Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Square Bowl, Square Foot

Posts

Square Bowl, Square Foot

#1

Square Bowl, Square Foot

Bruce Forrest

>This bowl is ash, about 10 1/2 by 13 inches and the most striking feature is probably not the foot, but the bark on the far side. The non-bark edges were left rough in keeping with the overall theme.

Comments welcome. (And, yes, the foot is a separate piece, glued on.)


img

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#2

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

Mick

>intriguing minimilist bowl/platter???

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#3

mixed review

GaryG in MD

>Bruce,

I love "simple" forms that emphasize the purity of the wood and its natural origin. The bowl part of this is beautiful -- outstanding, period.

But, frankly, I'm not so sure about the foot. I do like Asian-style feet if they are well integrated (as opposed to those often-vocal members who automatically dislike them), but in this case, I think the foot detracts from the piece because it seems unnatural and draws attention away from the bowl. It appears that the bowl has enough curve to get by without one, or with only a subtle 1/16" - 1/8" circle or square to lift it up just a tad more off the table.

I'll bet it wasn't easy to keep the bark on those edges. Great job.

...Gary

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#4

Re: mixed review

john lucas

>I have to agree with Gary. I love the upper surface and the natural edge but it really seems like the square foot competes. At least in the photo. It might not in person. I think I know why you did it. You have a square bowl why not a square foot. I probably would have done the same thing. could you carve or texture the square foot to sort of resemble the bark edge.

Good job on the turning it's a really nice piece. The foot detail is a small thing that only we turners fuss about.

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#5

Re: mixed review

Bruce Forrest

>I purposely took a fairly low angle on the photo to show the foot. On a more conventional shot, the foot wouldn't be visible at all. Placed in a "normal" position on a coffee table or sofa table, the foot is not all that noticeable (it's only about 3/4 inch high). But the square foot gives people a surprise when they pick it up and inevitably turn it over.

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#6

Re: mixed review

Mick

>Grumble, grumble....it's unique...it's different..It was not easy to do...I like the foot...

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#7

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

gtwilkins

>Very well done Bruce, I have tried many times to keep the bark edge attached unsuccessfully. Never thought about gluing the foot on, I always turned it and then cut it square and carved the rest of the bottom.

I have also done square platters with a square foot but turned the foot on the bias so the corners of the foot are pointing to the midpoint of the plater's side.

Trevor

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#8

Re: mixed review

John K Jordan

>Bruce,

I like the idea of the square foot. I'm wondering what it would look like with a strongly contrasting wood, say one made from ebony or bloodwood. That might make a stronger surprise!

JKJ

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

#9

Re: Square Bowl, Square Foot

Mark in B'ham, AL

>I would have been tempted to glue on a slice of a limb with the bark on. But, then again, I could never have made the bowl in the first place :-)

Nice work.