Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Posts

Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#1

Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Barry Irby

>Edward posted message about mangling a finger over on the main board. Maybe you should go read it as a warning. It got me to thinking about something I do that is bothering me.

When I cut bowl blanks on my Delta 14" Bandsaw with riser block there is a part that scares me. I just try to hack them down to an octagon or whatever. The problem is that when the blank passes the blade, there is sometimes a moment when the blank lunges forward, making the blade appear to pop out of the kerf. I am trying to be careful, controlling the blank and not allowing it to lunge and keeping my hands out of the "line of Fire", but there must be better ways.

Any Suggestions?

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#2

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>No one I stand beside my blade not in front. No two as I move the wood into the blade I put my pinkie and second smallest finger into the guide slot in the table so my hand can not be pulled in.

As with all power tools you must be focused on what you are doing or there will be an accident.

I know this for a fact because last spring I shortened my thumb on a table saw

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#3

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

john lucas

>Barry The bandsaw scares me also. I stand in front of the blade but I keep my hands as far away as possible. One thing I do that I probably shouldn't is I put my left hand behind the blade to help guide the work. I try not to push the work. I feel that if I have to push then the blade isn't doing it's job. When I push the blade as it exits it has a tendency to exit rapidly so I really slow down at this point.

I think as long as we no a problem exists and we are watching for it there is less chance for an injury.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#4

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

wilbur

>I've noticed this too. My guess is that the lunging comes when moving the blank so that the blade moves from cutting mostly cross grain to a ripping cut with the grain. It's always easier to cut with the grain, so the blade goes through the wood more easily.

In any case, keeping your fingers out of the line of fire is key.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#5

Steven Antonucci

I know others have been hurt on a bandsaw, but...

steve antonucci

>I think that it's one of the safer tools in my shop?

Why, you ask?

1.) The only way to get cut it to put you hand into the blade. Seems obvious, but you can only do that if you've got your hand in the cutting line. Don't put your hand in line with the blade.

2.) If you have the blank on a flat surface and the blank has a flat surface, there is a lot of support for the cut. Don't put the round side down! This not only has a fair amount of danger, but a nasty habit of ruining bandsaw blades!

3.) Tune your saw. If the band is dull or the saw is out of tune, you end up pushing through the cut. A sharp band is effortless.

4.) Did I mention to never put your hand in line with the bandsaw blade? Someone could kick the door open to your shop and you could hit a weakspot and drop the wood and you still can't get cut if you aren't moving your fingers towards the sharp spinning thingy...

No kickback, no line of fire, no 6" blade spinning at 3000 rpm -

Steven

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#6

Re:Barry- this sounds like you need.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...a new or sharp blade. The exit cut should be little different from the actual cutting pressure as you GENTLY push the wood forward thru the cut. I was often overloading my old Delta with blank preparation, and solved the problem with a MiniMax S45 to let the saw do the hard work!

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#7

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I don't use the bandsaw for blanks. In my view, these small band saws are not designed for cutting thick wet wood.

Instead I use my chain saw to size up a blank. Much safer for me.

In addition, I start most of my pieces between centers so that I can adjust the orientation; round blanks from the saw, while helping to balance the wieght, tend to inhibit changing the center axis. For bowls, I half the bolt leaving the pith line in the piece. The pith helps me center the grain in the bowl and then gets trimmed off later.

If I were to use the band saw, I would use a circle-cutting band saw jig so that all I'd have to do is rotate the wood into the blade with the jig hold the piece stable.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#8

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Barry Irby

>I used to use a circle cutting jig and it worked fairly well. Then I started using a different brand of blades and the jig does not work well for circles. Sort of a Hmm?

I now most often use an electric chainsaw. I like it better than the bandsaw, but I need to set up some sort of blank holder. Thinking of drilling a hole through the tip of the bar and making a pivot for it so I can use the Chainsaw like a chop saw. (Sort of half joking, but there is a thought hiding in there somewhere.)

I still resort the the bandsaw once in a while. I think the blade is part of the problem. I should be using a narrower blade with maybe 3TPI. And it should be sharper.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#9

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Don Orr

>My junior high school shop teacher Mr. Grubel (great guy !) did a simple demonstration in the shop on the bandsaw that I still remember clearly to this day, about 35 years later. He took a simple piece of 3/4 " pine and slid it very quickly into and out of the blade as it was running. It left a cut about 1.5" deep in an instant !! I never got to use the bandsaw in class but I remember that lesson. I try to keep my hands out of the blade line as well, sometimes moving to the side of the blade to steer the piece through. I also use push sticks and whatever it takes to keep my hands and fingers away from the blade.

Some people think some tools are less dangerous than others. I disagree-ALL tools can be dangerous. One of my worst tool related injuries was from a simple slotted-screw driver that slipped out of the screw and ended up embedded in my palm. Hurt like mad and bled like crazy. Fortunately no permanent damage other than my pride. There was a good article on a forum (don't remember which one) that has become my new mantra. I now say to myself when I pick up a sharp tool or go near a power tool "Where will it go if it slips ?" I think it helps me a lot to keep from doing something stupid or being careless.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#10

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Craig Daymon

>I don't think I should be offering advice as I am still healing from my encounter with the cabinet scraper inside the bowl.

On the issue of using a circle cutting jig, I think the problem with such jigs for cutting blanks is the irregularity of the blanks. Those jigs are made to set a fixed radius and then rotate. Problem with a blank is how to get to that initial starting point, which must be equal to the intended radius from the rotation pin. I've recently had some thoughts on this. If the jig permits setting a "stop" at the desired radius and allows the blank to be slid up to that point, toward the blade, one could nibble away at a small starting point until reaching the stop. At that point, the blank can be rotated completely to the desired size about the pin.

The nibbling part is very safe as your hands should be farthest from the blade when doing so. Rotating about the pin, once you are up to the stop should be safer as well since you don't need to get near the blade to generate the rotational force.

-Craig

P.S. Hand therapy is going well, though the doc says my right hand has definitely displayed masochistic tendencies. As I am right handed, the left hand also insists that the right hand has a god complex. I don't recall Senior Wences having these issues.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#11

Barry, You didn't say what blade you have been

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>using. This could have some effect.

I normally use a 1/2" blade with 2 - 3 tpi, and have never noticed what you are describing.

If the blade is not tensioned enough, maybe unloading the bow in the blade could be causing this.

I usually try to have a scrap of 1/4" mdf or something to help it slide on the bed easier.

Since a lot of turning stock is irregular shape, I have a concentric stack of circles up to about 36" which I cut out of a sheet of 1/2" mdf that I can set on top of the blank with a couple of screws to pin it in place. This helps to guide me to a fairly round blank even if the sides are low or high relative to the finished circle. It sure speeds and improved my roughing out.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#12

Accident already happened.

Ed Karch

>Just like you described 3 years ago. 16" kerf out of two knuckles right hand cut nerves and tendons. A year with hand surgery and therapy. Now have arthritis in two knuckles and right hand really hurts when cold. Use a sharp blade, dont push, and keep body parts out of the line of cut.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#13

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Suggestions:

1) Use a SHARP blade,

2) Use a SKIP-TOOTH blade (hook-tooth blades can be too aggressive),

3) Make sure the bottom surface of the blank is FLAT, and

4) Use a CIRCLE-CUTTING JIG.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#14

Re: Accident already happened.

Ed Karch

>make that 1/16" a 16" curf is lawnmower sized.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#15

Re: Barry, You didn't say what blade you have been

Barry Irby

>I am using a 1/2" 3TPI hooked tooth blade. I think the "dullness" factor may have crept up on me.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Accident already happened.

Dick Hines

>When i am cutting bolw blanks on the band saw I guide with my right hand and use a stick with a small finishing nail in the end to guide from the left. I had rather loose a blade than a finger.

This is something my grangfather tought me. He worked in a saw mill for 40 years and got out with all his fingers and toes. This was way before OSHA was ever thought of. I thnik he kenw a little about safety.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#17

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

gbalock

>I agree whole heartedky. The CS works much better than the Band saw.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Barry, A couple of pointers that may help. First plan your cuts.I try to make my exit cut on a cross-cut, as there is less energy expended than while ripping. When cutting the blank, there is a transition from cross- cut to ripping cut. This is the most dangerous cut, especially if the blade is dull, and the cut is near the edge of the blank. At this point, the blade can exit the cut in the blank, and the blank moves toward the blade with no resistance...this is where most accidents happen. Like John, I put my left hand behind the blade at this point; if I slip, there is almost no chance of running a hand into the saw blade.

I personally don't like circle cutting setups on bowl blanks, especially thick ones....if the blade doesn't track properly, a bow develops while cutting....binding the blade, and resulting in a dangerous situation.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#19

That's what's happening.

wilbur

>"...it should be sharper."

Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes.

A dull blade can definitely cause "the lunge".

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#20

Keep That Blade Guard Down!

Barry Turner

>Keeping the blade guard as low as possible reduces the amount of exposed blade and increases safety. The blade guard just just clear the wood.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#21

Re: Barry, You didn't say what blade you have been

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>Barry, I just got a new order of blades from my supplier, and it seems that the salesman didn't bother to look at my past orders, and chose to send me a bunch of rip type blades, which I don't need since I have a woodmizer for any re-sawing that I need to do.

These blades really cut too aggressive on when cutting across the grain. The hook will virtually pull the blade forward of the guides and thrust bearings. It may not be as bad on thicker work because the gullet would fill, and hold it back, until it started out of the cut.

I like a coarse tooth, but with no hook for cutting out turning blanks.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#22

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Justin Fields

>I'm a newbie to this, but I'm having a problem visualizing what precisely is going on. The few times I've cut blanks on the bandsaw, I don't see how I could get my fingers too close to the blade to have any minor sudden shift put me in danger.

From my (horrible) picture, my hands are the chicken-looking things. The bandsaw table is the filled blue square. The rough chunk of wood to be sawn is the green polygon, with the intended circlular shape in purple. The downward view shows the bandsaw cover as a rectangle with the red line representing the actual blade.

Standing on the side, with the circle marked on the wood. I start as shown, then go straight in until I hit the top of the circle and then gradually rotate the wood through the blade, with my hands at 3 and 6 o'cloock. As I turn a little bit, I reposition my hands back to the same place. They are never in line with the blade.

I'm not discounting anything anyone else has said with regard to issues such as blade sharpness, blade type or the importance of having the blank flat on the table. I'm just trying to understand the relative orientation of the person, their hands, the blank and the blade.

Thanks.

Justin


img

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#23

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Barry Irby

>I posted this to learn something and maybe make a point for others.

I have to admit that part of what I might be doing wrong is that I stand at about the 9 o'clock position and my hands are often at the 6 and 10 positions. So As I spiral the blank into the blade the left hand is in danger. I think part of my problem is that I am short. At 5' 7", if I put a tall irregular blank on the bandsaw table, I have trouble seeing over it to keep and eye on the blade. I need to look into trying this and seeing if it would not work better for me.

I have wondered why we have table saws with tables as big as aircraft carriers that sit so low some people raise them, but bandsaws with tiny little tables that look like helicopter landing pas on top of a building.

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

#24

Re: Help with Accident waiting to Happen?

Don Orr

>That's a great diagram Justin and a very safe way to round out a blank. I think more of us should do it that way. I have been trying to teach myself to change to that position but am having a hard time breaking old habits. Good for you.

I think most of us stand at the 9 o'clock position relative to your diagram and push straight into the blade, which, as you can imagine, could be a major problem if the blank suddenly lurches forward toward the blade.