>I started another thread about converting the Jet mini lathe motor to a variable speed using one of Vega's treadmill motors from a few year ago.
I was looking for someone who has already done this to have benefit of their hindsight.
The other thread went off into reasons why I want to do this and other conversion kits from I have already acquired. So this post is an attempt to hi-jack my original post back. LOL.
>You will need a power supply and a motor controller. You might look at Surplus Center and maybe send them the question to see if they might have what you need. Good Luck
I was hoping he would pop in and tell his experience with it. I want the perspective from someone who has already done it, to evaluate the pluses and minuses.
>early this year, I bought a complete conversion package from Penn State.
It was about $110.00 complete..It installed easily. It works great...I have never looked back...I'm spoiled.
The only variance from their instructions...they supplied a motor pulley; but, I used the JET motor pulley, on the new VS motor...this gave me a wider range of speeds.
I use this lathe a couple hours daily, about 5 days a week (about 1 year)
But first, this Vega offer was a few years ago and a one-time deal. The links are old and so it it no surprise that they no longer work.
I have accumulate a lot of information over the years. And I am more than willing to share. But like a lot of Internet information, some judicious winnowing is necessary.
As for an inexpensive motor and board, I found the very best deal from the local thrift shop. I bought a treadmill for $5. Since then I acquired another one for the hauling off of it.
What you get is a powerful DC motor that drives the tread. And the motor control board, although it is embedded in much other electronics that are unneeded. So far I have merely disassembled them and stored them for future projects.
You could also go to surpluscenter.com and look at their motor control boards and DC motors. In any event you will need electronic/electric expertise available to you. This is not a plug and play modification.
It is another 'why' in my question of others who may have done the renovation as to their hindsight observations.
So, can I help in some way? Or do you want to wait until others weigh in with regard to whether they would do it again or not? I have the question out on a couple of other forums, but I will share whatever I learn here also.
>Are you asking if having a variable speed is worth having? The answer to that one is - Yes, a variable speed is worth having. Once you have used it, you will never look back and ask this question again.
If you are asking if the variable speed drive is worth the extra cost on a new lathe, the answer is "Yes" because it will never cost less money than buying it ready-to-run from the factory
If you are asking if it is worth the time and cost to upgrade an existing lathe, that depends on on your personal abilities and the time you have available. There are 5 options available. Which you chose will depend on your time available to complete a do-it-yourself project, your skills and tools to complete the project, and how much money you want to spend.
1. You can obtain the Vega motor and controller, or similar options from other sources, buy any electrical components, belt and pulleys; then spend the time putting it all together; and have a variable speed lathe for less than $125.
2. You can purchase the motor and controller from Penn State, and do whatever is necessary to make it fit for about the same $125.
3. You can buy the motor and controller from Jet for $150 (the price may be higher now), swap motors, mount the control box, and be ready to run in a hour. This option may not be available if you have one of the older blue Jets.
4. You can sell the existing Jet-Mini for about $100, and buy a new variable speed lathe for $300 when they are on sale at Woodcraft, and be ready to run as soon as it is out of the box for about $200.
5. Or, you can do nothing, use the lathe you have, change speeds by changing the belt location on step-pulleys, and save the time and money. Changing the belt may seem like a labor intensive operation now, but it gets faster the more you do it.
Which you do is a personal preference based on personal circumstances, and we can't answer those questions for you.
>Now that you have told "the rest of the story" in your latest message, I am left with asking the bigger question - why did you post your original question when you already had all of the answers??
>like the Jet VS, they give you variable speed but no better range of speeds than the plain Jane Jet mini. The Vega package gave from 0 to top speed with no loss of torque at the lower end, just a little lag which I don't mind. I just disassembled mine getting ready for the dreaded move to California. Hope I can get everything back together again, that is I am able to resume turning.
>I heard from 2 people (Don Henthorn and Mark Kauder) who have successfully made the conversion with the Vega motor and board. Both would do it again in a heartbeat. Don added that zero RPM is achievable. There is a feedback loop electronically that provides for the same torque at lower RPM's.
When I finish with it, there will be a paper with all the modifications I could find and verify (from the Internet), along with pictures of my conversion.
Now I need some time to work on it. Lent is a pretty busy time for preachers. But I get to go home for vacation right after Easter and will be able to pick-up the rest of the stuff I need from my shop.
In the mean time, with a little warming up, I might get out into the garage and make a mess. I hope.
>Howdy Carol: I'm just now catching up and decided to respond to your request. As you know, I've done the mod. I wouldn't be without it. The additional torque - all the way from zero to max rpms is worth it. Being able to go all the way down to zero is a real plus for me, as is the forward/reverse capability. The only downside is it's additional weight. Mounted in a box at the headstock end of the lath, the motor and ancillary parts, including wood frame, etc., add several pounds to the original weight. Still managable, just not as light. Another downside is the very poor solder traces on the bottom of the circuit board (I'm talking about the GE circuit board that comes with the Vega system now). I've resoldered every trace on the three systems I've worked with to keep them working. But, they now work just great.
>Thanks, Ed. I had forgotten you had done it. Sorry. But it was good to have other folks chime in with their experience. Added weight seems to be the only reported downside. That isn't an issue with me. I can barely lift the darn thing as it is! And that's with the tailstock and tool rest off!
I'm going to put the motor under the lathe, not out the end. It will all go on wheels when all is said and done. Takes care of the weight issue. :)
I am finishing up the powered scary sharp with the second motor. That's actually what started all this! I built that thing long before I got interested in lathes. When I discovered I needed variable speed and, more importantly, reversibility, I bought the Vega motors. And if one motor was good, two just had to be better! :)