Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

Posts

Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#1

Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

matthew fallon

>Good Morning'

i'm trying to do a bit of research on these angle grinder attachments or rotary wheel carving tools,

after checking out the arbortech products i happened across a few other varieties,so am thinking there must be a few more out there i've yet to stumble on .

seems to be 4 varieties ive seen so far. the multi toothed saw blade type,the 2 or 4 teeth carbide wheels similar to a moulder for a table-saw arbor, the spikey wheels that more resemble the burr bits for dremel/foredom high-speed rotary tool,and one wheel which has a tiny loop of chainsaw chain.

I was a bit shocked to not find any threads on them here nor on other turning forums?i know its not specifically a turning tool but imagined it'd be a popular topic for carving turnings.besides this purpose im thinking of getting "it" for shaping and carving in rustic furniture.

any thoughts towards the arbortech mini and pro4 carving accesories?

they seem great,bit pricey possibly,which spurred my interest in finding alternatives. i'm not opposed to buying these though if i can get some feedback as to their quality and durability,they seem like fine tools from what i see in their videos, the turning demos were very inspiring!!!

namaste'

matthew~


google videos of arbortech products

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#2

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

john lucas

>Wow I'm going to have to spend some serious time watching those videos. I use a lot of different tools in my carving and have looked at most of the others. Wish I had the time and money to try them all to be able to do a comparison but I haven't been blessed with the Lottery win yet.

I have the Lancelot chain saw carving wheel that is 4" in diameter. I've gotten a lot of use out of it but if I was buying another one I would get the arbortec. I've learned to get around the lancelot cutters short comings which are it's tendency to want to self feed into the wood. When it does this it's like sticking the nose of the chainsaw into the wood, it runs(quickly and powerfully) and if you aren't anticipating that problem you could easily get cut. I suppose the arbortec might do that also but doesn't happen as easily, at least on the smaller wheel that I have.

To get around this problem i tilt the blade and cut with the blade like a scraping action. This is very controllable and has the advantage of not throwing the sharp shavings right back at your arm. I always use this thing with 2 hands. I find I have much more control and can take off the tiniest shavings. I use the blade guard as a bevel to control the depth of cut. I rotate the blade guard around so that you can rest it on the wood. Then lower the cutter in and make very controlled safe cuts. I don't know if you can do this with all grinders.

I have the arborec 2" cutter on an angle grinder. It cuts so fast and clean it's hard to control by feel. You have to look at the cut. I'm still learning to use this but I think it's a must have tool if you like power carving. It hogs off wood very fast but is controllable enough to take small bites. I used it to rough out most of the heart on my Cardiac lamp.

The Proxxon had my interest and I played with one at the AAW show. When I asked about it on the web too many people had burned one up. some loved them and some hated them so I dediced not to take the chance. I think if you are carving smaller work they would be great. One thing I don't like about the arbortec and lancelot is using them on the angle grinder. They are quite a bit larger than the proxxon and it takes more skill to use it for delicate cuts.

One thing to consider are the Kutzall carbide wheels. The flap wheels that fit the angle grinder and 24 grit sanding discs. These ae much safer to use than the arbortec or lancelot and remove wood almost as fast. What they don't do as well is reach into tighter places so the type of carving you may limit their use.

Another option to consider is an Die grinder with carbide cutters or one of the stone carving tools from www.rotarychisel.com. I know a lot of woodturners use these. I don't own one yet but it's very high on my list. The carbide cutters and rotarychisel cutters will also work in flex shaft machines.

I haven't used any of the www.duragrit.com cutters yet. I feel like they are for finer stock removeal than the ones mentioned above. I have several other methods for doing that kind of work.

If you do smaller work don't overlook the Dremel. With Carbide cutters or Kutzal cutters it will remove a fair amount of wood and let you do quite a bit of experimenting with rotary carving without a lot of money going out the door. You can't take large cuts but I've done an awful lot of carving with mine. In fact if have 2 and will probably buy more as I find them at flea mkts this summer. They are kind of like chucks, you can't have too many.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#3

rotary chisel link

john lucas

>

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#4

don't know what happened'  *LINK*

john lucas

>


http://www.rotarychisel.com/

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#5

JL

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

JL

>I've got the tungsten carbide "donuts" and a Lancelot rotary chain saw attachment for my angle grinder. I use them to carve out seats. I've been lusting after one of Proxxon or equivalents for a while.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#6

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

Donna Banfield

>Matthew, everything that John Lucas tells you is spot on accurate.

As for the Proxxon, I seem to recall reading about these on one of the turning forums a few years back; that they didn't last very long and were being returned at a surprisingly high rate. A friend who worked at Woodcraft at the time confirmed that many of those sold were being returned for a variety of reasons.

I highly recommend the Arbortech tool; the neck extension allows you to reach into places not accessible with many other carving tools. I have an angle grinder with the lancelot teeth (round chainsaw teeth disc), but opted for the entire Arbortech tool, not just the extension piece that can be mounted on most angle grinders. The reason for my decision is that the Arbortech grinder is slightly smaller and lighter than the angle grinder that I have, and fits my more comfortably in my smaller hand. This translates to less fatigue and cramping in my hand and fingers after extended periods of use.

Other tools that Joh mentioned -- die grinders -- are also great, and when used with the Kutzall Burrs are another way to remove large amounts of material. The advantage to the Kutzall burrs is that they don't need sharpening, and if you use them on green or sappy wood, they can be cleaned simply by using a propane torch to burn that gunk off. Be careful not to come near any metal with those teeth, though, because they will break off (the teeth, I mean). Die grinders are relatively inexpensive, but the down side is you'll need a compressor to run it, and they can be noisy.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#7

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

john lucas

>Donna I forgot to mention that you can buy electric dye grinders that work quite well. They are larger than the air version but have a lot of power. If you want to carve flutes and larger details it is a very good alternative. The downside is they only take 1/4" shanks so you need to buy the larger more expensive cutters. The upside is the big cutters take off a lot of material and are quite durable.

You can look at many of these tools in Woodcarvers supply as well as Woodcraft and Highland Hardware.


http://www.woodcarverssupply.com

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#8

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

matthew fallon

>Fantastic stuff John, thanks! just the type of feedback i was hoping for.

i'm going to go ahead with the mini-carver and their carbide wheel,as well as the larger carbide wheel for bigger work.

i actually will need to buy an angle grinder too.

i see them going for anywhere from $15 to over 100,

any preferences out there?

i do want to get up some air tools and a good compressor.

would i be better off with an pneumatic angle-grinder? i have a mini-die grinder,but my small compressor wouldn't run it,ill pickup a 60gallon that does 150-175 psi. those rotarytools looked great.

yes i love the dremels,i use them a Ton in my native-flute making .amazon stocks one called GMC comes in a case with lots of bits,flex shaft,stand etc and only $15,i bought 10 a the time for teaching flute workshops!..the cheap diamond coated bits arent so hot for carving but work ok for signing your pieces(ball-tip)burning designs if you dont have a burner.they etch glass well though..

thanks again'

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#9

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

john lucas

>Matt I bought my first angle grinder from Harbour Freight. I thought if I use it a lot I'll buy a better grinder. Well I use it a lot. In fact it's my favorite grinder. I think I paid $20 for it. Since then I bought 2 more for $15. On lasted a month, the other one burned up the first time I used it, and I do mean burned up with smoke and small flames. For that reason I find it difficult to recommend their grinders even though I still use the $20 a lot.

I've purchased a dewalt and a makita and both are tons quieter and a lot less vibration. I don't like the blade guards on them as much but that's a small thing.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#10

Automach and Foredom *LINK*

John K Jordan

>The Arbortech seems huge and looks difficult to control for filne work compared to a smaller carver. I guess a lot depends on whether you want to carve big things or small things - carousel horses and black bears from logs or cup handles and bowl rims?

I have the Automach HCT-30 reciprocating carver which is about the size of a Dremel. It uses Flexcut chisels and gouges and is capable of incredible detail. The Arbortech gouges are monsters next to these.

For a rotary carver, I prefer one with a small handpiece on a flexible shaft. I have the Foredom and I use a handpiece that's about the size of a fat magic marker. It can be held like a pencil with the same level of control. This thing is FAR easier to control than a rotary tool like a Dremel. The motor hangs from a hook and it came with a variable speed foot pedal. I generally use solid carbide cutters, but the carbide burrs will remove a lot of wood quickly.

BTW, I carved the coffee scoops in the photo with these two carvers. I used the reciprocating carver for most of the handles and much of the outside and primarily used the rotary carver for inside.

JKJ


img

flexcut gouges

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#11

Those are nice scoops John K Jordan!

Donna Banfield

>

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#12

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

charlie belden

>I've got a Foredom flex shaft with full wave rectified foot pedal along with most of the handpieces Foredom made and all sorts of bits, burs, little saw blades and sanding disks (I made jewelry) plus a reciprocating hand piece and Flex Cut type carving chisels for it.

I've also got the small 2" Proxxon with variable speed, the 2" diam 2 carbide toothed wheel, a 2" diam "medium grit" donut shaped wheel and a half dozen 2" sanding disks.

These all work for small carving - the Proxxon with the kutzall and sanding disks are great for spoons and work on smaller wood turnings.

Attached is a picture of a turned lidded box out of pine I played with using the Proxxon and a sanding disk. Tried two different types of spirals - a raised "vein" and "overlaping surfaces". Attached is a shot of that piece - shown about actual size -which I never actually finished - too many other things to try.

I wouldn't want to do any heavy carving with any of these smaller tools, nor use them for hours on end - but the Proxxon is my favorite for smaller pieces.


img

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#13

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

Ralph Watts

>I bought a Proxxon carver about three years ago. Sent it to the factory for repair after about 3 months. Got it back and it broke in about 2 months. The third time I sent it in they said that it was a bearing design problem and that my "new" carver had the new fix. I have used the current carver for about 2 years now (and I use it almost daily, sometimes for long periods of time) and it is running fine. However it does get hot after about 30-40 min of use. Using a arbortech blade in the Proxxon allows me to carve within a 1/16" of my layout.

Stay away from the chainsaw type carvers. They tend to grab the wood and are far more difficult to control and more difficult to sharpen.

The arbortech blades can be sharpened with a diamond hone to extend their life.

regards, Ralph

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#14

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

leppikallio

>I have had that mini Arbortech for some time now and have used it very very much. I suggest that carbide tooth wheel for that also, I think it works better (then again it may be just me). This can be used for very very delicate work or it can hog away huge amounts of wood quickly. Selection and quality of angle grinder is another important thing. You are using this thing much longer periods than angle grinder is "normally" used. So check weight and dimensions. I have had good luck and lots of quality time with Makita angle grinders. Oh and this Mini version is also great for on-lathe-texturing ala Phil Irons.

Recently I bought also that bigger bastard, that "Industrial" blade, with that guard. Man I must say that is Awesome piece of equipment. Again very easy to take away small amounts of wood but if and when you have to it will remove wood faster than you can say "this is fun!". Mostly because of that guard you just can't get kick backs with this one. And amazingly even with that guard it will fit very well to quite small places. And when it can't fit Mini is better choice anyway.

For lighter shaping those Arbortech "Mini-Sanders", sanding disks which go in place of that cutter, are great. As are regular flap disks for angle grinder.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#15

If Ralph uses it you can't go wrong

John K Jordan

>You would agree if you saw some of his work. (He would never admit it, but I think Ralph is one of the most creative and prolific turners/carvers in the southeast!)

JKJ

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#16

rotary chisel question

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>John, I have never heard of these before. They look interesting. i looked at the site and think I might order a couple. Question is, which shapes are the most useful. I was thinking about ordering A and B to start with. Do you think that would be a good way to start?

Thanks

keithz

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#17

Re: rotary chisel question

john lucas

>Keith I'm leaning toward A and B myself. I just talked to a friend who took Al Stirt's class and he uses D. He uses it as a texturing tool. I was looking for a tool that would be both carving and texturing which is why I'm leaning toward A and B.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#18

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools?

john lucas

>Thanks for the insight on that tool Ralph. I certainly handles well and balances better than the angle grinders.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#19

Dremel

John K Jordan

>>In fact if have 2 and will probably buy more as I find them at flea mkts this summer.

Once when I was a kid I watched a model maker working on a huge HO gauge train layout. I was really impressed - he had SEVEN Dremels hanging, presumably to keep from changing bits. Same reason it's difficult to have too many chucks.

JKJ

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#20

I agree John- One of our unsung hero's

john lucas

>

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#21

Keith and John, I have several of those

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>And have recommenced them several times on this forum. Keith this is what you should be using for your spoons, if you are doing enough of them to merit the expense.

I have two of the A profile. The small one is the CT 100, which I use in a Dremel, and the 3/8" one I use in a long neck die-grinder. They really cut nice with easy control.

I also have one of he square bottom, and the V also, but don't use them quite as much.

I would also like to mention that I had wished for a long neck die-grinder for many years before getting one, then shortly after doing so, HF started offering them, for less than the cost of one of these cutters. I thought what the heck, and bought one for about $30. It turned out to be a pretty good tool.

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#22

proxxon etc.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>When I bought the Proxxon, I thought it would get more use than the arbortec, but I didn't like it for that use. I have since converted it strictly for sanding, and it is a super little finishing tool for this.

I took the blade guard off, and used one of the little plastic disk that came with the 2" arbortec cutters. I scuffed the face good with coarse paper, then glued on a piece of felt about 1/16" thick, which I totally saturated it with spray contact. This makes a good backing for the little sticky back sanding disk which I punch out of larger disk for my RO sander.

This takes care of sanding the little details which have been made with all of the other cutters being discussed in this thread,

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#23

Re: Keith and John, I have several of those

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Well, I don't make spoons, but I just ordered a small A and B for use in my dremel. I think I'll check HF and see if I can find that long neck die-grinder you mentioned.

Thanks Keith for the additional info, and Thanks John for bringing these to my attention. I'll have to play with them and see what I can do with them.

keithz

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#24

Re: Those are nice scoops John K Jordan!

John K Jordan

>Thanks. My wife immediately put one made from Pink Flame into use at her coffee pot and the one made from cocobolo went quickly in the Christmas festive family free-for-all fun frenzy.

JKJ

Re: Arbortech / proxxon etc. power carving tools? *LINK*

#25

Re: proxxon etc.

charlie belden

>Keith wrote:

"When I bought the Proxxon, I thought it would get more use than the arbortec, but I didn't like it for that use. I have since converted it strictly for sanding, and it is a super little finishing tool for this."

When you need to grind or sand fine details the Foredom "dental" handpiece. And dentist (as well as their more affluent cousings - dontists") have all kinds of little burs and little abrassive disks - and NEVER throw away any tool. Often they will give you burs and so forth that are either new but "obsolete" or used once or twice and replaced.