More experimenting with shape and form on large vessels. This piece is Spalted Red Maple Burl and is 13" high x 9"dia x 1/8" wall. The collar has a 1 �� opening and the base is 1 3/4� dia. I try to hide the base by bringing the catenary curve all the way around the bottom then cut in the base.
The max diameter is above center at 7 �� height point. I think the piece would have been better with the max diameter higher? I applied 6 coats of Waterlox to darken the light areas and the black lines. Please comment on shape & form etc.
>Andy, once again some beautiful wood and the finish does it real justice. On the form I'm going to have to say it's too oval. It seems to just go straight down and stop.
>Andy, I think we are our own worst critics, sometimes. As far as the wood is concerned, I think it's just beautiful. For the form... I think if you look at the old master's (DE) forms, you'll see that this one is as pretty as any of his. Carrying the curve all the way through the bottom was nice work. Could you have shaped it differently? Yes. But why? Just because the rules say so? I think not. This one is beautiful. Form and finish. My .02.
With all due respect to Cyril's comment, I have to say that for me, the form is fine. I don't believe in cookie-cutter shapes. This one is very pleasing to my eye, and I like to believe that I am discriminating, if untrained.
Thanks for the compliments. Yes, I am my own worst critic. I do think the piece is a little to oval but I still really like it. The splated wood is exceptional and I was a little disappointed about the shape. A
year ago I would have been happy to even make a piece like that one.