Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Another Stopper Thought

Posts

Another Stopper Thought

#1

Another Stopper Thought

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have been thinking about those turners who have sold a lot of chrome plated stoppers but have never had a complaint. I never had a complaint either. In fact I would not have known except that my stoppers corroded and my sister's corroded. We are both red wine drinkers. If you sell a lot of stoppers, there is a good chance that if someone had a complaint they would either not know to whom they should complain or they just wouldn't bother. Either way they would not be anxious to buy another.

I told the company from whom I bought those chrome stoppers about the corrosion. Their response was that I was the first one to have a problem. Of course I knew better than that. I might have been the first one to let them know but I hardly think my sister and I were the first to have the problem.

If you drink a whole bottle of wine in the same evening the chrome plated stopper will last forever; it isn't being used. If you drink one glass a night, the stopper is in continuous use and will corrode.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#2

Re: Another Stopper Thought

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Several people have told me they had chrome stoppers that either discolored or corroded over time.

JKJ

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#3

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Bill Crommett

>I had to ditch two of the chrome ones. I think you are on the right track when you say that the disappointed purchasers of the chrome stoppers just resolved not to buy any more shiny stoppers. It is a little like trying to get a refund from a failed newspaper box, not worth the trouble.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#4

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Norm Smith

>Barbara, Do you think that there might be the slightest possibility that there may be some chrome stoppers that do not corrode. That is to say that some may be of better quality than others? I have sold hundreds locally to family and friends with no complants.

Since the last posting about stoppers I have received Email from folks that tell me that they havent had a problem but didnt want to post it because they do not want to be critized or ganged up on. Me, I speak my mind and dont care. There seems to be a group here that is determined to promote Ruths stoppers.

Norm

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#5

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I would think that most of the chrome stoppers would come from only several manufactures but maybe not. So sure there is always that possibility.

Ganged up on? That is silly. It reminds me of high school mentality. I certainly didn't see any sign of that happening in the thread below. It is not necessarily a right or wrong issue. If they have something to say they should, just like you did.

Personally I am thrilled with the stainless stoppers Ruth developed. They solved several problems that the older chrome presented including the height issue. Because of that satisfaction people who use them like to promote them.

Before Ruth started having her stoppers made I had switched to the neoprene(?) ones that fit on a dowel. It always worried me that the rubber/neoprene might come off when the stopper was pulled out of a bottle. Sure enough I got an e-mail from someone who had that happen. Fortunately they let me know about it so I could make compensation.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#6

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Carole Valentine

>Huh? Everyone tends to promote products that they feel are good, but that doesn't mean they are going to beat someone up just because they don't think the same way! Do I promote WC business folks if they have a good product? Yes, I do and I am happy to do it. In fact, I will promote any product that I think is good. The testimonials to Niles Stoppers are just that - endorsements of a good product. I don't get a discount for saying that either. ;))

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#7

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Barry Turner

>I bought one of Ruth's stoppers at the TAW Symposium yesterday in Nashville. I wanted to try them out. I got the threaded version. Has anyone tried the version with no threads, just a tenon that is glued in place? I'm a bit worried about getting those threads snugged up. I dense wood, it can be a real chore to thread the chrome ones into the wood. Sometimes, I slip the rubber gasket back and use pliers on the portion of the cone that is under the rubber.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#8

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Jose Klipstein -Cleveland OH

>In the past five or six years I have made well over a thousand bottle stoppers using the chrome kits from Berea Hardwoods. I haven't had a single complaint. I sell primarily through a local gallery. I have been told by the owner that several customers return regularly to purchase these stoppers for their own use and as gifts.

Jose

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#9

Re: Another Stopper Thought

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Has anyone tried the version with no threads,

>just a tenon that is glued in place?

I've only made a few so far, but that's the only kind I've used. I used epoxy on the shaft and a little on the flat. (I turned a shallow recess into the bottom to fit the top of the stopper so a bit of glue there will be hidden.)

The photo is of the first one I made, the wood is pink flame (I posted this once before). I love the weight and balance of these as well as the look.

JKJ


img

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#10

Re: Another Stopper Thought

john lucas

>Barry I've only made a dozen of Ruth's stoppers. They were all the straight shank version.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#11

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Norm Smith

>Barbarsa, read the first paragraph of your first post and the last paragraph of your second post.

I and lots of others on this site often give a heads up or promote a product that they use and like. There is nothing wrong with that. But to continually promote a product and bad mouth a competing product in the same thread is wrong. Ruths stoppers are probably the best on the market, there is no denying that but there are a lot of people in businesses large and small that sell chrome wine stoppers. You are hurting those people. If you want to promote a product , go for it but dont try to hurt others in the process.

Norm

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#12

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Nick Tuzzolino

>I use Ruth Niles' stoppers. After a while, the rubber or (neoprene probably) gets a little sticky. A quick rinse and wipe with warm water solves the problem. I have used several dozen as giveaways. No complaints.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#13

Norm, you're not being fair to Barbara

Ruth Niles

>Sorry, Norm, but you really aren't being fair because Barbara is not trying to hurt other businesses and she did not "bad mouth" but posted a warning about a material used for an item that comes in contact with a food. Here is a picture sent to me by a customer.

If you've turned thousands of chrome-plated stoppers and have never had any complaints, that's great. Seriously. Not every chrome-plated stopper will pit or corrode. And thank you for complementing my design.

There are only a few importers of the chrome-plated stoppers, most catalog supply places, Woodcraft stores or others purchase them from one of the importers and they are all made in the same factory in China.

There are other stainless steel stoppers on the market, Arizona Sillhouette sells one that is actually made from a higher quality ss than mine (his will not break down for 15,000 yrs., mine will break down in 3,000 yrs.!). Craft Supplies has a ss stopper with a lower profile, not as low as mine, no one seems to know what grade stainless but stainless non the less.

Here is a link to a glass supply catalog, same chrome-plated stoppers, buys from the importer out of Phila., same factory in China. You might find it interesting that he posts a caveat for the chrome stoppers and this is printed on every box with the stopper. This is Aanraku glass, on the "online store" page and stoppers.

https://abasg.siteturn.com/mm5/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Store_Code=ASC&Category_Code=WBS

I'm definitely not putting down any other business, if you're happy with whatever product you're using, that's wonderful. When I went to buy my Ford station wagon, all my friends told me I'd have nothing but problems, I bought it, don't have problems and would buy another one. Same thing. Doesn't mean they can't keep telling me how much trouble they've had with Ford. : )


img

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#14

One wino's opinion.....

Rick Davenport

>Chrome is pretty hard stuff.

There should be no problem with it being exposed to wine unless there is a flaw in the finish and it gets under the chrome plating.

Even then it has to be sitting in the wine for quite some time.

If that's the case, does that mean people open a bottle and stopper it while it's still full?

If anything, you should let a red wine breath for awhile, ideally decanting it into another container.

Wine changes character rather rapidly when exposed to oxygen.

After just a few hours, it's not as good as it once was and after a few days, it's kinda lame.

If people keep opened wine that long, they should get a vacuum pump stopper to remove the oxygen.

For me, the t handle stopper/corkscrews outsell straight stoppers 4 to 1.

I tell them it's the perfect picnic tool to open the wine AND keep the ants out.

Having said that, the next time I reload on stoppers, I will probably purchase Ruth's.

My rule of thumb: always go for top quality.

That way you can be proud of what you offer and have no guilt about charging top dollar.

R

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#15

You are stretching it Ruth.

Norm Smith

>Warning about a product that comes in contact with food, come on , it a wine bottle stopper.

When a person continually critizes or bad mouths a product on a forum such as this, they are hurting others. It is one thing to give a heads up on a bad product. That is fine, but when you are promoting another persons SS stopper ,not all SS stoppers, but your stoppers in the same thread , that is wrong, regardless of how you look at it. You say that you are not critizing your competition but than post a photo of a defective stopper. I spent my life in my own business and one thing that I learned early on was , do not bad mouth your competition.

Ruth, I think that your stoppers are great and I sincerely wish you well in your business. I admire people that get into their own business.

This subject is being blown way out proportion and this is the last time that I will address it.

Re: Another Stopper Thought

#16

Re: Another Stopper Thought

Barry Irby

>I have made between 25 and 50 stoppers, all were Ruth's with a smooth shank. I was a little distrusting of the smooth shank and so I either filed a few notches in it or roughed it up with coarse sandpaper to give the glue something to physically engage. I have used both medium CA and Epoxy. (If I am doing one or two, I use CA because it is quick and handy, if I am doing a bunch I may use the epoxy. Not real sure why, but that's what I did and both worked.)

The club just made a purchase and I participated, That batch was threaded and I have not used any of them yet. I may just drill the hole full sized and use epoxy, treating the threads as notches. Or I may thread the hole with a tap, or I may drill the hole very slightly under sized and let the stopper thread the hole and use some glue. I would be more worried about splitting the wood, unless I were careful. Would not want to drill the hole for the root size of the treads and then try to force the stopper to fully thread it.