Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

scratches and finishing

Posts

scratches and finishing

#1

scratches and finishing

Mark Paulley

>Hello all,

I need to some help with the finishing process. I sand my pieces and it appears I get all of the scrathces out from the previous sand paper grit. However I no sooner apply my finish (deft cut 50/50)and a few scrathes appear. I use a clean soft paper towl and the scratches do not appear to be from the paper.

Is there a method/ process that can help me eliminate these scratches I can't seem to see until I apply finish?

Getting a bit frustrated with trying to finish a nice bowl!!!!

Thank for any and all help

Mark

Re: scratches and finishing

#2

Re: scratches and finishing

Barry Elder

>Man, do I remember saying the same thing!!?? After getting some help from my mentor and a couple of other turners, I googled sanding and finishing and read up on the subject for two or three weeks, and practiced for a couple of months, practiced yoga and meditation for a couple of months, and finally discovered that all the older more experienced guys know that patience is the key.

Re: scratches and finishing

#3

Re: scratches and finishing

Bruce Forrest

>You might try wiping the piece with mineral spirits. Or try taking a picture or two and looking at them. This is an application of Murphy's Law. (Scratches will never show up until the piece is completely finished.) Or just blowing off the sawdust and inspecting very closely in a good light.

Re: scratches and finishing

#4

Check the articles in "Russ's Corner" *LINK*

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The articles section of this site has a section called "Russ's Corner" which contains much sage advice from Russ Fairfield. The multi-part article on finishing is very good.


Russ's Corner - Finishing Secrets

Re: scratches and finishing

#5

Re: scratches and finishing

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Buy quality sandpaper from the same manufacturer. I happen to use Klingspore J-Flex. Use all grits, don't skip a grit size. The rougher grits take longer to sand out the previous scratches. Keep the sanding material moving while in contact with the wood and have a light hand. Blow off the work between grit change. It does not help much to move to a finer grit if there is residual grit from the prior sanding material still on the wood. Do not exceed 900 rpm while sanding. You may want to spritz water on the wood at about 400 grit let it dry before proceeding. This will raise the grain and you will get a better finish. Sand to 600.

Between each grit change blow off the wood and inspect what you have done. If you think there any scratches from previous grain size just hand sand across the scratches and if they go away you are OK. If not go back a grit and do it again.

Be patient and don't get the wood hot.

Treat sandpaper as if someone else was paying for it. Don't over use it

Good turning and be safe

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: scratches and finishing

#6

Re: scratches and finishing

john lucas

>Bill covered it well. I had the same problem when I moved to my new shop. I decided it was mostly lighting. I use a smaller light held at a pretty extreme angle to inspect the piece to look for scratches.

Blowing the dust off and/or wiping with Naptha also helps find the scratches. They are often filled with sanding dust from the previous grit. Mineral spirits work well also but takes long to evaporate.

Re: scratches and finishing

#7

Re: scratches and finishing-Thanks for the info

Mark Paulley

>To all who responded to my plea for help, a big THANKS.

I will try all of your suggestions. Thanks for suggesting several different process and methods.

THANKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Mark

Re: scratches and finishing

#8

Re: scratches and finishing

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I agree with John about the lighting. If the light is too diffuse (for example, wide fluorescents) the scratches are too evenly illuminated to see. A strong point source light is the best, but a bright bulb in a fixture also works. Holding the light at a glancing angle to the wood keeps the scratch shadowed and easier to see. I mount one light fixture with a magnetic base behind the lathe where I can tilt it up and turn it on only when needed.

I also sand as much or more with the lathe turned off as on, finishing up each grit by sanding with the grain and/or figure. This makes it easier to tell if the scratches from the last grit are gone.

JKJ

Re: scratches and finishing

#9

The ultimate light for seeing scratches

Carole Valentine

>is the original one - bright sunlight. If you don't see any scratches while turning the piece out side in bright sunlight, you are good to go.

Re: scratches and finishing

#10

Re: The ultimate light for seeing scratches

Barry Irby

>I agree with all of the above. Especially about the light. I have lots of four foot fluorescents in my shop for general lighting. They are awful for finding scratches. The light strikes me as sort of soft diffuse and fuzzy. I also have a similar opinion of LED lights. They seem to be gray and fuzzy to me. (Is that just me?)

Blow it off to get rid of the larger grit and dust packed in the scratches, wet it, look at in the sun and use sand paper like you stole it.

Re: scratches and finishing

#11

Re: scratches and finishing *LINK*

Jack Savona

>Good advice given by all, especially on the lighting. Magnification will really help, too. I also beall buff my bowls before applying any finish.


Sample of Magnifiers

Re: scratches and finishing

#12

Richard Allen

Re: scratches and finishing

Richard Allen

>Lighting and magnification help a LOT. To get a better look you might remove the workpiece from the lathe for a final inspection in good light and with magnification. You can keep the workpiece in the chuck for this inspection. Being able to manipulate the workpiece in all directions in front of your eyes will help a lot.

Us this as a learning process. Once you find a scratch or two you will be able to find those scratches on the lathe. As you become more accustom to seeing the previously invisable scratches when mounted on the lathe you will have less cause to inspect the workpiece off the lathe.

Re: scratches and finishing

#13

Question re lighting

Dinyar Chavda

>There have been lots of suggestions re using good lighting, both here and in earlier threads on general lighting. Most fixtures restrict one to less than 60 or 75w. I've tried using various types of bulbs, and have not been very satisfied, either for sanding purposes, or as supplements to fluorescents for spot lights from the ceiling.

My question is what lightbulbs do people recommend? May I request that you be as specific as possible in your recommendations?

Thanks.

Dinyar

Re: scratches and finishing

#14

Re: Dinyar- recently I saw a really nice....

Jamie Donaldson

>...Q/H fixture that hangs over the lathe bed, but don't remember where I saw the ad? I do not have one, but have worked under one somewhere- 2 Q/H lamps in a metal tube with a lamp situated at each end behind a protective grid. As I recall it was priced less than $50, and that easily fits the phrugal turner's budget. Anyone remember where this fixture could be purchased?

Re: scratches and finishing

#15

Reflector bulbs

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use incandescent reflector bulbs, the type used for track lighting. I prefer spotlight bulbs, but I'm using up a batch of flood bulbs right now. Specifically, 50W and 65W indoor reflector bulbs.

I do not and will not use halogen bulbs - the strobe effect is too nasty.

Re: scratches and finishing

#16

Re: scratches and finishing

eliot d

>Everything that's been said is good advice. But I have taken a new direction in my sanding , and I wish I had discovered it earlier. There were several posts here about the method, posted by, (I think ) Bill Nedow(?). Anyway, the method goes against the grain of most turners, who power sand with both the lathe and their power sander turning slowly. The method I now like best uses extremely fast lath speed and power sanding speed -- using an angle grinder-- and an extremely light touch. (Three 'extremely"s'.) I also use only AstroDot sanding disks from Woodchuckers in Canada, using gits up to 1000. You won't see and sanding scratches; and the process is very fast.

Re: scratches and finishing

#17

Re:rian- strobe effects from Q/H bulbs????

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: scratches and finishing

#18

You bet!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I initially had a 2-bulb quartz halogen fixture over my lathe. Very, very annoying strobe effect.

Ever watch the rain at night in the beam of a Q/H light? Or watched a moth flutter through the beam?

Re: scratches and finishing

#19

Re: This is the first reference I've ever heard...

Jamie Donaldson

>... regarding such?

Re: scratches and finishing

#20

Re: This is the first reference I've ever heard...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>It came up on the AAW forum last fall some time.

Also, it might be like monitor flicker. Some people are more sensitive to it than others.

Re: scratches and finishing

#21

flicker vertigo, halogen flicker?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Flicker vertigo from lights through a spinning propeller (such as when landing into the sun) has been known to cause nausea, disorientation, and even unconsciousness in extreme cases. I imagine unconsciousness would be detrimental to landing an airplane! I once experienced mild symptoms looking through a prop with the engine at idle.

I've also never heard of flickering halogen lamps. Since halogen lamps are incandescent and produce light with a white-hot filament, it's hard to imagine how they can produce significant high-frequency flicker. Is this flicker observed in halogens electronically pulsed with a control circuit such as a dimmer?

I did a brief google search on flickering halogen lights and found only the statement "When using the high-current halogen bulb it is important to keep the switch contacts clean or light flickering will result". In fact, I read several recommendations to replace fluorescents with halogen to eliminate flicker. I'm going to do a strobe test with some halogens I have here.

JKJ

Re: scratches and finishing

#22

Re: halogen flicker?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I was rather surprised myself because I didn't expect any strobe effect. The fixture I was using had two 150 watt bulbs in it and the strobe effect was much sharper than the old fluorescent tube flicker.

A couple of years ago I was sitting on a friend's porch one evening. They use a 500 W halogen fixture to light up the yard. A luna moth was fluttering in the beam of the light. Except it was stuttering and jumping. We both noticed it and agreed that it was a strobe effect. (BTW, he's a high school physics and chemistry teacher, I'm a retired R&D science type.)

Re: scratches and finishing

#23

Re:In AC theory I understand....

Jamie Donaldson

>... that there could be a potential for some flicker, but in the physics of an incandescent bulb element it would be hard to see under normal circumstances? Same idea with scan lines of a CRT TV, but not visable to the human eye. I've worked with lighting as a photographer for more than 40 yrs. and never noticed any Q/H flicker, so I'm not going to worry about potential theoretical problems now!

Re: scratches and finishing

#24

Re: halogen flicker?

John K Jordan

>>...I'm a retired R&D science type

No, it was actually the rare multi-dimensional flicker moth that toggles rapidly back and forth between alternate universes when illuminated with light of a certain frequency.

As another retired R&D science type, your information makes me want to experiment even more. I have a variety of halogen light fixtures here, including the exterior tube types, floods, and small bulbs. I think spinning a strobe disk on the VS lathe would show any flicker effect.

BTW, in the unusual department, I once noticed a discrete visual effect with, of all things, a chemical light source! A friend was spinning a cyalume light stick on the end of a string in the dark - I forget the color of the light stick but it may have been blue. I noticed a discrete afterimage a few degrees wide about 1/3 of the way around the arc following the light stick. The afterimage was a different color from the light stick. (And no, there was no other chemical substance in use at the time!) I've asked people schooled in various sciences about this over the years and no one had a clue. My best guess so far is the rods in the eye had some type of delayed response to the primary light trigger.

JKJ

Re: scratches and finishing

#25

That's the test I'd do. Let us know the results.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>