Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Posts

Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#1

Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Peter Hyde

>I took this blank to a shop get together on Saturday and Mike Brazeau did a coring demo on it. See link http://www.canadianwoodworking.com/forum/showthread.php?t=20371

During the coring the red started to appear and in places showed like red ink spots. I brought the 2 rough bowls home and finished roughing them out ready for drying. As you can see the red is very pronounced. Everyone who has seen the wood has identified it as ash but no-one has seen this red in ash before.

So what do you think?


img

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#2

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Dale Stansbery

>That grain looks more like a member of the maple family to me, or possibly box elder which would explain the red.

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#3

Steven Antonucci

I've seen it before

steve antonucci

>If the wood was very wet and freshly cut, it's possible to see shades of red/pink. Fades very quickly in the ash I've had. Expect a creamy yellow, brown heartwood.

Steven

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#4

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Mike Brazeau

>Dale - this is definitely an ash. The grain is not at all similar to Box Elder or Manitoba Maple as it is commonly known here.

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#5

I've seen it before - me, too

nailshooter

>>If the wood was very wet and freshly cut, it's possible to see shades of >red/pink. Fades very quickly in the ash I've had.

Exactly my experience, and I turn a lot of ash. In fact. some of the very green ash I have turned will turn pink and red all across the fresh cut face. I have sealed it immediately will all manner of sealers, but it fades out to "ash color" no matter what I do.

Robert

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#6

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Sean Troy

>I've seen older growth ash look like that also. Ash is a fun wood to turn and lots can be done with it.On another note, the jaws on the chuck are extended way to for out. You loose most of the holding power when they are out like that. The strongest chuck support is when the jaws are closest to being closed.

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#7

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before? *LINK*

Rick Allen

>The woodturning club I belong to had the opportunity to turn some White Ash which was planted by George Washington. The wood was somewhat green when we turned it.

We found red staining on many of the pieces that were turned. I talked it over with a few of the other turners and we decided that the red came from bruising the wood.

I had some of the ash left over. So when I got home I decided to test that theory. Sure enough as I turned the wood I could generate red easily by being aggressive. If I reworked the red areas with a freshly sharpened tool and used a light touch no red appeared.

The red you are experiencing might be caused by something completely different.


George Washington Ash Project

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#8

Re: Oneway Talon has patented jaws

Peter Hyde

>The jaws are in a wave shape so they grip equally no matter how wide they are opened, but thanks for your concern.

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#9

Right, Rick, it's from the tree trying ....

Allen Neighbors

>to protect, or repair, itself. There was some great posts on WC not long ago in reference to the red in Box Elder, and what caused it.

What I understood about it was that the tree sends something (chemical?) to the area of harm, to try to take care of itself, and that something either turns red, or is red, itself.

I've also seen the same thing in a fresh cut Ash tree.

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

#10

Re: Ash? Red Ash? Anyone seen this before?

Ed Larson

>Mu buddy in NW Washington sent me some wet just cut alder. When it is first turned it is bright white. After sitting in a bag with shavings for 2-3 days it is bright orange just line your bowl. After returning the wood is light pink. To late to take a picture tonight and lucky me I'm going to a Jimmy Clews demo all day tomorrow in Sacramento so a picture will have to wait until Thurdsay. Let me know if you would like a picture.

Ed