Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Posts

Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#1

Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Scott in Montana

>Hello,

I am very new to the world of bowl turning, but look forward to getting started. I recently purchased a barely used Vega model 24, 24" bowl lathe. Now it isn't the big model 27, but I figured it was a good place to start and the price was right.

My question is this... Rockler is having a 20% off on one item sale until the tenth of this month. The catch is that the sale doesn't apply to items already on sale. The Oneway Talon is on sale for $179.99 so it doesn't qualify for the sale. They also have the Oneway Stronghold chuck for $269.99, which after the 20% discount is priced around $218. Oneway recommends this chuck for lathes larger than 16". Now my lathe is a 24", but not as heavy duty as the majority of large lathes. Is this a good choice for my lathe or is the Talon a better choice?

Maybe neither of these is a good choice?

Thanks in advance for your input.

Scott

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#2

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

john lucas

>Scott I don't own any chucks bigger than the talon and have turned bowls up to 20". However I think chucks are kind of like lathes. You can turn small stuff on a big chuck but you can turn bigger stuff on a big chuck safer. I wouldn't use the Oneway on my mini lathes. For that I would go with the Talon.

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Scott, the Stronghold sounds like a great deal....you really can't go wrong. The Stronghold is a top-of-the-line chuck, and will serve you well for years.

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#4

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Steve in NC

>Scott

I have had a Talon for several years and like it alot. When I upgraded to my 3520B I purchased a Stronghold. I thoght I would use both chucks but find I always use the Stronghold when turning bowls. (I leave the Talon on my mini). The stronghold is larger and heavier and provides more grip especially when roughing out of balance blanks. Given the size of you lathe I would recommend the Stronghold.

Be aware that you need the threaded adapter for your lathe and you will likely want the get one larger and one smaller jaw sets.

Enjoy your lathe

Steve

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#5

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Steve Worcester

>You can't go wrong, good chuck, bullet proof. I own 5 of them, just so I don't have to stop and change jaws.

Steve Worcester

www.turningwood.com

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#6

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

George Van

>Scott, I have to go with the Stronghold also. I had them when I used my 3520 and did not think thet were too big. As others have said they are good for out of round and out of balance pieces.They also hold small items ;-)

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#7

Re: Oneway Stronghold chuck, the right choice?

Barry Turner

>Oneway's are very fine chucks. If there is a downside at all, the Stronghold weighs in at eight (8) pounds, more than twice the weight of the Talon. That could get tiresome if you change chucks a lot.

With that said, I don't own either of the chucks you are speaking of. I have a Super Nova and a Super Nova II. I have found both to be quite satisfactory for my style of turning, although I prefer the Super Nova II because of it's improved chuck key. I considered getting a Oneway chuck when I bought my Stubby, but I already had the Super Nova and several sets of jaws. They wouldn't have fit the Oneway, so I just bought another Nova.

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#8

Thanks to all for your input. Scott

Scott in Montana

>

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#9

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Scott, I use both a Talon and a Stronghold on my Vega bowl lathe. I also use a PSI Barracuda 4 on it as well. The Stronghold is a good choice if you want to stick with one chuck for the time being.

Have fun with that Vega! Mine does very well for me.

Bill

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

#10

Re: Onesay Stonghold chuck, the right choice?

Fog Tanner

>It all depends on where your interests are. If you do small work, then the smaller chuck is fine. If you do larger pieces, then you need the larger chuck. You can put a large piece of wood in the smaller chuck, but you are asking a lot of both the chuck and the wood. I have come to the conclusion that you really need at least one of each size. Two of each size is better, one for each different jawset would be ideal - but way overkill.

I have two Strongholds with most of the jawsets that fit them. I got the second one was because I was tired of swapping jaws. I used them on everything from small boxes to large bowls on my 16" lathe. I now have a 24" lathe and still use them for some of the bowls.

I started buying Vicmarc chucks after some issues with my Strongholds. I have the little VM90(lever operated) and VM100(key operated). I now use these for smaller boxes and bowls. I also have the VM120 which I use for anything I can fit on my lathe down to some of the larger boxes.

I did not realize how handy the small chucks are for smaller projects until I bough the VM90. I originally got it for use on a threading jig, but started using it for boxes and small bowls. I found it a lot easier to work around than the larger chucks, either the Vic or Stronghold. I got the key operated VM100 when C.S. had sale that I couldn't turn down.

I have moved the lever operated VM90 to my mini, and my primary chucks are the Vics. The size of the piece dictates which one. I use the Strongholds when I need a particular jawset that is mounted in them or the Jumbo jaws for doing the bottom of a bowl.