Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

Posts

Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#1

Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

wilbur

>I've been trying to turn a thin walled bowl. As the walls get thinner, I get this horrible screeching sound, whether I use a gouge or a scraper. I'm sure this is due to the wall of the bowl vibrating more as it gets thinner, but is there a way around this? It's highly annoying.

So far I've come up with:

A. 80 grit gouge

2. Ear plugs

III. That's why you should turn bowls with 3/8" thick walls, dolt!

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#2

Re: You must have some serious .....

Jamie Donaldson

>...chatter marks there Wilbur. I also suspect that you are using speeds that are too high, and maybe a less than scary sharp gouge on dry wood. Depending on how thin it is now, your only option might be the 80 grit tool. If it's still 1/4" or more you should be able to make a fresh undercut with a sharp gouge, starting at the rim and working your way down, but if the rim is thin or not supported by a mass of wood below it, time for the sanding to begin.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#3

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screec

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Wilber, turn the outside to the shape you want then start to thin one inch at a time to the final thickness. This way the wood has support.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#4

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screec

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Here are some more suggestions:

- "Scary Sharp" tools. Hone them after grinding them. Very sharp tools produce need less force to cut and produce less vibration.

- Use your hand or fingers on the outside of the bowl to dampen the vibrations. This is easier with a scraper, but also works with a bowl gouge.

- Vary the lathe speed. Sometimes the vibration is less at a faster or slower speed.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#5

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screec

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Like Brian, I use a gloved hand on the outside of thin dishes and a newly sharpened gouge.

It doesn't always work because hand pressure can distort the dish and force it on to the gouge and I have lost 3-4 inches of diameter.

Very much a trial and error scenario!

Regards, Peter.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#6

Clarificatons: screech screech screech screec

wilbur

>I should probably clarify a few things:

First, the screeching starts up when I am working the inside of the bowl, after I've done the outside. Judging from the bowl I did last night, I get the walls down to just less than 3/16" thick when the screeching starts.

Second, the bowls I have been practicing on are cutoffs from a chunk of 8/4 cherry that was kiln dried. I'm not sure how much this affects the screeching issue, as I don't have any problems up until I get to the 3/16" wall thickness part. Am I asking too much of the wood to go thinner?

My lathe is an old Walker-Turner from the 1940's, and according to a catalog from that time, the speed that I'm turning at is 1300 rpm, which is the second slowest speed. The lowest speed is 700 rpm. Less than ideal, I know, but in general is 1300 rpm too fast for bowl turning?

Or are you all trying to get me to buy a new lathe? :@)

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#7

Re: Clarificatons: screech screech screech screec

Ruth Niles

>Wilbur, I turn a lot of kiln-dried cherry that's 8/4, it can be turned to 1/8" thinness if it's not too deep. You don't mention the size (at least I don't think you did) or depth you're going.

I agree with Brian, you have to support the outside of the bowl, use very light whispy cuts either with the scraper or a bowl gouge at 90 degrees. A little screeching is to be expected. The speed is fine if you're comfortable with it. I'd turn a little faster because, for me, the slower speed allows the tool to bounce with the flexing wood, the tool takes the whispy cuts smoother with the higher speed.

If you follow my advice and the bowl flies apart, that only means what works for one doesn't always work for another. It's only wood.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#8

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screec

John K Jordan

>You might dampen vibration by wrapping the outside tightly with tape.

JKJ

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#9

Re: Clarificatons: screech screech screech screec

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I doubt it's the wood. I've turned some pretty thin bowls out of cherry. When the noise starts I get the steady rest out and that helps a lot. The glove thing works also, but it's harder to control the gouge. Unlike some Super-Turners, I only have two hands.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#10

A Combination of Things....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If you're going to turn thin walled bowls there are a few "musts" when you're hollowing. First, even if it's dry wood, rough out the bowl inside and out. If the bowl is under 8 inches dia., 1/2 to 5/8 inch will do. Then completely finish the outside, except for the foot area, including sanding to the final grit. Then do the inside to final size working your way down, an inch or so at a time, so that you're always cutting against heavy wood. The screeching occurs when you turn it thin near the bottom of the bowl, then try to come back to the rim area. The thin wood will vibrate, and you'll get chatter marks.

As you're working your way down the inside of the bowl, shear scrape to get rid of rough areas etc. You can do shear scraping very effectively with your bowl gouge, if it's side ground. Roll the gouge over so that the flute is facing the wood, then with the top cutting edge very near the wood. VERY lightly scrape with the bottom cutting edge. Draw the tool toward the rim. You can support the wood by holding the fingers of your left hand against the wood on the outside, while the left thumb is on the tool. It helps if you mark the lumps etc. with a pencil while the piece is turning. Sounds difficult, but it's not. The danger with this kind of shear scraping is if you let the top cutting edge get too far from the wood, the bottom cutting edge becomes an unsupported cutting edge and it WILL dig in.

If you have a wide round nosed tool, side ground on the left side, that will work very well on the bottom area on the inside of the bowl.

None of this is difficult. My classes in beginning bowl turning do it exactly as I've described while turning their first ever bowl. With some help from me of course.

Wally

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#11

For me, a good bowl steady...

Allen Neighbors

>is a must! I can't stand the idea of having my fingers on the outside of a thin-walled bowl, and a scary-sharp/or dull gouge on the inside. I shake too bad to try that caper. :(

So I have a two-wheel bowl steady that I can add a third wheel to if necessary.

And I spin it at about 1500 rpm or so for the last, very light, passes with my freshly sharpened scraper.

And sometimes I still get some screeches. :)

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#12

Couple of Other Things....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Wilber you've asked a couple of other important questions that I didn't answer.

Cherry is an excellent wood to turn, wet or dry. I would often turn cherry (when I can get it) to a uniform 1/16th in. walls.

You asked about speed. I don't think that you mentioned the size of the bowl that you're turning. If it's under 10 inches, 1200 RPM is a good speed to use. 700 is way too slow. If I was turning a 5 or 6 inch bowl I would use at least 1600 RPM. For under 4 inches, I would go to 2000. At the higher speeds sharp tools cut better and cleaner. For sanding however, slow it down a bit.

Wally

Wally

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Couple of Other Things....

Keith Tompkins

>Wilbur, I say it's the lathe....send it to me, and I'll dispose of it properly :)

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#14

Hearty thanks and coupla follow-on questions

Edro Plainsman in Alabama

>Wally (et al), thanks for your help to Wilbur -- I'm a rookie turner and chronic lurker, and I'm sure many like me will benefit from your experience-proven advice. I realize there are many ways to get from point A to B, but from your post, I'd say I am certainly running the lathe too slowly and not inching my way to the final thickness as you suggest. Turning to uniform 1/16-inch thickness seems like a far reach for me at this point, but perhaps I can gut out 1/8!

May I ask:

1. Do you use a jig for side-grinding bowl gouges?

2. How thin do you teach your beginners to turn their bowls? How much comes off on the final pass (with outside finger support)?

3. Do you simply sand with folded sandpaper, or is it more complex than that?

4. How do you teach your beginners to finish that foot that was left undone when otherwise finishing the outside of the bowl?

Thank you for your patience, your time, and your help.

Kind regards,

Edro

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#15

Thanks!

wilbur

>Thanks for all the tips! I've got a list of things next time I give this a try. I'll be sure to post my results.

Re: Turning a bowl: screech screech screech screech

#16

Re: Hearty thanks and coupla follow-on questions

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I had the second night of a 2 night class in beginning bowl turning last night and I'm a bit pooped. However, everyone went home with a smile on their face and a lovely bowl to show off at home. That's my reward.

I do use a Oneway jig and showing how it's used is the very first thing that we do in a class. We start out with sharp tools.

I'm fascinated with thin walled turnings but I don't try to push it off on students. Most of the beginning bowls (7 or 8 inches) are turned to 3/16 or sometimes 1/8 inch thickness.

Learning how to sand is quite important. Students learn oil sanding on the first grit, they learn to not skip grits, they learn to keep the sp moving, they learn that a few minutes of shear scraping saves a lot time sanding. All of that and more.

The foot area is left for last because it's important to keep heavy wood there until the rest of the bowl is finished, inside and out.

Wally