>I have always turned mesquite green to finished but I have always turned bowls. I have a piece of mesquite large enough to turn two plates about 10 1/2" in diameter. The blank would start out about 5/4".
Is wet mesquite as stable when turned into plates as it is when turned into bowls?
>I've not turned green/wet mesquite, but have turned a lot of platters and plates, both green and twice turned.
My experience has been that even twice turned (roughed, let it dry, turn it a second time) I have discovered some warpage after I finish turned what I thought was a dry roughed out plate or platter. Of course, in a twice turned piece, I don't want that. I've had better luck i.e., little or no warpage when the blank was quartersawn from the log.
If you planned to turn the green mesquite to finish in a single turning, then you're probably looking for it to warp? Or was your question more along the lines of -- will it crack horribly?
>Actually I would be surprised if the mesquite cracked as it is a very stable wood. For bowls it is often more stable than many of the dry eastern woods. I usually would not turn a platter or plate from green wood. I use air dried(at least 5 years). Since Mesquite is so stable I would consider turning a plate from green however I wanted to check with those who turn mesquite to see what to expect.
>Barbara, mesquite is the most stable wood in North America. However, it will move a little if turned wet, especially in a platter.
Around here, mesquite is often free. I sometimes get some at a place that sells firewood. There is a mesquite mill nearby that cuts lumber and slabs for furniture. They let it air dry with almost no warping. They make beautiful doors and cabinets from mesquite.
If you let finished mesquite stay out in the sun for at least a day it turns quite red. Very attractive.
I have turned quite a few flatwork pieces like plates and platters from green mesquite. I have not had any crack provided you keep a couple of things in mind. Stay as far away from the center as you can and also check close for shake. Most of the mesquite will contain some shake. I think you called it something else but it is the sepperation of the annular rings. I hope this helps.
>>...mesquite is the most stable wood in North America.
The total shrinkage of mesquite is small compared to most US hardwoods which does make it stable in one sense. However, the potential warping due to the difference between the tangential and radial shrinkage is what makes things go out of round or warp. I've also found mesquite to be relatively stable, especially if it's fairly dry while turning, but I've had things warp nicely as well.
I looked up the numbers: honey mesquite only shrinks shrinks 3.2% tangentially going from green to 0% MC (oven dry). (Compare this to oak at around 10%, over three times as as much!) All numbers are much less, of course, at higher MCs.
However, the T/R shrinkage ratio for honey mesquite is around 2.0 when dried to 0% MC. This is not much different from some other common US hardwoods, for example at 0% (oven dry), T/R ratios:
Red Oak - 2.1
Holly - 2.1
Dogwood - 1.6
Cherry - 1.9
Sugar Maple - 2.1
Walnut - 1.4
This, combined with the percent shrinkage values for both T and R will tell you how much it can go out of round. However, based on the low absolute shrinkage numbers, the amount of warpage in mesquite while turning will be less severe and after it reaches EMC, the ongoing movement from seasonal humidity changes should be far less.
>Barbara, it is as stable in a plate as it is in a bowl. However, if I was going to turn the plate down to, say, about 1/4" finished thickness, I would first turn the inside third of the tenon down to 1/4", leaving enough thickness around the outside of the tenon for strength. Then I would turn the plate down to about 3/8 thickness throughout, and let it sit for a couple of days just to be safe, and then make the final cuts to bring it down to 1/4". Hollowing the tenon to finished thickness beforehand insures that the piece won't warp too much, or crack, while it's sitting there for that couple of days.
I have a bandsaw box that I made to hold some professional dominoes about 10 years ago. I made the box the day after I cut the live tree. It's still exactly the same shape it was the day I made it, and the lid still has the suction fit.
I think what we call "ring shake" is what (I can't remember his name) was talking about.
>It will warp some. Not a lot but if you are going to use it as a plate a little is a little to much. I would rgh it, let it set to finish dry and then finish it. A rgh plate will dry quite quickly.