Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Posts

In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#1

In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The only really safe hollowing tools are captive tools, such as the Jamieson and others. That's because they are not hand held.

The arm brace tool was designed to give better control to the turner when a catch occurs, than can be had with the more convenional straight handled tools. Most big catches happen when control of the tool is lost when a small catch occurs.

Ellis's post yeaterday told us how he lost control of his tool, resulting in an injury. I strongly feel that had he been using an arm brace tool, he'd have been better able to keep the tool under control.

I've heard stories of serious injuries that have occured when using an arm brace tool. Can anybody really verify one?

I have been using a Dennis Stewart arm brace tool since 1987 and have turned many hundreds of hollow vessels with it. Along the way I've had serious catches,(doesn't everybody?) especially when using the tool in deep vessels. I can recall having a big one at least a couple of times, resulting in a broken bowl and a sore arm for a couple of days. In every case, it was result a of carelessly holding the tool loosely, so that I momentarily lost control. I'm certain that had I been using a tool with a conventional handle, I'd have been more seriously injured, because I'd have completely lost control of the tool. When using any tool by extending it a long way beyond the tool rest, a small catch can, in an instant develop into a large bowl busting, arm wrenching catch. When using the arm brace tool, it is much easier to maintain control of the tool, helping to eliminate those big catches.

The regular hooker bar for the Stewart tool is 14 inches long. When he came out with a 21 inch bar I bought one. I used it on a few deep vessels but found it scary to use. For the deeper pieces I now use a Nichols captive tool.

I teach classes in a woodshop where we have 7 Woodfast lathes, some of them shortbed lathes. The on-off switch is located below the headstock, making it impossible to turn the lathe off when hollowing a vessel. For that reason I don't allow the students to turn vessels with openings so small that they can't safely remove the tool with the lathe running. A remote control would be a great addition.

Wally

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#2

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

GaryG in MD

>Wally,

It's good to hear your further thoughts on this. I've got a Don Pencil Scorpion w/ arm brace that I like to use, and the previous post was causing me to doubt the safety factor. Your points seem valid, and one can't discount you years of experience.

What would you estimate as your dividing line between hand held and constrained hollowers in terms of the overhang distance from the tool rest, say with a 3/4" bar?

...Gary

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#3

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools.... *LINK*

JohnKJordan in East TN

>The eighth message down in this thread mentions a way to hold the arm brace to avoid shoulder injury. (I personally have no experience in this.)


hollowing thread

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#4

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

john lucas

>Wally I mentioned the one bad catch that I've had since using the armbrace but there have been many smaller ones that didn't do anything but iritate me. I switched to the armbrace because it hurt my wrist to use a straight handle for very long. I'm not sure what I do different when I'm hollowing vs regular turning but the Arm Brace relieved the pain.

I am going to borrow one of John Jordan's handles from a friend to see if that is more comfortable.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#5

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Russ Fairfield

>I have never thought the arm-brace was inherently unsafe. Rather, I have always thought of the Arm-Brace as being a safer tool because it was an extension of my arm, making some motions more natural than with a hand-held handles tool. Used correctly, the Arm-Brace is like having a long finger, rather than holding a separate tool in my hand. Being an extension of my arm, there is better a better feeling of where the tip is and what it is doing. Going in and out of a hollow form through a small hole is one of these places where the long finger is definitely the safer tool.

I think the problem with the arm-brace is in how people use it. Reaching way out over the lathe bed is not a good way to control any tool, and the arm-brace is no different. Keeping the tool handle, and the arm holding the Arm-Brace, in next to our body gives us much better control of the tool and adds our body weight to resist cutting forces. That is why a short bed lathe or a sliding head is the better choice for hollowing. It is also why some woodturners with long bed lathes sit on the lathe bed like it was a horse when using hollowing tools. It is also a good reason for being able to standing on the other side of the lathe.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#6

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Clay Foster

>"It is also a good reason for being able to standing on the other side of the lathe."

Or turn in reverse if the faceplate has a set screw that will keep the faceplate from coming off..

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#7

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Clay Foster

>I agree, Wally. I don't think an arm brace handle is any more dangerous than any other turning tool, including captured tools. No tool is idiot proof because idiots are so ingenious.

One advantage of the arm brace handle that hasn't been mentioned is the ergonomic design is much less likely to cause carpal tunnel problems. When you grab the handle, your hand is still at it's natural angle to your arm. A gorilla grip on a straight handle turning tool is one of the most efficient ways in the world to acquire carpal tunnel problems.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#8

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Yeah, but for some of us, a normal grip is a gorilla grip. :-) I have yanked my share of pieces off the lathe when the tool would have come spinning out of most peoples' hand.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#9

Re: I began using the Stewart handle....

Jamie Donaldson

>... years ago because of the therapeutic relief it provided for my tendonitis. I made a few different tool shafts to fit, and it is still my preferred tool system for most hollowing. I can achieve a better sense of control and feel with this tool, and some of my preference may be based on the experience I have gained hollowing with this method. I do sometimes do the roughing out with variations of the Jamieson D handle, but the Stewart handle is the fine tuning tool of choice.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#10

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Barry Irby

>I'm just worried that this falls into the "something's got to give" category.

In the case of a catch or even a heavy cut or when the hollow form sills with shavings and it gets a really good grip on the tool, (none of which should happen, but sometimes do), something has got to give.

All of us have seen and experienced many catches that ended with out serious injury to the piece or the turner. Sometimes they are worse.

If we keep upping the ante, what is the next thing to give? The piece comes out of the chuck or the screws in the faceplate turn loose, the belt on the lathe slips, the lathe stops, the tool breaks or what? Somehow, we need to realize that we are part of the system and the equipment does not care where the failure occurs. It only takes once.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#11

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Roger Smith

>My first class was with Larry Hasiak using a Stewart tool. Larry stands on the backside of the lathe and turns left handed. This allows you to keep the tool firmly against your body. I think this may also be safer as a catch turning right-handed will begin to take your arm and rotate it away from your side. Left-handed and you still have your body to help.

Also not all hooker tools are the same. Some of them have the cutting tip extended passed the center line of the tool shaft and are more likely to catch. The tool rest should be far enough away that the shaft is resting on it and not the swan-neck part.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#12

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I use the Scorpion armbrace for my hollowing forms that are larger than minis. I feel I have more stability and control with it than using a straight handled tool. It is really comfortable and I enjoy using it. I have had a few catches, but nothing serious has happened other than destroying the opening I hollowing through. It may be that I just haven't been turning long enough or made enough dumb mistakes to have experienced the degree of catches others have described.

keithz

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#13

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Gary, it's difficult to come up with an answer that fits all conditions. Of course much of it depends on the experience of the turner. The piece of wood being turned can be an easy one or it can be a difficult one. It makes a difference if You're turning a tall slim piece or a shorter fat one. Perhaps I'm not as sure of my ability to handle a tool deep in a piece as I once was. I get a bit nervous when I'm turning beyond 12 inches deep. I switch to my Nichols system, usually before I get that deep.

Wally

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#14

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I feel the same way Russ. I do get the feeling that the tool is an extension of my arm which gives better control. I have my lathe spindle height higher than most because I want to stand naturally, facing the piece when I'm hollowing. Anything else will affect the safety. The advent of shortbed lathes, sliding headstocks etc. have made hollowing a lot safer and easier.

It seems to me that the pistol grip as used on the arm brace is a much more natural way to hold a tool than a conventional handle.

Wally

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#15

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Allen Neighbors

>I have a Don Pencil Scorpion, and I love it. I modified the cradle as suggested, by squeezing it a little to make it more snug on my skinny arm.

I also turn from the off side of the lathe most of the time with this tool, which makes it more comfortable to me. My Spindle height is 49".

I've never had a catch... yeah right... :) Really, though, I've never had a catch that gave me any discomfort using the Scorpion.

However, this poor thing has been lonely since I built the captured system. :)

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#16

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Wally -- yeah, I think I'll quit around 9", at least until I get a lot more experience. ...Gary

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#17

Re: Arm Brace Tools....my system

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>Here is a Pic of my system. I made 2 added bars that can be used with the DS arm brace or with the Jamieson System. The long bar is 64" long and 1 1/4" Dia. SS and very heavy. I use it either free hand or in the arm brace. But not for very long at a time.

Bill


img

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#18

Re: Arm Brace Tools....my system

eliot d

>You know, it all depends on who you talk to. I once mentioned to John Jordan that I was worried about his style of using an arm brace because I didn't want to end up on the ceiling. He made a motion of griping an imaginary arm brace and pulling his arm very close to his side, saying,"Not if you hold it like this." Then, of course, there's the whole school of constrained rigs. Then there's David Ellsworth, who uses no brace nor rig, and even advocates not having the cutting tip in line with the axis of the tool because he wants the tool to twist away from the wood at the slightest catch. I mentioned this philosophy to Jameison, ( who was selling his rig) and he said to take a look at Ellsworth sometime when he's turning and you'd see his neck muscles straining. (I did, and didn't see any strain.) My self, I use the Ellsworth style near the opening around the shoulder and switch to a modified ElboTool once inside. I have never had a dangerous catch, but I have gone through the sides a few times when using the laser systems -- almost always because the laser light sliped a bit relative to the cutting edge.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#19

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for the reality check, Wally

Ellis Walentine

>My post wasn't intended to discourage the use of arm brace tools, but rather to raise awareness of what I still see as a potential danger and a call for more caution. I know I will be more cautions from now on. Once bit, twice shy.

I'm glad (and somewhat reassured) to hear other's opinions on this.

Ellis

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#20

Ellis, you did us a service...

GaryG in MD

>Thinking about SAFETY is something that we can never get too much of.

These two threads have emphasized the need to keep ones elbow in tight to the body when using an arm brace -- even if you have to sit on the lathe or work from the back side. I think that's perhaps the most important thing I'm going to remember out of all this. Thanks for starting it. ...Gary

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#21

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

charlie b

>In response to the request for a verifiable incident of serious injury due to an arm brace tool - the president of Silicon Valley Woodturners had a bad catch using one - and the resulting shoulder injury required surgery to correct. He turns on a full sized Stubby, turns mainly green wood - but big pieces of wet wood - and once roughed to round he cranks up the speed in the 2-3K rpms.

If you're doing an accident survey e-mail me and I'll pass it on to Rich.

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#22

Re: Thanks for the reality check, Wally

charlie belden

>I'm looking at the physics of this thing and put the attachment together to illustrate the forces and movements involved.

If you turn "from the backside", the top part of the illustration is only partially correct - the forces are correct - but having your arm locked into your hip will let you use that bone and your body weigth to resist the rotation caused by the catch.

The second part of the illustration is true regardless of which side of the lathe you're standng on.


img

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#23

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>He hollows at 2/3K RPMS and the tool is being blamed for a serious accident? That was a serious accicent waiting to happen. If I have an accident while driving at 120 MPH I'm going to be killed. If I have a fender bender at moderate speeds I probably will receive a few bruises.

Wally

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools....

#24

Re: In Defense of Arm Brace Tools.... *LINK*

charlie belden

>Clarification:

He finish turns at 2-3K. Obviously, that speed range would be insane for roughing and initial hollowing. He does mainly natural edged stuff now. But he's done many other types of turning over the years including hollow forms with very small neck openings. I suspect that having a beefy lathe like the Stubby or VB36 would tempt one to turn BIG. Big turning, big forces.

I'll be seeing him Wednesday and will ask for specifics on his Arm Brace accident. Will report back the details.

Another member of the club turns BIG - and as far as I know, he uses regular handles gouges. See first pic on the attached page.


Turning BIG and Deep