Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

Posts

History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#1

History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

Tony De Masi

>This is a Scarlett Oak bowl which measures 8 3/4 x 1 3/4. Finished with Minwax Antique Oil and then buffed.

The history of the wood is as such. The tree was planted in April of 1860 by the grandson of former President Andrew Jackson on the north grounds of the White House. The tree came down in a storm in late October of 2007 and I was fortunate enough to get some from the National Park Service at the White House.

I wouldn't say this is my best work but nothing I could have done would out do the provenance of the tree.

Some of you may remember a post a while back by Bill Grumbine about this same tree. I'm sure he will do it more justice than I can. At least until I get to take his turning class.

Tony


img

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#2

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>That has to be a keeper. Wright the history on the back.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#3

It must have been an unusual tree

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>Since there only seem to be about forty something annual rings showing.

Not that I am doubting the provenance of your wood, I do have a bit of suspicion about the age, and who might have planted it.

Unless this limb was a sucker which grew from an older branch after pruning, it should have the same number of rings as the rest of tree after it reached the height of this limb. So if it took say, twenty years to grow up to this limb, there should be about 120 rings between the pith and cambium.

Maybe there is more to the wood than what shows in your photos, but the rings of a tree tell a lot about its life story. One of the things that I like about turning, is learning to read that story.

I am not a dendrochronologist, but I have a friend who is, and I have a booklet of his chronologies for my area, and have learned quite a bit from that friend.

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#4

Re: It must have been an unusual tree

Tony De Masi

>All I can tell you is that I was there when the tree was being cut into pieces for removal and I got the information from the National Park Service on the provenance.

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#5

Tony, I am not doubting you.

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I am not doubting what they may have told you nor that a tree was planted in that spot in 1860. It may have lived a good long life of 70 years, then was replaced by this one.

If this is the same tree, and they were to cut it down now. It should have 147 annual rings in its trunk section. If it took 47 years for the tree to get large enough for this limb to begin life as a twig, then there should be 100 annual rings in a cross section of your wood.

All you need to do is count those rings in your limb to get a good idea of how old this limb is. Your photo is a little small for me to count them. Since this is something that I do regularly with my own work, I couldn't help but notice that there doesn't seem to be a high enough count for it to be that old.

Does it make the wood less valuable to know that it may have been planted by Lady Bird, or Pat Nixon?

I would be a little embarrassed if I sold a turning that was supposed to be 150 years old, and the buyer bought it in good faith that it was, but then someone like me came along and pointed out that in reality it was only 50 years old. I would rather know the truth than to make that kind of mistake myself, wouldn't you?

All you need to do is to clean up the end of a cross-section, then: get a magnifying glass, and start counting. I usually put a mark at the end of every ten years, so I can check myself if I want to re-count or loose count part way through.

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#6

Re: The Park Service reps may have .....

Jamie Donaldson

>....had good intentions but bad information. Not unusual in a government bureaucracy like ours.

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

#7

Re: History of the Scarlett Oak Bowl

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Very nice Tony! My share of the wood is sitting next to the bandsaw waiting to be sawn into blanks. I sure don't want it getting mixed up with the firewood pile!

I won't argue with anyone about the actual age of the tree, but I accept the provenance, and I am very grateful to the gentleman who was kind enough to procure the wood for me.

Bill