Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Identifying wood

Posts

Identifying wood

#1

Identifying wood

Bob Macgregor

>We just went through an ice storm that took a lot of branches and trees down (as well as power poles!). Over the next few months, I'll be collecting a lot of the larger pieces for firewood and setting some aside for turning.

When I label my pieces I note the type of wood, but sometimes have to be generic (eg, "maple", where it could be red, silver or sugar; or "birch" where it could be white, yellow, grey). After being stacked all together in the wood pile for six months or a year, I lose track of exactly what kind of wood it was, especially with the maples. Something tells me it should matter--that I should be accurate as to wood species-- but does it really?

What do you think? Should I be more careful and segregate my woodpile better or label the sealed logs?

Re: Identifying wood

#2

Re: Identifying wood

John K Jordan

>>Should I be more careful and segregate my

>woodpile better or label the sealed logs?

Yikes, it might take a lot of different wood piles to segregate them all! A lumber crayon is pretty good for writing on the ends of logs, as long as you do it before applying anchorseal. The bark of some species is so distinctive they don't need labeling (e.g., dogwood, persimmon). It sure is a lot easier to figure the species when looking at the tree. Sometimes in the winter I'll try to find leaves on the ground for ID, and take them back to look up in the books if necessary (especially with maples since I get them confused).

Does recording an accurate species name matter? From what I've seen, many people just make up a species name but that could prove embarrassing. But assuming you like to write the species on a turning, "sugar maple" sounds a lot better than "maple". And "oak" can cover some quite dissimilar woods.

When preparing blanks, I try to write the species on each blank which saves a bunch of trouble trying to figure out/remember much later. Sometimes I keep prepared turning squares in tubs so I write the species on the tub.

JKJ

Re: Identifying wood

#3

Re: I don't get too specific when.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...labeling my finished pieces- just "maple" seem to be specific enough for most buyers.

Re: Identifying wood

#4

Re: Identifying wood

Steven Kubien

>Does it matter? Depends.

.

.

.

.

.

Oh, you wanted more details than that? Sorry... I can see two good reasons for labelling wood or finished pieces as accurately as you can. #1, for your own curiosity. #2, If it helps you sell (ie: your customers like it). For myself, I recognize few species by the wood or bark so I tend to go generic. If I do know the tree, I will be as accurate as I can.

My 2 cents.

Steve Kubien

Re: Identifying wood

#5

Re: Identifying wood

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I label to the same level that hardwood lumber is labeled. Shagbark hickory is just hickory, pecan (a hickory subfamily) is pecan. Pin oak is a member of the red oak group, so it becomes red oak. Wild black cherry is cherry, etc....

Re: Identifying wood

#6

Re: Identifying wood

Emmett Manley

>Most of the wood I use does not require fine point identification -- walnut, persimmon, sweet gum, osage orange, holly, magnolia, cherry, etc. Hickory is hickory. We have only river birch in this area. Maple is usually red maple. If I turn oak, it will be white oak

My rule is to label any wood that is not obvious or is unusual. Do this on the harvest end, because, a year later, memories get fuzzy. When labeling finished items, it is meaningful to add appropriate adjectives, as "wormy persimmon, spalted river birch, fiddleback black walnut, ambrosia maple, etc." Adjectives describe and adjectives sell.

Re: Identifying wood

#7

Re: Bob, doing it your way, opens...

Allen Neighbors

>the door for experiencing miracles. I do the same as you. The other day I sawed up an oak trunk that has been spalting in my pile. When I was turning some of it, it miraculously changed itself into Sweet Gum.

How exciting! :)

Re: Identifying wood

#8

Re: Identifying wood

Bob Macgregor

>Thanks, all, for the suggestions and observations. Most of the species I am likely to turn are the birches and maples, possibly a little cherry or alder and the occasional beech. I may just stick with the generic name, except when I am really, really sure about what I have turned...oh, yes and when the wood also looks like what I was sure it was!