest and few memories from my childhood was my neighbor threading a hole in a piece of steel. I thought that was the coolest thing.

I think we should start teaching mechanical skills. How to use clean and store a file, how to tap a hole, etc. Simple machanical skills like how to take a tailstock apart, or shim a headstock for alignment, or simply trouble shooting lathe problems should be discussed at some point.

Those of you who grew up on the farm or grew up working on cars take this for granted but the new generation does not have these skills. Heck I can hardly work on the newer parts of my car but that's a whole nother topic. What do you all think.


http://men.msn.com/articlepm.aspx?cp-documentid=5877371>1=10856

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#2

Re: DIY dying

jared

>You are so right. There are a number of reasons for this and I hve thought about it a lot. I am a farmer, full time and very self supporting. I have built houses, have one in the works now, built cabinets, put in my own plumbing, wiring, etc. I used to enjoy working on cars when I was younger but due to designs that it impossible now. My first car, a handmedown 55 chev[which is still sitting in the grove], you could take teh engine out in a couple of hours with a couple of wrenches and a screwdriver. Try that now. I dont mean to sound like an old fogey, I am only 56, but products these days are made to be used for a while and then thrown away. They are impossible to repari or tune up. My son who is 19 would rather sit and diddle with a computer than try to fix something mechanical. I try to encourage my son who is now in college to help me, learn things, etc but there are so many demands on everyones time, along with the difficulty of trying to repair or work with todays complex household and work machines that it is discouraging for me and him. Part of this could be traced back to fear of liability on everyones part which has some real unintended consequences. Many schools have stopped any sort of shop programs. I had shop starting in the 7tj grade, learned the basics of what was called mechanical drawing and made a few small projects. I still have the first thing I made, a small lamp that looks like an old water pump. It still works and is in use daily at our vacation home. I dont mean to be picking on public schools buy if just a small percentage of students that participate in shop programs would have that real spark of interest and get some encouragement to at least develop their skills on a hobby basis we would all be better off. I live in a rural county in Iowa. There are four school districts in the county and ours is the only one with a vocational ag program. It just doesnt seem right. I know I only see a small portion of the world but I feel these things are pervasive in our society and I dont know what the answers are. Sorry to have taken so much of your time. Jared

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#3

Re: DIY dying

john lucas

>Well you covered it well. I have been totally unable to get my son to work on anything. He is now studying engineering so I thought that if I got a metal lathe he would get excited about learning to build something, Nope, just play on the computer. I do think I'm rubbing off on him a little because he has taken the task of doing some electrical repair around the house and completely took his laptop apart to resolder a jack connection. I guesss that's all we can do is lead by example.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#4

Re: DIY dying

Jeff Rich

>I was lucky enough to have a school that still teaches industrial arts.

I took advantage of these classes with a year of woodworking and a year of metalworking and went on to vocational electronics.

However, I wish I would have taken chemistry.

In my years of professional life I have seen many new or summer employees work at Shoemaker, many of these "kids" have no idea what is a screwdriver or how to use a drill.

IMHO I think at least all students should have a basic understanding of tools.

There is a Star Trek Next Generation episode about the aliens who have all this wonderful technology, but they do not understand how it works or how to repair it.....I hope we do a better job of educating

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#5

Re: DIY dying

Bill Clark

>John, you hit the nail on the head (which few younger people can do today). My father grew up on a farm. He and my grandfather did it all. They repaired and overhauled their tractors and cars. Built equipment they needed and if they didn�t build it they took the new piece of equipment apart and improved it before they put it into service. He turned into a great physician and surgeon. His surgical skills were enhanced by his days on the farm and working with his hands. My fondest memories when I was a boy were when we would work on projects together in the garage and make or repair things. To this day I still have the attitude I gained from him that I can make something better or improve on something new from the store or factory. Unfortunately many of the things we get today are made in such a way they can�t be repaired or are made with planned obsolescence in mind. Still it gives me great satisfaction to repair or make things better when I can. I love to make jigs for my shop. I�m always looking for ways to improve some process. Kids today need those skills. Not only is it useful but it builds TRUE self-esteem. Not just a bumper sticker announcing to the world that �My Kid Was Student Of The Month� just because their name came up in a rotation to be awarded the sticker. It�s scary to think about some future surgeon or dentist working on you that has never learned manual skills when he was a kid. Even kids in college prep courses need some shop time.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#6

Re: DIY dying

Barry Irby

>The confusion is fading. I opened this thread thinking I was going to learn how to color wood myself.

I see this everyday on my home inspections. I suggest to people the would put those missing cover plates on the electrical outlets themselves or tighten the loose screws in the door knobs, and look completely baffled. I have had people call and complain that I failed to explain to them how to pull the cover on their recessed lights down to change the bulbs. I have become reluctant to suggest they make their own repairs.

Another thing I see on inspections is a stunning variety of repairs. I can tell you that some of the contractors out there today are unskilled and untrained. They must not even watch HGTV. I HATE going back to reinspect the repairs I suggested. Most often the work is stunningly bad.

It would be good if the schools would teach some skills not only so that people could do some work for themselves, but also so they would recognise good or bad work when they see it.

I have two sons. One has shop skills and the other does not. Its a joy to try to pass on the skills to the one. I recently visited the other and was stunned by the fact that he did not even own a ruler. (I had made him a night stand and he wanted another. I had built it on the fly and had no plans for it, not even the basic dimensions.)

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#7

Re: DIY dying

Cyril Griesbach

>I've got a friend in the appliance business. We're talking one day and up comes a discussion on audio/visual product quality. He tells me about a VCR he gets in for warranty work. He calls the company and says "I need a door hinge, part #XYZ for this VCR which is under warranty".

They Sez "throw it away and we'll send you a new one for replacement"

Nuf said.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#8

Re: DIY dying

Wayne Kuhn

>IMHO these are the reasons why hands on has gone to the wayside.

Schools afraid of getting sued.

Schools & parents brainwashing studets into thinking a college degree is a must. "You don't want to have to WORK for a living like I did do you?"

Manufacturing going overseas.

I was told in Jr. High/midle school-We are moving from a product driven society to an information driven society.

The computer/internet industry. (not that there is anything wrong with that.) Apparently the teachers in Jr. High were right.

We used to build forts and tree-forts every summer in the woods near our house (suburbia). Now the drugies and pervs prevent kids from going near the woods at all.

Fix it!!?? We'll just buy a new one. With many household products are manufactured, they are impossible to repair.

My Dad Worked for a living as a tool & die maker in a factory. He could fix anything and just about make anything. I have always admired him for his attitude, "don't buy that I can make you one." We still joke about that at family gatherings.

Late in his career, he was very frustrated with the throw it away and buy a new one attitude. "we used to rebuild pumps around here"

I did not go to college in 1977, I went to work in the HVAC industry and learned a ton more about mechanics, physics and the world than I would have learned in college. I feel I will always have a job, and love answering questions from DIYers at parties about what the freon presure should be in thier central AC at home.

I can fix just about anything and do.

However, I hate working on cars, always have. I did work on them in my younger years because I could. I could not afford to have a mechanic work on them for me.

I also have and still do the majority of my home repairs and modifications however I realize my limits.

Sorry to ramble but I think this is a very interesting thread and just had to throw in my 2 cents.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#9

Re: DIY dying

Barry Turner

>This didn't just happen overnight, John. It's all part of a bigger plan. Schools are eliminating shop classes. We aren't meant to "work on" anything anymore. You have to destroy many small appliances to get even them apart. They're intended to be thrown away and replaced with new. Lift your car hood and what do you see? A bunch of hoses, wires and unfamiliar parts. Change the spark plugs? Forget it. You're lucky if you can find one or two of them, let alone get a socket on one. I agree DIY is a dying art, and it's a damned shame.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#10

Re: DIY dying

Barry Turner

>When I was about 15, I bought an old Sears' MoPed from a friend for $15.00. He had blown up the engine, had tried to take it apart to see what the problem was, but gave up. The engine was in a box, along with assorted needle bearings and other parts. First thing, I ordered a manual from Sears. I took the engine upstairs in the room next to my bedroom and disassembled it on my workbench. (I had already had a workbench and some tools for many years.) Well, once I figured out what the problem was (broken ring locked up the engine), I went to Sears and ordered a box full of new parts. When they came in, it was back to the workbench to put the engine back together, individual needle bearings, gaskets and all. A week or so later, I was riding the backroads on my new toy, and continued to do so for many years. I learned a lot of new skills, saved about $300 (price of a new MoPed in those days), made new friends, (the parts guy at Sear's for one), and had a lot of fun to boot. That's hard to beat.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#11

Steven Antonucci

Thought about this a bunch...

steve antonucci

>and I think it's something that doesn't have to be this way!

I grew up in the 80's at the "dawn" of the PC revolution, but I have always had an interest in making things. In retrospect, it was probably due to my grandfather, who made things despite his overall lack of sophistication with tools. His generation was expected to be handy out of pure need.

I have a 9 year old boy who is in the shop with me on weekends and nights. It started out as a way to give my wife a break, and over time evolved into he actually enjoys it and is developing some basic skills. My daughter is 6, and coming along the same way. My twin boys just turned two, and now that they can walk pretty well, they are coming in more and more. I think of it as a long apprenticeship.

My father in law had collected some electronics kits for building basic robots, and even though there are pages of theory around the electrical design, it's the soldering he enjoys! Cutting wires, working with his hands to make something, and seeing the results is exciting.

As our society values the crafts less and less, and moves towards disposable technology, I think it becomes more important for those of us with young people in our lives to pass on the thrill of being mechanically competent. Everyone should know how to use the basics- a hammer, a screwdriver, a saw, and a wrench! How else will you build that first bike on Christmas?

I read the article in John's original post, and it goes off in different directions: the internet, split families, etc. In the end, we (humanity) keep the things that we're interested in as part of our culture, and outsource the things we consider work. I don't work on my truck now because I can't do it better than the dealership can or more cheaply. I don't grow my own food.

I do work with my hands as a hobby because it interests me to be able to recreate 10,000 years of human history and technology. Hammering steel into a knife blade. Turning a bowl. Building a playset for my kids. This stuff isn't for everybody, but anyone can do it...

Steven

Steven

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#12

It's all relative guys...

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>My Grandfather lamented that none of the grandkids knew how to hitch a team, slaughter a hog, or dynamite a stump.

And, my thirteen year-old grandson recently built a computer from online ordered parts...a powerhouse with impressive (if I knew what it all meant) memory, speed, and gaming capabilities.

It's all relative....

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

On the subject of contractors...

steve antonucci

>My neighbor and I were two DIYer's. He was having an extension put on his house, and had hired the local contractor, who didn't know what plumb meant. Unfortunately for my neighbor, he found this out after it was sheetrocked.

When the vanity top came in, the contractor had jammed it in so hard it was 1/4" into the sheetrock. That's what happens when your walls aren't straight. So my neighbor calls me over to "consult".

When I looked in the contractors bucket, there was a bent screwdriver with a busted tip and a handplane that wouldn't cut butter with a blade that looked serrated from the 50 screws he must have hit. It was sticking out so far that the entire throat of the plane was closed, and I'm guessing he never used it and it was merely there for display.

I taught them how to scribe a line, and my neighbor and I cleaned up his mess in no time. He fired the guy and we did the finish work together.

Steven

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#14

Steven Antonucci

Good point... a question for the "old school"?

steve antonucci

>How many "old time DIYer's" that use the internet to get on WoodCentral could build a PC, provision a data center to host it, write the HTML code for the application, or debug the any one of 800 things that could make it unavailable to the masses?

I could do some of those things, but not others, but I could learn any of them...

As a society, we've gotten away from things that can be done by an individual and more towards things that must be done by teams. By not having to do all of these things ourselves, we get more things done.

Steven

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#15

Re: DIY dying

Fred

>These days, a college degree is a MUST if you plan on having your youth compete with the rest of the world!

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#16

Re: DIY dying

John K Jordan

>I think it is difficult to make generalizations. Certainly there are many people who don't know the difference between phillips and slotted screw heads, but there are still a vast number of young people who are interested in how things work and somehow learn how to do things.

I suspect the drop in educational opportunities and the attractiveness of careers in the crafts is somewhat because craftsmanship has lost respect during the "technology" revolution of the last 30 years or so. However, I also think this may turn around as our society slowly learns the need for and the value of quality craftsmanship.

JKJ

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#17

Re: DIY dying..I'm guilty

Stuart Johnson

>My Dad was a welder and during WWII was unable to enlist because he was labeled as a "Master Mechanic" in a shipyard. He could fix anything with just a stern look but none of that rubbed off on me. He tried and tried to teach me or at least spark some interest. I wasn't going to have any of that. He worked long hours and got filthy dirty. That wasn't for me. After I got over my teenage stupids and received my army discharge I decided I wanted to work in an office. I could wear a suite and tie, stay clean and not have to break out in a sweat. It seems like the stupids last a longer than the teenage years.

I did finally come around and realized my Dad had so much to teach me and had spent over half his life trying to get me interest. Only by that time he couldn't any longer.

He has been gone a lot of years now but I'm constantly reminded of how much I threw away. We both lost something that could have been wonderful.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#18

Re: DIY dying..we're All Guilty ! ! !

Barry Turner

>If we aren't going to teach our kids all about this stuff, we'd better send them to the best colleges we can find so that can make lots of money so they can hire someone like your Dad to fix the things they don't have a clue about!

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#19

Re: DIY dying..I'm guilty

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>This thread almost brings a tear. We have all iterated the same feeling about the young people of today. I too am almost all self taught. I have had a few years of college but most of what I learned was a waste as I never use it. I am a good plumber, an electrician and a carpenter. My main income over the years has been in management and self employment as a Landscape Contractor in AZ.

One of my pet peeves is a well educated Engineer or Architect who has no common sense due to a lack of hands on experience.

I was in Wal Mart the other day getting the batteries changed in my truck and I struck up a conversation with the mechanic. He was telling me about one of the newer cars that you have to remove the rear tire to change the battery. Now that is questionable engineering.

I feel all young people need at least one year of mechanical skills.

My Rant

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#20

Re: DIY dying..we're All Guilty ! ! !

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Barry

That sounds all well and good but what happens when all of us old guys are gone ?

We will be a total throw away culture until all the resources are gone and then what. So glad I will not be here when that happens.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#21

Martin Harris

Re: DIY dying

Martin Harris

>Your point is well taken, but "civilization" progresses. I have been re-reading some Greek and Roman history, and the same themes of skills (and attitudes)lost keep coming up there also.

I was interested by the comment about the grandfather who was concerned that the younger generation couldn't handle a team of horses. I wondered about how much opportunity there was to learn when he made the comment.

Since we probably can't change the trend away from the practical in the education system, we should work even harder to introduce young people to woodturning (and other things) as leisure activities. That will involve teaching some math, physics, etc., but that can be fun too.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#22

Re: DIY dying

Bill Crommett

>All is not lost. Many years ago I noticed my young son taking apart an old alarm clock to see what made it used to tick. So I found a defunct sewing machine that gave him many hours of pleasure, but nothing compared with the war surplus Norden Bomb Site with its thousands of cogs and wheels. Later on he actually learned to put something back togather. I will always remember the pride he had when he came home to show me the great new invention he had bought ---- an Osbourne Computer with a great five inch screen. Analysis: Some kids inherit mechanical curiosity and some don't. As an added stem to the complaint about no Industrial arts education, remember that school boards are made up of usually successful businessmen who are in no way capable of evaluating a candidate for an industrial arts program. So the get poor quality of instructors (sometimes) and the program goes down the tube for lack of interest by the students. The best cure for this is an instance of a friend of mine who had to convince the school board members in a small town than an Ag program would keep the kids in school where they could learn some of the other things about life rather than just how to raise pigs and feed cows.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#23

Re: DIY dying

Robert W

>Well. all the stories of stupid contractors being taught by the DIY guys aside...

Stupid happens in any profession.

But the larger issue is something I see every time I go to a client's house. I see it in my brother in law, and I see it in some of my friends. These guys were never exposed to much "hands on work" and don't really even have an idea of whether they like it or not. They have no experience to draw on, so they don't even have a starting place.

We all know the mantra of "I want my kids to have a better life than I did", and of course that's true. But probably a couple of generations (at least) back, having a better life meant not sweating at work, not working in AC, and worst of all, not making a living with your hands.

This whole situation started years ago with teachers saying "well, if you don't learn this you might as well get used to digging ditches for a living" as a threat. Working with one's hands was not a good thing, even if digging a ditch was just a starting point.

Then in the 60s and 70s, working with one's hands became a way to connect with one's simpler self. With no pressure of wearing a tie, worrying about language or butt kissing, it looked like a much simpler and natural way of life. A formal education wasn't required, and a trades/jobsite education wasn't appreciated by the literati. In fact, those working in air conditioning sneered opening at those of us working out in 100 degree days - I know, I was the one in the heat.

I can tell you this, it was a bitter disappointment to my parents when I couldn't afford to stay in college (I was paying for it) and keep my business going. I chose my small contracting company, and they let me know every time they could how dumb they thought that was. They wanted a "better life" for me, when I didn't think theirs was bad at all.

Now the kids are so protected (kids, grandkids, etc. as a cumulative effect) that we don't even really want them to get dirty. How will they learn simple manual skills if they don't get dirty? How will they learn the satisfaction of fixing something on their own if they don't get to try?

It is a shame that hand working skills and are now appreciated by folks in their mid forties and up. In the early 70s when I started in the trades being a "full charge" carpenter was something to aspire to, and the person was someone to look at with admiration. Try selling that one to a 40-50-60 something that has had a financially successful career. My clients are almost all mid to upper middle class, and they are proud of themselves when they oil a lock successfully.

But they can tell you the status of every major college sporting event in the US.

Just my observations, no answers here.

Robert

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#24

Re: DIY dying

Allen Neighbors

>John, I think you're correct in your assumptions. I don't know anyone under 40, with the exception of a few of the firemen, that can do anything mechanical. They need to learn the skills of trying to think things through when they have a problem in the turning area of expertise.

Most of the people that come into my shop see all the tools that I've made, and are astounded. To me, they are so crude, but to them, I'm a genius. One of the guys that comes around all the time, when he comes into the shop yells, "Hey, Mr Wizard!" He can't even install a license plate.

Kids aren't taught enough about the real world... but how do we do such as that? I guess, just give 'em Darrell's URL???

We need some more folks like Darrell Feltmate around. For about 2 years after I began woodturning, his Website was my opening page when I got onto the net.

Re: DIY dying *LINK*

#25

Re: DIY dying

john lucas

>Barry I thought I was the only one who actually owned a moped. I rode the snot out of that thing. My first vehicle besides a bicycle. Well OK the Moped is almost a bicycle but at least it was legal on the streets.