Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Posts

Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#1

Bill Blasic

Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Bill Blasic

>There have been discussions about the quality of the Nova Chucks coming from China. That being the case I wanted to know for myself what it was going to be. I got one from the first shipment sent, randomly picked and have checked it out pretty thoroughly. These are my findings to follow. When in Cleveland last Saturday for the monthly meeting of the North Coast Woodturners I stopped at Woodcraft and picked up a 1 1/4 X 8 Pinnacle adapter (these fit the Nova chucks) as I knew I would need an insert.

The chuck arrived and upon opening the box it looked just like the box from a NZ Super Nova2 chuck. I was looking for a made in China sticker which was added to the box and read Designed by Teknatoll International - Manufactured by Teknatool International PRC. I assume that is Peoples Republic of China. Other than that I did not find any markings on the chuck itself that specifically says Made in China. As a matter of fact the dust shield on the back still says made in New Zealand. You will notice in the picture that the the Chinese version (picture on the left) has deeper lines machined toward the face where as the New Zealand version has lighter lines towards the bottom and other than the bigger radius on the face of the NZ chuck and the wording on the the locking mechanism says IN on the Chinese and LOCK on the NZ version there are no other visual differences.

Upon opening and closing the slides I found no difference between the two chucks, both operated very smoothly. I put the Pinnacle adapter on the Chinese and mounted it on the lathe. With a dial bore gauge I checked run out on the OD which was .003, I checked runout on the face and it was .002. I then put on the NZ chuck with the Nova insert and checked the same places - .003 and .002. I then switched the adapters and made the same check again. Both were identical to the first reading .003 and .002. I then tried the same thing with my old Super Nova and a G3, same readings! I was mildly surprised to find them all so very close.

The fit and finish of the Chinese version is very nice and I'll keep an eye on it to see how it wears in use. My NZ Super Nova 2 has a little pitting so we'll see how the other does over time. If there is anything someone would like checked out let me know. It shows to me at the moment that the Chinese version is at least as good as the NZ version and with time might even be a hair better, we'll see. Hope this helps, at the moment it at least tells me they are trying. Yes I too wish that everything that used to be made here and other places were still made here and other places, that's a sad fact that I can't do much about.


img

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#2

Steven Antonucci

Interesting...I didn't know

steve antonucci

>Not that it matters (unless you're worried about lead poisoning from their factories :-O )

I just went to see which version I got for Christmas, and lo and behold, I have the Chinese version too.

I have to say that my initial impressions are overall very positive too. I think it's a huge improvement over the older Super Nova, which mine is now dedicated to holding my Cole jaws. I think it's a great value, and I might just pick up another one.

Steven

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#3

Age of chuck

Steven Kubien

>Hey Bill,

My SN2 is about 8 or 9 months old. It came with the Nova 1624 which I bought off someone who had for less and 3 months. It looks IDENTICAL to the Chinese made one you picture on the left. Same deep grooves on the body, same "IN" stamping vs the "LOCK" stamping on the Kiwi version. This raises a question...How long ago did Teknatool switch manufacturing locations? I had thought this was a recent move (3 months or so from what I have heard). Curious.

The bottom line is my chuck performs just as it should. I really like and wouldn't hesitate to get another. It seems to me the fears (quality control) which were brought up by some people on a number of forums were unfounded.

Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

P.S. So, did I get an earlier version of the Chinese made chuck or a very late model NZ chuck?

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#4

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

john lucas

>bill They look just like my vicmarc and the chinese copy of the vicmaarc that I have. do you know if the jaws will interchange with vicmarc. I have one of the older Nova tommy bar chucks and the jaws won't interchange between it and the Nova.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#5

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Gordon Seto

>I have to dig up my receipts to check on the dates. I have two SN2, one of which is at least or close to couple years old. Both have the 3 rings on top of the chuck body. I like them so much that I bought another last Christmas. They all look like the Chinese version.

Gordon

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#6

Bill, now I am thinking...

Steven Kubien

>...and wondering how old your older chuck is? Didn't Teknatools do a redesign of the original Super Nova and call it Super Nova 2? Is it possible you've got an older chuck (on the right)?

Just wondering.

Steve Kubien

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#7

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Fog Tanner

>I think the real test will be time. I have used Japanese model airplane engines of over 30 years. They are some of the best finished on the planet, real mechanical master pieces. But, the metal alloys used leave a lot to be desired. I have had to replace pistons and connecting rods with ones made from the correct materials. Over time they would not stand up to a lot of use, but they still looked good on the outside. After replacing all the wear parts they were nice little engines.

I also will never buy anymore Japanese or Chinese stainless steel cap screws for the same reason. I had too many round the head out when I tried using them more than once.

And there is now a problem in some of the chrome molly tubing being brought in from China. The fuel cars in drag racing have been having frame failures related to the quality of the steel tubing, forcing them to revamp the specs.

I think it would be interesting to hear how your chuck is doing in a year or two of use. That would show how good the Chinese branch of Technatool is doing in their quality control.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#8

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Eric in Los Gatos

>Based on my experience would never buy anything made in the PRC where the quality of metal matter. Have been burned every time I tried. Machining and workmanship don't seem to be issues but material is a killer.

On a different note I hope the TTool and hold their prices by manufacturing in the PRC to offset the weaker US$.

Happy spinning.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#9

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Interesting information Bill. Thanks for doing the leg work for the rest of us.

Jen

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#10

John, it's my understanding...

Allen Neighbors

>that the jaws on all Nova chucks are interchangeable except for the Compac chuck, and the Titan Powergrip Jaws. I have a Compac, two SuperNova2s and a Titan. The 50mm, 47mm Spigot, 25mm, and 100mm SN2 jaws will all fit on the Titan, but not on the Compac. The Compac's Jaw Slides are engineered differently than the SN2 slides.

The Titan PowerGrip Jaws are three hole, and are larger than the SN2s slide capacity, so they won't fit the SN2s.

I may be wrong, but I think the SN2 jaws will also fit on the old Super Nova and the Midi.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#11

Re: John, it's my understanding...

Gordon Seto

>Allen,

You are correct. All the jaws are interchangeable between Midi, G3, original SN, SN2 and Titan except the 3 holes per jaw Titan Power Grip.

Gordon

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#12

Hey Bill

TheMoun tainMan

>I read all of the respones to your thread - did you tell where you bought the ChiComm unit - and what did you have to give for it???

Regards

The MountainMan

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#13

Re: Hey Bill

don lewonczyk

>Off the subject of the chuck but still regarding made in China for Teknatol there is a lot to be desired in the quality of their OT mill.If I had a chance to put my hands on it and crank the slides and look it over good I don't think I would have bought it. It just isn't precision made. They couldn't even drill a center hole in the end of the screw for the cross slide so every revolation it binds. I don't have time right now to get deep into this right now but if you want to know what I think email me. Yes it will do the job it's intended for and many people will be happy with it but I am particular when you pay $500 for a tool. I think they rushed it to get it out and it could have been better designed. Anything to cut corners. DonL

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#14

Re: Interesting...I didn't know

Chet Bisno

>What's the price? I have the basic Pinacle chuck (tommy bars) and find it excellent. Incorporating the benefits of a Super Nova are attractive.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#15

Bill Blasic

Re: Hey Bill

Bill Blasic

>As Gordon e-mailed me yesterday and told me that his SN2's all looked like the Chinese version (one of which is two years old), My SN2 (the one on the right) is somewhere over 3 years old. I have no other reference than the one I have and did not realize that they obviously were changed sometime after I got my SN2. I have sent an e-mail to Teknatool asking the question - When did they start making the chucks in China as I was told that this was the first shipment of chucks from China.

Regardless of this issue the chuck is as good as my first SN2 and as I said we'll see how the metal holds up down the road.

Oh yes, the Ornamental Turning Unit! As mentioned above there seems to have been some quality problems with this equipment. Gordon has issues with his and I sent my first one back as it needed a repair that I felt I shouldn't have to make. The second one I got is fine and works as advertised. This was the main reason for all the above as folks had heard that the Chucks were crap and I had been told the quality was better than NZ and upon getting the OT with the quality issues and I wasn't going to make comments about something I hadn't seen, that is when I asked to purchase one of these out of the "first shipment". Let's face it if a company in this day and age does not pay attention to quality they are not going to be in business long. This chuck has satisfied my curiosity for now but that by no way means that everything they make in China is fine, as always Buyer Beware!

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#16

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

John Peck

>A SuperNova2 that I purchased in April 2006 fits your description of a Chinese-made SN2 - deep groves on the body and the word "in" engraved on the locking mechanism. So maybe Chinese-made SN2's have been around for a while. I also have a Titan purchased in 2006 that has "in" engraved on the locking mechanism, leading me to wonder whether it was made in China, too. It wobbles - and I've tried several different Nova inserts (1-1/4 x 8 tpi) and can't eliminate the wobble entirely (the amount of wobble varies with the insert). I've since purchased Vicmarc chucks, think they're great, and would never go back to Nova chucks.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#17

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Gordon Seto

>"Learn" something new every day. My Titan has 3 rings on the bottom but there is no engraving on the locking mechanism. All of my Nova chucks (from Midi, G3, SN, SN2 and Titan) run silky smooth. I don't notice any run out or wobble. I like them because their jaws are interchangeable (except the Powergrip for Titan).

Gordon

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#18

Made in China? I'll buy it!

Scott in Montana

>After thirty years in the audio/video industry, let me tell you, when you're buying a new piece of consumer electronics, you want it to say made in China on it. Never thought in a million years I would say that!!! Currently, industry wide, the mainline electronic products from the P.R.C. have the lowest failure rates that we have ever seen. American products might have been the benchmark, but they never had this low of failure rate. It is simply amazing.

Today, I'm thinking that if you get a cheaply constructed product from China, it's because whoever specified the product, only paid for a cheaply constructed product. Blame the company who puts their name on the product, not the country of manufacture.

Not looking to start any kind of heated debate, just thought it interesting what a turn around I've seen in our industry.

Scott

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#19

Re: Made in China? I'll buy it!

Barry Irby

>When I was a kid (half a century ago) Made In Japan meant "the cheapest possible junk". Not any more. I am thinking that the Chinese will rise to the occasion even faster.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#20

Finally, the way it really is.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I have to echo those words. If the controls are in place it will come out of P.R.C. working right out of the box. If testing and material costs are scrimped on to gain a better profit margin point, then quality will suffer. Once a process is locked down, adhered to, and controlled their manufacturing is very good.

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#21

Re: Made in China? I'll buy it!

John K Jordan

>>...when you're buying a new piece of consumer

>electronics, you want it to say made in China

If you followed the industry over the last 10 years or so, you probably know a couple of interesting things about electronics from China. When US chipmakers shut down plants due to price slashing, the Chinese bought the equipment which accelerated their industry. Four or five years ago I read there were about 500 semiconductor design centers in China and they were rapidly overtaking the US. I understand that laws in China helped a great deal - it was legal to reverse-engineer chips made by Intel and others and reproduce them for sale and the Chinese became the best in the world at this. I saw details once where chips were machined down layer by layer and photographed to analyze the design. I haven't kept up with this over the last few years but since reverse-engineering is one of the best ways to take an unbiased look at a design and figure out how to make it better and cheaper, I'm not surprised to see the Chinese have gotten very good at electronics. There are questions about whether advancement by reverse-engineering is ethical, but no question that it works.

JKJ

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#22

Re: Made in China? I'll buy it!

Scott in Montana

>You're right John. I read many of the same articles a few years back and when I read your comment I thought to myself, "nowadays, what is the usable lifespan of any given chip or circuit?" Today, I'm not sure you could reverse engineer, tool up, and market a chip fast enough to stay current and competitive.

Just my thought. Fascinating stuff to think about.

Scott

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#23

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Wilford Bickel

>My Supernova has the rings on the bottom as the unit on the right.

My first Supernova 2 that I have had over 2 years, maybe close to 3 yrs. has the rings like the one on the left (your Chinese) with "Lock" and an arrow on the gear drive.

My second Supernova 3 that I bought late last year also has the rings on the top and the word "In" on the gear drive. This one had been in the local Woodcraft store a while as the packing grease had hardened and I had to soak the whole chuck in Mineral Spirits when I got it home. The box and chuck both show made in New Zealand. It appears that the new Chinese production is the same as the production from New Zealand last year.

Bill, Does the Chinese chuck have numbered jaws? I was told by Tim Geist or Teknatool Customer Service a while back (can't remember which one but will try to find the email) that the jaws would be cut by a different machine in China and would not need numbered.

Working with exported chemicals, I am shocked that USA customs has let these in with Made in New Zealand on the chuck itself. I would not be surprised if Teknatool gets fined or has shipments refused if a customs inspector opens the box and finds this is not marked properly for where it is made.

Wilford

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

#24

Re: Chinese version Super Nova Chuck

Wilford Bickel

>Wish this had an edit - should be Supernova 2 not 3 on the 3rd description.