Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Tool position inside the bowl

Posts

Tool position inside the bowl

#1

Tool position inside the bowl

Mike Horner

>Hi and thanks in advance for sharing your expertise. This afternoon, I was hollowing a section of green olive that the north winds blew down on wednesday. It caught and flew from the nova chuck giving me a bruised and raw knuckle.

I was using a long handled scraper after hollowing the bowl quite a bit with a bowl gouge. I don't think that I had the tool scraping at the right level.

Should a scraper meet the wood above the center line or below? How about a bowl gouge - again, above or below the center? does anyone have a reference that discusses where and how to set the tool rest?

thanks from a learner.

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#2

Re: Tool position inside the bowl *LINK*

john lucas

>The important thing about using a scraper is to keep the handle higher than the scraping edge. There are two types of tools or cuts if we really narrow it down. Bevel rubbing and non bevel rubbing.

The scraper is generally a non bevel rubbing cutter. This means that the edge touches the wood without any support. If you have the handle lower than the cutting edge it will try to self feed and you get a good catch.

Gouges and skews are usually bevel rubbing cuts. This means you touch the bevel of the tool on the wood and then lift than handle until the cutting edge starts to cut. If you want a deep cut lift the handle further. The bevel acts as a fulcrum and keeps the tool from self feeding into the wood. You can still get a catch from these tools but it is usually caused by either coming off of the bevel or using an unsupported portion of the cutting edge (like the upper U shaped portion of the bowl gouge while it's supported under the bottom of the U)

Tool rest height and where you cut on the wood is pretty important for either of these methods. Generally speaking you should be cutting at or above the center line to the wood. Most people cut above the center a little. With a scraper on a bowl interior this is really important.

I adjust the tool rest height so that the cut is above the center a little and the handle of the tool is on my hip or wherever you think you have the most control. Because of this tool rest height is a personal thing. If you are tall and your lathe is short your tool rest will be at a slightly different height that someone who is short and uses a tall lathe. A rough guideline is to have the tool rest near the center line of the wood. For a more indepth discussion see the link below.


http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=4508

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#3

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

Barry Irby

>John got it right.

I keep my tool rest set at the same height most of the time. I have a plastic sleeve I made out of a plumbing fitting that I generally leave on the shaft of the tool rest.

I use the bowl gouge nearly level and I have it set up so that I can make a cut that starts at the rim of the bowl and carries right across the center o the bottom.

The reason you want to cut just above center is the geometry of a catch. Think about where your cutting tip goes if you get a catch and it knocks the tip down. If you are cutting above center, there is air below the tip and the catch knocks the tool out of the wood, hopefully rather harmlessly. If you are cutting below center, there is wood below the tip and the cutting edge is driving in to the wood and may bind against the rest, until something gives. (The bowl flies out of the chuck, the tool rest moves, or the tool flies out of your hand.)

So, when I work with a scraper, I move the tool rest up as much as an inch and keep the handle high and the tip down, but the tip still contacts the work at or above center.

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#4

Steven Antonucci

John's answer is good

steve antonucci

>When it comes to cutting the inside of a bowl, I think the best use of a scraped is only light touch-ups. You should be practicing cutting the inside of the bowl on every pass from rim to center. Body position, getting one smooth continuous cut-free from tearout, and cutting angles are all things that don't come on the first bowl.

I only use a scraper for those inevitable little ridges that come from lack of bevel contact. Cleaning them up is done with a freshly honed scraper, and the wisps that come off of it are so thin that they stick to my arms magnetically. I don't recommend using the scraper as a substitute for technique, as it just delays the learning process.

It's hard when your standing at the lathe and you want to get a bowl "done" to delay the immediate satisfaction, but in the long run much better for your development as a woodturner.

2 cents

Steven

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#5

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

georgetroy

>Over the years I have blown more bowls with the scraper than any other tool. As the others has spoken here go by what they say. The scraper must be sharp, you are cutting with the burr. The bigger the scraper the more careful you have to be, there is a lot of surface to watch for. It is important also vital to have that tool rest as close as possible to the area you want to cut. A curved tool rest can reach those areas. I use outriggers bars to resist torque. I will even use Vise grips if necessary. Captive systems can be used safely on open bowls as well as small mouth. Don't try to cut large areas with scrapers they are for ridges and clean up. I like to present my scrapers at an angle for me it is much safer. Notice that the carbide cutters are usually set at an angle to help prevent catches.

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#6

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

John K Jordan

>>Should a scraper meet the wood above the center line or below?

>does anyone have a reference that discusses where and how to set the tool rest?

Mike,

I agree with Barry's comment about tip placement.

Richard Raffan states this in his book "Turning Wood": "Always position scrapers so that in the event of a catch the edge swings into space." For the inside of a bowl this means positioning the cutting edge in the upper quadrant. Too low, small catch, bang: big catch.

Raffan goes on to state: "The golden rule when using square-section scrapers is to keep them flat on the rest. There is a tendency to lift one side, which then gets caught by the wood, bangs down, and usually scars the surface you're trying to smooth." and "For internal scraping [the rest] should be set at center."

He also writes: "Mostly you'll have the tool pitched down a few degrees." I think he says "mostly" since that has more to do with the best performance given the geometry of the scraper edge and less about stability and reducing catches. I often use scrapers internally with the cutting edge raised, especially on a deep hollow where it may be otherwise impossible to access the upper quadrant.

Another wise piece Raffan of advice: to avoid massive catches when working far from the toolrest, minimize the contact length of the edge. perhaps to 1/2" or so. A wide edge can cause a catch larger than you can control. (This is the reason very narrow tips are used in hollowing tools.)

There is more, but I don't want to type the whole book! This book, BTW, is an excellent reference for almost any kind of turning.

JKJ

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#7

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

robo hippy

>I use scrapers a lot on bowls, both for roughing and finish cuts. As far as the 2 types of cuts, I will add 2 more, a scraping cut and a shear cut. both of these can be done with either tool, and the bevel seldom rides on a scraping cut, and some times rides on a shear cut. The difference is the angle of the cutting edge as you present it to the wood. For roughing cuts, always a scraping cut, with the cutting edge flat or 90 degrees to the wood's rotation. For finishing cuts, always a shear cut, with the cutting edge at 45 or so degrees to the wood. A shear cut will put less pressure on the wood than a scraping cut. I am guessing that the scraper caught while you were near the rim of the bowl, and not while it was down inside the bowl. This is common. The reason is that the rim will be thinner, and will start to vibrate when the tool is applied. There just isn't much wood to support the turning pressure, no matter how light of a cut you do. You can use a steady rest which helps, or you can use your hand on the outside of the bowl as a steady rest also. Just enough pressure to support the wood, but not so much that you generate heat. Use only the lightest tool pressure, and use a shear cut. You can also turn down the edge in stages, by turning to finish about an inch at a time, then another inch, until you are at the bottom of the bowl. Some times it is better to sand some more than risk going once more from the rim to the base in one final cut. A friend of mine calls the final cuts with the scraper a 'whisper cut'. You get only the lightest whisps of shavings coming off the tool.

robo hippy

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

#8

Re: Tool position inside the bowl

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I agree with all of the above. Keep the tool very sharp for very light cuts. The scraper at a 45 or so degree for a shear cut. High speed helps to not catch as you will likley make light tool presentation. The rest must be as close as you can get it for leverage on the tool. Personally I never hold the tool by the back end of the tool. I hold right over the tang.

Most of all I consider the tool as a finish cut only to remove the ridges.

Never never try to shear to the outer edge of a finished bowl.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.