Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OT: Photography rant

Posts

OT: Photography rant

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Photography rant

steve antonucci

>I'm certain that a lot of people here are "guilty" of this, but I have a pet peeve about people who think they are UPGRADING their digital cameras by buying ones with higher megapixels! My wife is one of those people, and we now own 4 digital cameras, and she still doesn't know how to take a decent snapshot.

Rant time.

Megapixels are a measurement of resolving power of the camera, which is only really useful when you are enlarging to a "big print". Most commercial prints come back at 4x6, which is a throw back to 35 mm negative. The paper and the equipment used to print matters much more than the amount of data in the image, since if the paper can't handle the resolution, it doesn't matter how many megapixels there are. Think of it as an HD signal on an old B&W 12" TV...

Lots of people are under the impression that more is inherently better. At magnification and to a discerning eye, that is certainly true, but how much so? I have a snapshot of Yosemite Falls in my living room that I had enlarged to 20"x30". It was taken with a $99 Kodak 3.0MP camera, and there is no obvious loss of quality at that magnification.

I laugh when I hear about "upgrading the camera". Most folks need to point and shoot, and almost anything will do. In fact, there's probably nothing wrong with their current cameras, other than the fact that people believe that "better" cameras will take better pictures and make them better photographers. No camera in the world is capable of taking a good picture with a bad photographer.

Just like we need to learn our craft standing at the lathe, a camera is an instrument, a tool. Without training, it is useless. The good news is that huge improvements can be had with very little effort- sometimes less than a day or one good book on photography. I highly recommend this as the next upgrade to most people.

Rant off.

Steve

P.S. Did you ever notice that most website pictures are 20K? Ellis only lets us push 80K up. Think about it.

P.P.S. Anyone want to buy a good 3.0MP camera? A 5.0MP? a 6.0MP? Wife still doesn't get it...

Re: OT: Photography rant

#2

Re: OT: Photography rant

Bill Howatt

>You are correct. Most people set the camera to Auto and push the button.

The other thing is that the higher mega-pixel sensors introduce noise into the picture so you may have more resolution but you have more noise as well.

Probably the best way to buy a camera for most is to market how clever the Auto setting is rather than the resolution. :)

Bill

Re: OT: Photography rant

#3

Well that may be true but

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>How are you suppose to use all of that extra space in the new computer is you only take small resolution photos? You just don't understand the logic.

Now, while I agree with most of what you just wrote. I think that the cameras are getting better at analyzing the light, and metering for the situation without the user needing to know how to make the appropriate settings to compensate. I know that this can be corrected in the computer later, but why bother if the camera can do it first and faster. Mine seems to know when it is inside or out, or even florescent. I know how to make and use all of the correction, but find it nice that the camera can do it faster than I can make the changes.

Also my present camera has face recognition. This is no big deal, unless the shooter doesn't understand what aperture setting to use when those assorted faces are not on the same focal plane. The newer software in these camera are capable of turning more rookies into better photographers.

Then there is the argument to being able to crop more deeply after the image is in the computer to get better composition without getting grainy resolution.

I hope your wife doesn't find out how you feel about her photographs. ;-)

Re: OT: Photography rant

#4

Re: Well that may be true but

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Steve is correct for the point and shoot folks. Steve you do have more knowledge than the average about photography so you are not in the P&S group. You obviously compose and consider what you are doing.

Bill in CG, AZ

Re: OT: Photography rant

#5

Steven Antonucci

A sharp photo isn't necessarily a good one

steve antonucci

>Undoubtedly, a good camera will meter better and take a sharper picture, but not necessarily a better one.

Case in point. Some of the best pictures I've ever taken were shot with a Rolleiflex TLR. More than the technical stuff about getting the exposure correct and processing the image, a good photo is based upon so many more "artistic" things-

How long is the exposure? More light leads to better color saturation.

Handheld? too long leads to blurring.

Composition. What is the subject and how do you frame it?

Message- what emotion or feeling are you trying to convey? Good photos have this quality.

As much as I agree that better software makes it easier to take pictures without exposure issues, I think they also make it hard to become a good photographer because you don't need to understand what it takes to take a good picture. DOF, aperture, shutter speed all become masked by electronics.

It's like standing at the lathe and not knowing the difference between a gouge and a scraper...

Steven

Re: OT: Photography rant

#6

Re: A sharp photo isn't necessarily a good one

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Gee Steve I thought a gouge was a round scraper! :)

Re: OT: Photography rant

#7

Re: A sharp photo isn't necessarily a good one

Bill Crommett

>Steve: You make some good points, but how can we get face recognition, shake resolution, Macro-tele-zoom without getting a bunch of unneeded pixels ? I have been wanting to replace my old Canon D460 for a couple of years, but I shiver at the thought of going through 30 pages of technobabel in order to take pictures of my turnings and the bugs that feast on my garden.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#8

Steven Antonucci

I'm not saying that there aren't reasons to buy

steve antonucci

>newer cameras.

But harken back to the film days, when all of the same issues were still present? Did people upgrade the camera then or spend more time learning photography?

I've gone from being a photographer to a slightly better than average snapshooter most days. For me, the freedom of not being tied to processing costs and the instant gratification has transformed the way I shoot. I take far more "bad pictures" today simply because they don't cost me anything. In an effort to get a good picture, I am perfectly willing to hit the shutter button 5-6 times, simply because I can ignore the bad pictures or delete them if I fill the card.

But my background in photography also means that I'm getting a lot more good pictures as well. Being able to see what will be captured, and instantly reshoot if there is an issue means I'm not missing the shot, although I might have to make 5-6 exposures to get it.

It just frustrates me to no end that people equate more pixels with better... bad is bad, no matter how many pixels you have!

S

Re: OT: Photography rant

#9

Re: I'm not saying that there aren't reasons to bu

Jim Rutten

>Hi Steve,

You mentioned people would be better served by reading a book on photography than by upgrading their camera. Are there any that you would suggest (please keep in mind that most of my discretionary funds go into woodturning). Thanks.

Jim

Re: OT: Photography rant

#10

Re: OT: Photography rant

Tony - Memphis

>Yeah, it is pretty funny. My first digital was a Canon Elph 2.0 Mp and it took (still takes) some great pictures. I can print 8x10 and it looks great. I haven't tried anything larger. My next Camera was a Nikon D70. Really nice camera- far more capable than I am, but its "only" six Mp. I can't tell you how many people have bought the latest snapshot camera that is 6+ Mp and assumed theirs is better than mine! And the funny thing is, most folks rarely print anything. It all goes out in email. MArketing is a powerful thing.

I've got some pics I took with the Canon Elph (2MP) and printed on a cheap HP inkjet that look pretty amazing. But if you ask someone "who knows," they'll tell you that can't be done with that equipment. Ha!

Tony

Re: OT: Photography rant

#11

Steven Antonucci

There are too many to mention

steve antonucci

>I have a shelf full of them. Much like my woodturning books, I began with "How-to" books, and then moved to "Advanced How-to" books. Nowadays, I find almost all of the books are photoessays that talk more about mood and subject matter than film type and exposure.

The first book I learned the basics from was An Ansel Adams Guide: Basic Techniques of Photography by John Schafer. A lot of it is probably no longer relative, but the concepts are there.

The simplest thing anyone can do to get better is to go out with a camera and shoot. I don't mean bring it with you in case, but go out for the express purpose of taking pictures. Subject doesn't matter. I used to walk the streets on NYC, hike with my Hasselblad (all 11 lbs), and shoot weddings in an editorial style (no posed shots). With digital, it's so easy because you can delete the folder if you want...

Steven

Re: OT: Photography rant

#12

Re: I'm not saying that there aren't reasons to bu

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Steve

Here is a perfect example of what you speak.

This is a piece that I have in a gallery in Las Vegas. My Daughter took the picture with a Cannon 10 MP XTi. It has anti shake an all but a bad picture is still bad. the second pic is with the same camera.

Bill in CG


img

Re: OT: Photography rant

#13

Re: OT: Photography rant

Raymond Overman in SC

>Yeah, but that doesn't make me stop drooling over the new Nikon D3s instead of my old D50 which are opposite ends of a wide spectrum. With a full frame sensor, nine shots a second, and 12MP, it's a beast of a camera.

I think the key is, does she need the extra pixels, does she need the speed, does the newer camera have better glass, does it have a more advanced focusing system for those candid shots, and is she willing to learn to use the extra features?

My D50 isn't only used for shooting pictures for the web. My wife uses it with her newspaper photography and we use it for shots of the children around the house. It's nice to be able to have different lenses for different situations and I'm slowly learning what can be done with all of the settings. It's nice to have the extra there when you want it.

Of course, I understand the feeling of consumerism problem too. It's frustrating that companies almost build in obsolescence while advertising their latest toys, especially among electronics. I'm still holding out until I have to for buying that big screen.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#14

Steven Antonucci

Nothing personal, but they're both "bad"

steve antonucci

>The one on the right has obvious technical problems. Slow shutter speed, without the flash firing caused the blur.

The one on the left is so cluttered it's difficult to make out the form. The background details detract from the piece.

I think most people's barrier to better pictures is the second one, not the first. If there had been a slight correction of the angle the picture was taken and the DOF was limited to arounf the piece, the second photo would have been much better, but that's what happens when you let the camera make decisions for you.

Steven

Re: OT: Photography rant

#15

Steven Antonucci

Two dead TV's this year and a cell phone later

steve antonucci

>That's part of the issue. We're being condition to replace electronics because "we need to". All of my cameras still work very well, despite being dropped and dragged up the side of a mountain.

I used to oogle the digital Hasselblad, but quickly came to realize that I don't need it. Even if I won the lottery, I could never use the capabilities of that camera. I am happy with what I have and when I reach the point where IT limits ME, it will be time to upgrade.

s

Re: OT: Photography rant

#16

Re: OT: Photography rant

Justin Fields

>Steve,

I agree with a lot of what you are saying, but I also understand that it just doesn't matter.

Yes, you're right that people upgrade for upgrading's sake, rather than because of need. I just replaced an 8 year old digital camera, because it had been dropped one too many times and had damage to the lense. (Small kids at home). So I went from a 3 MP to 10. Not because I need the resolution, but because the overall package I wanted happened to have it at a reasonable price.

The camera I got works great for my needs, as well as those of my wife. It can easily fit into a pocket/purse and get taken places. In our case, simply having it with us is the first obstacle to overcome. Neither of us want to carry a camera bag around. It has the features I could want, but the ease of use that even allow my 5 year old to take pictures in auto-everything mode.

I'm not at the point I am through lack of experience with more sophisticated photography. My parents have had a darkroom in the house for more than 25 years. I went through the military's photojournalism course and spent two years as a full-time photojournalist, doing all my own camera and darkroom work. I know what it is to use and appreciate quality photographic equipment.

Most people don't get farther in their research for a camera than the first online review or the first 5 minutes of the big-box chain store salesman's pitch. They inevitably buy more than they need. Part of it is unwillingness to put in the time to be educated. Part of it is our culture's rampant consumerism and desire to one-up the neighbors. While your facts are totally straight, I've given up fighting and prostelytizing. If a close friend asks my opinion, I'll give it, but otherwise, it is not my problem. This saves me headaches and time, which I can put to better use.

Justin

Re: OT: Photography rant

#17

Re: OT: Photography rant - long

don at central illinois

>I have to agree. There is more to photography than pixels. If that criteria had been around earlier, then the better film you bought, the better pictures you would take. Same concept, more pixels would equal better film. As a professional photography, I went from a Fuji 3.1 megapixel to at 12+ megapixel, but only because the older one was causing problems. But then, we are printing 11X14 and sending out for up to 30X40 for final prints. It's like, if I buy better golf clubs I can golf like Tiger. Yeah, right.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#18

Enough already. How bad do you

Gary Smyth

>want to move them? Cripes I'm using two Nikon F's, 2 FTn's, one F-1 with motor, one Nikkormat, a Minolta with bellows and a slew of lenses. I also guard my Omega 45, which I might keep over all the others, and an old MP-3 Polaroid copy stand. I'll(try to)never get rid of them (except the MP-3). I still think photography is a silver medium, but it isn't "green". For learning, the best photography series ever made for the public was the Time-Life 17 volume set (plus annuals) that was put out in the 1970's. That said, how much for your digital camera(s)? I'm working with a 1.3mp Sony now to record all my tools and stuff on discs for placement in a off site safe deposit box, but I want a macro something for details like trademarks and better optical enlarging. Finally, I fully understand what your rant was about but don't put down the megapixels entirely. When they get enough to blend to old Polariod molecular level then they can quit. I'll worry about the presentation medium later. I always hated grain. Always.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#19

Re: OT: Photography rant

john lucas

>Well I've been busy shooting with my (the school's) 12 MEG camera all day. Although I will agree that most people don't need more megs, here at work I do. We stacked 3 10 meg camera's together to shoot 500 people for a poster. We had a roughly 24 meg file when done and it was adequate but we were losing sharpness on peoples faces when you looked close.

Another reason for more megs is still the same as film. On a standard sized photo you simply have a smoother transition from shadow to highlight on skin tones and more internal contrast. It's a subtle thing but is the reason I started shooting 8x10 along with my 4x5.

All of this of course depends on everything you use along the line. The printer, the size of print, the type of ink etc. On my printer at home 1 meg is way too much and more quality than it will ever produce.

Now for viewing on a monitor I doubt 12 megs will make a difference.

What I find disturbing in all of this is our willingness to put up with cameras that only last 2 or 3 years. I have had a bunch of people come into our office to see if we could repair their cameras. Of course we couldn't but these cameras are no more than a few years old. My first real camera was a Mercury 2 half frame that my dad bought in Crete during WWII. It still works, as did all of my Nikons before i sold them, some were almost 30 years old.

Steve and other have covered this topic, but it's not the quality of the image it's everything about the image that makes it great. Timing, light quality, subject matter, and composition are much more important than anything else. Of course if you can put it all together like Ansel Adams them you get to be king of the hill.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#20

Steven Antonucci

I cried the day Ektar 25 came off the market.

steve antonucci

>I also loved the Kodak B&W 3200 (might have only been 1600?)

I was at Newark Airport at 5AM dropping off my in-laws for their trip to Alaska and shot without a flash. It was like having night vision, but alas, big grain...

Steven

Re: OT: Photography rant

#21

Dick Hines

Re: OT: Photography rant

Dick Hines

>I still have my onl SLR Ricoh I bought in 1970. It still works great. It is begenning hard to get film anymore though. It has the old Pentex thread on the body which was change for a different thread some time ago. I lost the lens and flash in the divorec and had to buy am addaper and new lens.

Even the Ricoh works great I like being able to take pictures and be able to put them on the computer to see what I need to change instead of waiting for days for the pictures to come back.

With the digtal cameras ther is not need to shoot up 5 rolls of film to get one good shot. As much as I hate technogloy a digital camera has it all over the old LSR's.

As my mother used to say "to each his own"

Re: OT: Photography rant

#22

Re: OT: Photography Rant

Barry Turner

>My first serious camera was a Minolta SRT-102 with 28mm, 55mm and 135mm Minolta Rokkor lenses. It still works as well as the day I bought it over 25 years ago. I have no doubt that it will outlast my 3-year-old Olympus digital camera. That digital is nice, though.

Re: OT: Photography rant

#23

OK Steve, I have heard enough.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I have had other friends that seem to have gone through this before. I am going to predict that your next camera will be a pin-hole. There is a gallery waiting for the results of this new adventure. Go for it man, you can do it. Ha K

Re: OT: Photography rant

#24

Steven Antonucci

I've already made two pinhole cameras

steve antonucci

>At one point, I bought a huge bellows to make my own view camera. I was aiming for a 12x 20" landscape camera until I priced film in that size.

I still have it in the box, and the front and rear standards of the view camera sitting next to it.

My pinhole camera was a 4x5 with a wide angle. It took some of the weirdest pictures I've ever seen (DOF from 0 to infinity). It's laying around here too somewhere.

Steve

Re: OT: Photography rant

#25

Ellis Walentine

New camera considerations

Ellis Walentine

>I just bought my first new camera in four years, Steve, upgrading from a 4mp Olympus to a new 12mp Canon G9. The difference in resolution is startling when you first see it on your monitor. For inkjet printing, there probably isn't enough difference to matter.

But, I've found there are other considerations besides higher resolution, at least in my case. For one thing, there's zoom range. I prefer a long optical zoom. Most cameras come with a 3X zoom that is the equivalent of about 45-135 or so (IIRC). My old camera came with a 10X zoom, which was great for shooting pics of birds high in trees and other subjects that are farther away. My new camera only zooms to 6X but the additional resolution means I can crop heavily and still get a sharp image.

Related to the zoom issue is the image stabilization feature found on many new-generation P&S cameras. It helps you to get sharper images at lower shutter speeds and at longer focal lengths, where exposure time and camera movement are issues. That means you get a higher percentage of usable images -- a definite advantage.

Size, shape, bulk and weight are all factors, too. As much as I like my Olympus Camedia, the price you pay for 10X zoom is a lens barrel that sticks out about an inch and a half from the front of the camera. It is a pain to stow it in a fanny pack or a briefcase. My new camera body is a half inch thinner and the lens retracts completely when the camera is turned off. It's still doesn't fit into as small a shirt pocket as my wife's Elph does, but it's good enough for me. The mass factor is the only reason I didn't spring for a DSLR. I'm an SLR fan for all the right reasons, but I just don't do enough serious photography these days to justify the size, weight and expense of a DSLR.

Other improvements I'm appreciating are face recognition, multiple autofocus modes, faster startup, shorter lag time on exposures, better navigation controls and the size and quality of the LCD screen. My new camera has a high-resolution, 3" screen that is positively awesome compared to the smaller screen on my Olympus. You can really see what you're shooting. I still use the optical viewfinder outside on sunny days, but that's actually a better shooting practice anyway.

So, resolution isn't the only reason to upgrade. I can attest to that.

Ellis