Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Your best guess

Posts

Your best guess

#1

Your best guess

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>How many times can you sharpen a tool during it's useful life or say one inch of flute length. I do understand no one keeps track or even cares but give it a try.

One day I'll measure a tool length, sharpen with a jig then measure again to find out how much steel is used.

Re: Your best guess

#2

Bill Blasic

Re: Your best guess

Bill Blasic

>Doug,

I think that you would have to include time between sharpenings into the equation. I sharpen your tools less often than I would my conventional tools therefore the Thompson tools would last longer. Unfortunately it isn't going to work that way because I basically only use the Thompson tools now and the others don't get used so they will last longer. But I'm a happy camper!

Re: Your best guess

#3

Re: Your best guess

john lucas

>Doug I sharpen a lot. Early in my turning career I sharpened by hand and used up a gouge in about 5 years. I now remove less metal when sharpening by hand because my skills have improved and when sharpening with a jig I remove very little. I remove so little I don't even know for sure how I would measure it.

I also have several gouges now so I don't sharpen any of them as often, however I reach for your tools an awful lot. In fact I just spent a long weekend turning and used nothing but your skew, detail gouge and a $2.50 cent parting tool I bought at the flea mkt. By the way I only sharpened the skew 1 time in 34 wine stoppers. I did sharpen the detail gouge twice but some of these were very hard wood.

I'll try to figure out how to measure the tool and then use it for a month an see what I come up with.

Re: Your best guess

#4

Steven Antonucci

Better question: how many wheels do you use...

steve antonucci

>before your tool is gone? I've replaced the wheel on my Tormek when it got below 7.5", but I probably have sharpened the gouges a couple of hundred times each including shaping. I believe the first wheel lasted 5 years, several hundred bowls and hollowforms and well over 1000 uses.

How many lick to get to the center of a Tootsie Roll Pop? The world may never know...

Steven

Re: Your best guess

#5

Re: Your best guess

Barry Irby

>Doug, I don't have any of your tools, yet. (Sniff!) But when I grow up, I plan on getting some.

I have an Ellsworth gouge I bought at Arrowmont 8 years ago, while I was taking a class from David Ellsworth. You have raised an interesting question. I wish now I had measured the tool when I bought it. I doubt that I have ground away more than an inch of it and I really would like to know. I use the Jig that I got with it to sharpen and I sharpen very lightly. My joke is that I just put the shine back on it and clean the crud off. I am a hobby turner and turn in bursts, but this is my go to tool and when I am turning, it get the lions share of the use.

I went with the club and did some demo's for a local group. The club carried a grinder and the set up on it was different than mine. Though the changes in the shape were subtle, they made a dramatic difference in the "feel" of the tool. I suspect that day of turning cost me more metal than a month in my shop.

Re: Your best guess

#6

Re: Your best guess

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I would guess > 50 < 100. I usually start with a cratex wheel shaped like the flute, which will polish the dull pitting on the inside. Then if it only needs a little, I can give it a light touch on a fine diamond wheel about 4 times before grinding the whole bevel again.

I am just guessing though, I would like to hear what you think.

Re: Your best guess

#7

Re: Your best guess

John K Jordan

>Good question.

I haven't measured, but I think it depends on your sharpening means. I've seen people who have worn their tools down to a nub sharpening by hand.

I use a Tormek and with the jig set properly it removes so little metal I think I could use the tool for my lifetime than pass it on to the next generations. (I hone with a ultra fine diamond paddle between Tormek sharpenings.)

JKJ

Re: Your best guess

#8

My First Bowl Gouge....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>In about 1982 or 1983 I acquired my first bowl gouge after seeing Dale Nish use one. I had never seen one before and neither had anyone else in the audience. They had just started to market them in this country a short time before. I still have that gouge although is has long ago been sharpened down to a 1 inch flute, and replaced by several others.

It's a Sorby 1/2 inch gouge and it was discarded long before I used a jig for sharpening. The handle is 11 1/2 inches long. That's the way they were made in those days. They came ground straight across like a roughing gouge, and that's the way everyone used them at first. Later the fingernail grind came into use, and later yet the side grind.

I have no idea how often that gouge was sharpened, but I do know that if a jig had been available and used it would have lasted a lot longer.

Wally

Re: Your best guess

#9

Re: My First Bowl Gouge....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I shoulld mention that seeing Dale turn that bowl with a gouge was an eye popping experience for all in the the audience. He was turning a wet blank and those long shavings curling off the wood was beautiful to watch. We had never seen that before.

Dale Passed out Craft Supply catalogs, his company that had just started up. Most of us ordered our first gouges right there. I wish that I had kept that old CS catalog. It wasn't very large. There wasn't much available to the woodturner then.

Wally

Re: Your best guess

#10

5-13/16"

Ron in Drums PA

>That's how long my 3/8" Sorby gouge is after five years of continued use.

Re: Your best guess

#11

Re: Your best guess

Bill Noce - Jefferson, Ohio

>Doug that's hard to figure because the most lost is when you first sharpen to get the grind you want and then when you decide that you don't like that grind. I do know I have gone through about two Sorby 3/8 spindle gouges and one sorby mini 1/4" spindle gouge since I started turning in 1995. I did lose about a 1" on my PM Crown 5/8" bowl gouge because it was factory grind and I wanted the Ellsworth grind but I saved lots of money buy the normal grind at the time. Now that I got your gouges the others will only get used if It has a special grind that I need. Also there's those gouges you just had to have an they are still in the package... :):)

Re: Your best guess

#12

Re: Your best guess

Allen Neighbors

>Doug, I don't think I ever take off as much as a 64th of an inch when I sharpen. But if that amount was taken off each time, you could sharpen 64 times per inch of toolshaft. Sometimes I turn for 5 or 6 hours a day and may do that 3 or 4 days per week, and it may be two or three days between trips to the grinder. If all these 'guesstimates' were fact, it would well be over a year per inch of useable tool length. Does that make sense to you?

Re: Your best guess

#13

This was a surprise...

Doug Thompson

>My guess before this post was 1 inch per year using a jig or 200 to 300 times during the useful life of a tool. To see that many do last almost forever depending how they are ground was the biggest surprise.

Back when I had time and any piece of wood found was turned gave a tool life of one year. I do grind freehand and change the grind depending on the day but one 3/8 and 1/2 was replaced in a Glaser handle every year. (Note to self... Learn how to grind one day)

Thanks, learned something new today.

Re: Your best guess

#14

Wally

Doug Thompson

>This goes to show how much woodturning has change in the past 25 years and where will it be 25 years from now. I couldn't even imagine...

Re: Your best guess

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Your best guess

Keith Tompkins

>HI Doug....I bought my favorite bowl gouge 8 years ago from Packard woodworks...M2 5/8" conventional grind. It is one inch shorter than my new "spare". I cannot begin to know how many pieces I have turned on it. BTW....I want to contact you with a custom tool request!

Re: Your best guess

#16

500 grinds per inch of tool is my guess

Jake Niedling

>My guess is .002" per grind, so 100 grinds would be .2", so 500 grinds would be 1". I am assuming a wolverine grinding jig and a light touch.

Re: Your best guess

#17

Re: Your best guess

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Keith, write out or draw the basic idea, in a few weeks to a month I'll have time to work on it.

I've been working on a couple designs and have a new one in this batch. The half round scraper works very well but I don't have time work with it to find the right nose angle but it looks like 10 -15 degrees.

Re: Your best guess

#18

My gouges

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Doug,

I have been using some new gouges from some guy in Ohio, I can't remember his name right now. Don or Doug or something. But every night when I stop turning I put these gouges in the rack. Then when I take them out the next day the are a 1/64" longer. I can't explain it, it must be the tool elves at work. :)

Dave

Re: Your best guess

#19

LOL Dave

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>